Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to identify the data elements that social network sites (SNS) users consider important for shaping their digital identity and explore how users’ privacy concerns, self-esteem and the chosen SNS shape this process. Design/methodology/approach This study conducted an online survey with the participation of 759 individuals, to examine the influence of privacy concerns, self-esteem and the chosen SNS platform, on the shaping of the digital identity, through a classification of identity elements that users disclose when using a SNS, the Rosenberg self-esteem scale and relevant constructs from the literature. Findings Findings reveal that users consider the name, gender, picture, interests and job as most important elements for shaping their digital identity. They also demonstrate that privacy concerns do not seem to affect the amount of information users choose to publish when shaping their digital identity. Specific characteristics of SNS platforms are found to affect the way that users shape their digital identity and their privacy behavior. Finally, self-esteem was found to affect privacy concerns and digital identity formation. Research limitations/implications To avoid a lengthy questionnaire and the risk of low participation, the respondents answered the questions for one SNS of their choice instead of answering the full questionnaire for each SNS that they use. The survey included the most popular SNSs at the time of the survey in terms of popularity. Practical implications The results contribute to the theory by furthering our knowledge on the elements that shape digital identity and by providing evidence with regard to the role of privacy and self-esteem within social networking. In practice, they can be useful for SNS providers, as well as for entities that design security and privacy awareness campaigns. Originality/value This paper identifies novel factors that influence digital identity formation, including the specific SNS used with its particular characteristics in combination with privacy concerns and self-esteem of the user.

The privacy paradox in the context of online social networking: A self‐identity perspective

Data Privacy: from Transparency to Fairness

When Facebook Becomes a Part of the Self: How Do Motives for Using Facebook Influence Privacy Management?

Beyond the Individual Privacy Paradigm: Implications for Interpersonal Interactions on Facebook

Privacy helplessness on social media: its constituents, antecedents and consequences

Conceptualizing Online Social Networking Privacy Concerns

Identity construction on Facebook: Digital empowerment in anchored relationships

Transformative privacy calculus: Conceptualizing the personalization‐privacy paradox on social media

Self-disclosure under social networking sites: a risk-utility decision model

Imagined Communities: Awareness, Information Sharing, and Privacy on the Facebook

Beyond lazy; external locus of control as an alternative explanation for the privacy paradox

A Critical Take on Privacy in a Datafied Society

Factors Affecting Privacy Disclosure on Social Network Sites: an Integrated Model

Information privacy and correlates: an empirical attempt to bridge and distinguish privacy-related concepts

SG-PAC: A Stochastic Game Approach to Generate Personal Privacy Paradox Access-Control Policies in Social Networks

Seeing the Forest and the Trees: a Meta-Analysis of the Antecedents to Online Self-Disclosure

Theoretical conceptualization of online privacy-related decision making - Introducing the tripartite self-disclosure decision model

We Care About Different Things: Non-Elite Conceptualizations of Social Media Privacy

Fair privacy: how college students perceive fair privacy protection in online datasets

Forming digital identities in social networks: the role of privacy concerns and self-esteem

Protection or Cynicism? Dual Strategies for Coping with Privacy Threats