Abstract:Radical/extremist Islamist actors use social media to disseminate uncompromising stories of monist religious political orders and identities. As a reaction, counter-movements to online Islamist radicalism/extremism emerged in Western societies (and beyond), while uncertainty about effective outcomes remains widespread. In a bid to understand how inclusionary and exclusionary discursive spaces are created, we ask: How do some Muslim actors create discursive spaces open to self-reflection, pluralism and liberal-democratic principles, while others construct illiberal, particularistic and non/anti-democratic spaces? To respond to this question, we compare two contrasting storytellers, one who agitates for exclusionary Islamist radicalism/extremism (Generation Islam) and one who offers inclusionary prevention and deradicalization work against that (Jamal al-Khatib). We draw on novel narrative approaches to the Discourse Historical Approach (DHA) in Critical Discourse Studies (CDS), via which we compare text-level and context-level narratives disseminated about three Muslim-related crises: the racist terrorist attacks/genocide to represent the national, European and global level. Our two-layered, DHA-inspired narrative analysis illustrates that, at the level of text, narrative persuasion varies between both contrasting actors. While Jamal al-Khatib disseminates persuasive stories, Generation Islam is much less invested in narrative persuasion; it seems to address an already convinced audience. These two text-level strategies reveal their meaning in two antagonistic narrative genres: Jamal al-Khatib's "self-reflexive savior" creates an inclusionary discursive space represented in a self-ironic narrative genre, while Generation Islam's "crusading savior" manufactures an exclusionary discursive space represented in a romance featuring a nostalgic return to the particularistic Islamic umma.

Intersectional Islamophobia: The Case of a Black Ahmadi Muslim Celebrity

Muslims and Islam: Freeze Framed Discourses in Hollywood during 1978-2013

BEYOND BURQAS, BOMBS, AND BOGEYMEN: AUSTRALIAN MUSLIMS AND THE MEDIA

ISLAMOPHOBIA IN CANADA: THE ROLE OF CANADIAN NEWSPAPERS IN SHAPING ATTITUDES TOWARDS ISLAM AND MUSLIMS

The representation of September 11th and American Islamophobia in non-Western cinema

Doors to the Imaginal: Implications of Sunni Islam’s Persecution of the Ahmadi “Heresy”

"A lot of us have a very difficult time reconciling what being Muslim is": A phenomenological study on the meaning of being Muslim American

Moving beyond (and back to) the black–white binary: a study of black and white Muslims’ racial positioning in the United States

Bridging the communal gap: The politics of “Hindu–Muslim” Salman Bhaijaan

Portraying the Arab Intellectual in Visual Media: A Sociological Analysis of the Plastic Artist’s Identity in Shaghaf TV Series

The Racialization of Islam in American Law

Exclusion, empathy, and Islam: The Runaways in the literary marketplace

Navigating Triple Consciousness in the Diaspora: An Autoethnographic Account of an Ahmadi Muslim Woman in Canada

What Social Workers Need to Know about Muslims: An Analysis of the Contemporary Social Work Scholarship

The Media Matters: Muslim American Portrayals and the Effects on Mass Attitudes

US news media portrayal of Islam and Muslims: a corpus-assisted Critical Discourse Analysis

Different Strokes: American Muslim Scholars Engage Media and Politics in the Woke Era

The Effect of Islamophobia on the Mental Health of Muslim Americans Following the Tragedy of September 11th

The Representation of Islam in Alice Walker’s Everyday Use

The Narrative Foundations of Radical and Deradicalizing Online Discursive Spaces: A Comparison of the Cases of Generation Islam and Jamal al-Khatib in Germany

The Mediated Experience of Girls of Muslim Culture in the French Context as a Challenge to Gender Stereotypes and Islamophobia: An Intersectional Perspective