"Crimes without Any Punishment at All": Dostoevsky and Woody Allen in Light of Bakhtinian Theory
Olga Stuchebrukhov
2012-04-01
Abstract:Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment has had its share of adaptations, imitations, and parodies in literature and film both in Russia and around the world. In "Caning of Modernist Profaners: Parody in Despair" Aleksandr Dolinin discusses several of them in the context of Russian writers' problematic attitude toward Dostoevsky's legacy during the turn of the twentieth century. His discussion includes Ivan Bunins short story "Looped Ears" (1916) that debunks, among other things, Dostoevsky's treatment of crime. Bunin thus ridicules Dostoevsky's highbrow murderer, Raskolnikov, and the prostitute with the heart of gold, Sonia Marmeladov, in the characters of Sokolovich and Korolkova: The murderer Sokolovich and the prostitute Korol'kova, his victim, - are the grim travesties of Raskolnikov and Sonia lacking any redeeming moral aspects of their models. Bunins hero is just a naturally born serial killer, a blood-thirsty monster, who murders women for no philosophical or ideological reason but for the sheer fun of the act; the prostitute is just a dumb, greedy and lusty slut with an indecent nickname referring to her pudenda, a professional who sells her body thoughdessly and eagerly. (Dolinin)1 Dismissing Dostoevsky's classic, Bunins Sokolovich provides his own philosophy of murder: "It is time to abandon the fairy tale about pangs of conscience, about those horrors which supposedly haunt the murderer. Enough of lies about killers shuddering from the sight of blood. Enough of writing novels about crimes with their punishments; it is rime to write about crime without any punishment at all ..." (qtd. in Dolinin). By inverting crime and punishment to crime without any punishment at all, Bunin himself purports to correct Dostoevsky's supposed idealism, providing instead a more realistic portrayal of human criminality. In a similar striving for realism, in Crimes and Misdemeanors (1989) and Match Point (2005), Woody Alien, like Bunin, removes the punishment from the crime-andpunishment scenario, which leads one of the movie critics to conclude that Match Point "is Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment - without the punishment" (Fibbs). The film's main character, Chris Wilton, just like Judah Rosenthal from Crimes and Misdemeanors, commits murder for no philosophical or ideological reason. At the same time, neither he, nor Judah, is a bloodthirsty monster like Bunin's Sokolovich; instead, both characters embody the banality of evil and commit murder solely to protect their lives of wealth and privilege. Despite some brief post-murder anxiety, at the end, both characters' lives return to normal. In "Deconstructing Dostoevsky: God, Guilt, and Morality in Woody Alien's Crimes and Misdemeanors? Ronald LeBlanc argues that Alien not merely deconstructs Dostoevsky, he also "provides ... a reconstructive extension or furtherance of [his] oeuvre" by "updating" his existential concerns for the postmodern age (99). In doing so, argues LeBlanc, he also pays homage to the Bakhtinian "polyphonic, dialogic nature of [Dostoevsky s] narrative art" (99) and, for these reasons, can be called an "American Dostoevsky" (96). I would argue quite the opposite, however, that, in Bakhtinian terms, Alien's "deconstruction/ reconstruction" of Dostoevsky 's classic in both Crimes and Misdemeanors and Match Point does not further Dostoevsky s existential issues or artistic method, but significantly trivializes them. In Problems of Dostoevsky s Poetics, Mikhail Bakhtin describes Dostoevsky s art as dialogic because "at the center of [his] artistic world must lie dialogue" of a special kind, dialogue as communion (252). An extralinguistic experience, it engages "characters-personalities"2 together with their "worldview and fate" (293). About Dostoevsky 's hero Bakhtin writes: "He invests his entire self in discourse, and this discourse enters into the dialogic fabric of human life, into the world symposium" (293). By the world symposium, he means a communion of fully valid, autonomous, dialogically linked voices, "singing variously on a single theme" which creates an open-ended internal concord instead of a closed-off external unity (Grossman, qtd. …
Law,Philosophy