Demand for Rarity: Evidence from a Collectible Good*

Jonathan E. Hughes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/joie.12262

2022-02-28

Abstract:The Journal of Industrial Economics, EarlyView.

economics,business, finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Measuring the impact of rarity on price: evidence from NBA Top Shot

Yeonjoon Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11002-022-09636-5

IF: 3.426

2022-07-15

Marketing Letters

Abstract:I measure the impact of rarity on price. The main challenge is that usually rarity is positively correlated with quality. In addition, sometimes price also affects rarity. To overcome these difficulties, I study an NBA digital collectibles market called NBA Top Shot where those concerns are well addressed. By analyzing novel and rich data sets, I find that the elasticity of price with respect to circulation (reverse rarity) is −0.74 on average. I also find that less popular products are more elastic than more popular products are.

business
The pursuit of optimal distinctiveness and consumer preferences.

Lingnan He,Feng Cong,Yanping Liu,Xinyue Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9450.2009.00802.x

2010-01-01

Scandinavian Journal of Psychology

Abstract:This article investigates the effect of optimal distinctiveness on consumer product consumption. The authors argue that consumers acquire and display material possessions to restore their optimal levels of distinctiveness. Results showed that placing consumers in a state of low distinctiveness increased desire to acquire distinctive products, whereas perceptions of high distinctiveness reduced desire to acquire such products. Consumers' desire for distinctiveness-related products held true for various consumer choices, including willingness to pay more for limited-edition products and preference for unpopular gifts. This finding has implications for understanding consumer choice in expressing identity.
A Hedonic Index for Collectables Arising from Modelling Diamond Prices

Nicholas I Fisher,Alan J Lee

2023-12-05

Abstract:This article describes a case study concerned with modelling the price of wholesale diamonds, as part of a project to develop an online diamond auction platform. The work was extended to exploring how to develop an index that could be used to track market trends of wholesale diamond prices. The approach we used is readily generalised to defining market indices for so-called Collectables, and can provide the basis for construction of derivatives. With the burgeoning interest in new markets of collectables such as those generated by the concept of a Non-Fungible Token, it is reasonable to suppose that there will be concomitant increasing interest in developing derivatives for these markets.

Pricing of Securities
Rarity Value and Species Extinction: The Anthropogenic Allee Effect

Franck Courchamp,Elena Angulo,Philippe Rivalan,Richard J Hall,Laetitia Signoret,Leigh Bull,Yves Meinard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0040415

IF: 9.8

2006-11-28

PLoS Biology

Abstract:Standard economic theory predicts that exploitation alone is unlikely to result in species extinction because of the escalating costs of finding the last individuals of a declining species. We argue that the human predisposition to place exaggerated value on rarity fuels disproportionate exploitation of rare species, rendering them even rarer and thus more desirable, ultimately leading them into an extinction vortex. Here we present a simple mathematical model and various empirical examples to show how the value attributed to rarity in some human activities could precipitate the extinction of rare species-a concept that we term the anthropogenic Allee effect. The alarming finding that human perception of rarity can precipitate species extinction has serious implications for the conservation of species that are rare or that may become so, be they charismatic and emblematic or simply likely to become fashionable for certain activities.

biochemistry & molecular biology,biology
How Precious Are Scarce Products? an Experimental Study on a Turn-and-Earn Allocation Mechanism

Yefen Chen,Xiaobo Zhao,Wanshan Zhu,Jinxing Xie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/deci.12358

2019-01-01

Decision Sciences

Abstract:ABSTRACTIn this study, we conduct laboratory experiments to analyze a turn‐and‐earn allocation mechanism by which a single supplier allocates scarce products to two identical retailers. Under this mechanism, the supplier uses past sales to dynamically allocate scarce capacity among downstream retailers. The experimental data show that retailers strategically and systematically order more than predicted by standard theory. We find that the psychological scarcity effect is an important phenomenon. Using cognitive hierarchy theory, we develop a behavioral model to consider the scarcity effect, which causes retailers to place additional value on the allocations in a supply‐shortfall period. Using structural estimation, we show that retailers perceive scarce products as being more precious than the standard theory predicts, and exhibit an average of 2.7 reasoning steps during strategic interactions. Moreover, the retailers exhibit social rejoice preference. They are more likely to make myopic decisions when the degree of scarcity is relatively low. Comparing with the proportional allocation mechanisms by an additional experiment, we find that the turn‐and‐earn mechanism is more beneficial to the supplier but less to the retailers.
How rarity and exclusivity influence types of perceived value for luxury

Xujia Wang,Billy Sung,Ian Phau

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41262-024-00359-8

IF: 4.35

2024-04-20

Journal of Brand Management

Abstract:The purpose of this study is to investigate how exclusivity and rarity (natural versus virtual) influence consumers' perceived value (functional, social and emotional) for luxury. Data were collected through an online panel. Luxury product categories including bags, wines, shoes and jewellery were selected as research stimuli. Structural equation modelling was used to test the hypotheses. Results showed that perceived natural rarity was a positive and significant predictor for all three types of consumers' perceived value and across all four product categories. Perceived virtual rarity was a positive and significant predictor only for perceived functional value. Perceived exclusivity did not show any significant effects on value across all categories. This study is the first to provide theoretical support that exclusivity and rarity may have different functions in luxury marketing implementations. It provides updated empirical evidence showing traditional marketing tactic, such as natural rarity, still receive positive social and emotional evaluations among contemporary consumers.

management,business
Purchasing Luck: the Impact of Scarcity Cues on Superstitious Behavior

Lili Wang,Xiao Su,Yanfen You

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/cb.1886

IF: 3.199

2021-01-01

Journal of Consumer Behaviour

Abstract:Resource scarcity is prevalent in consumers' everyday lives. In contrast to the prior research suggesting that resource scarcity rationalizes consumers' decision-making, this research examines when and why resource scarcity enhances consumers' superstitiousness, as represented by their preferences for lucky products. Six studies demonstrate that resource scarcity arouses consumers' desire for control, which, in turn, drives consumers to pursue lucky products. The paper concludes with a discussion of the theoretical and empirical implications of the results.
Unraveling Information Asymmetry in Blockchain-Enabled Nft Marketplaces: the Impact of Rarity Rank on Consumer Behavior

Lin Ye,Chaoyue Gao,Alvin Chung Man Leung,Qiang Ye

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4720944

2024-01-01

Abstract:Blockchain technology has revolutionized online marketplaces by introducing unparalleled levels of information transparency. However, it is still unclear whether full information transparency means information symmetry, especially in the novel setting of blockchain-enabled, two-sided marketplaces. In this research, we focus on the impact of rarity rank, a nascent feature in NFT marketplaces, on consumers’ awareness of scarcity and the reduction of information asymmetry. Our findings indicate that the introduction of rarity rank for Profile Picture NFT (PFP NFT) on platforms like Rarible.com significantly enhances awareness and perception of rarity information. Surprisingly, we found this to lead to a notable decrease in the number of transactions by 11% and a reduction in transaction prices by 8%. Furthermore, by analyzing NFTs categorized by rarity levels, we observed a substantial impact on trading behavior in low rarity collections, resulting in the overall reduction of transaction volume and average prices. Conversely, insignificant effects in high rarity segments was found to occur because their rarity information is already perceived sufficiently. These results suggest that information asymmetry is mainly present in low-rarity NFTs before the introduction of rarity rank, and not critical in the high rarity segment. In conclusion, our research not only advances the understanding of information asymmetry in NFT marketplaces, but also offers valuable suggestions for platform managers and traders regarding how to avoid losses and maximize profits. By understanding the dynamics of information asymmetry and the role of rarity rank, decision makers can make more informed choices in the context of NFT marketplaces.
Auctions Versus Posted-Price Selling: the Case of Correlated Private Valuations

RQ Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/136330

1998-01-01

Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d économique

Abstract:Two popular selling methods are compared in a one-period correlated private-values model. The seller of an object has to decide whether to sell it by posting a fixed price or by an auction. Without auctioning costs, an auction (with a reserve price) is always preferable. With positive auctioning costs, the authors find that an auction is still preferable when the distribution of buyers' valuations is sufficiently dispersed or when the object value is sufficiently high. The relations between these and previous results are also discussed.
The egalitarian value of counterfeit goods: Purchasing counterfeit luxury goods to address income inequality

Jingshi Liu,S. Wiley Wakeman,Michael I. Norton,Jingshi (Joyce) Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jcpy.1431

IF: 4.551

2024-07-02

Journal of Consumer Psychology

Abstract:The present research demonstrates a novel driver of the growing demand for counterfeit luxury goods: perceptions of income inequality. Across five studies, using different samples and counterfeit luxury goods, we find that as perceptions of income inequality increase, consumers value counterfeit luxury products for their "egalitarian value"—a value associated with counterfeits' perceived ability to restore equality in society. Consumers perceive both public and private counterfeit luxury goods to have egalitarian value, suggesting that their value manifests itself beyond consumers' attempts to signal status via consumption. Moreover, the egalitarian value increases consumers' motivation to purchase counterfeit luxury goods beyond their hedonic, utilitarian, economic, or status signaling value. Finally, the positive effect of the egalitarian value of counterfeit luxury goods on purchase preference is greater among consumers who think equality is more desirable and attainable (i.e., those low in social dominance orientation). Our results outline one psychological mechanism underlying consumers' interests in counterfeit luxury goods, explaining how egalitarian value may link two important societal issues: growing income inequality and increased demand for counterfeits.

psychology, applied,business
Price determinants of non-fungible tokens in the digital art market

Florian Horky,Carolina Rachel,Jarko Fidrmuc

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2022.103007

IF: 9.848

2022-08-01

Finance Research Letters

Abstract:While the traditional art market stagnates, the digital art market is booming partially due to its connection with non-fungible tokens, which allow any unique goods to be mapped in a digital environment. Using unique individual data from the online art NFTs marketplace SuperRare, we combine econometric tools with recent machine learning approaches. This approach allows us to define explanatory variables out of the NFTs descriptions for our Hedonic pricing approach. Using these variables, we are able to show that our Hedonic pricing models exhibit relevant informational value for NFTs prices. Moreover, we show that NFTs cannot be viewed as a simple derivative of cryptocurrencies.

business, finance
Scalable Demand and Markups

Enghin Atalay,Erika Frost,Alan T. Sorensen,Christopher Sullivan,Wanjia Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4448281

2023-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We study changes in markups across 72 product markets from 2006 to 2018. A growing literature has documented a rise in markups over time using a production function approach; we instead employ the standard microeconomic method, which is to estimate demand and then invert firms’ first-order pricing conditions to infer their markups. To make the method scalable, we propose estimating nested logit demand models, using household panel data to automate the assignment of products to nests. Our results indicate an overall upward trend in markups between 2006 and 2018, with considerable heterogeneity across and within product markets. We find that changes in firms’ marginal costs and households’ price sensitivity are the primary drivers of markup increases, with changes in firm ownership playing a much smaller role.Institutional subscribers to the NBER working paper series, and residents of developing countries may download this paper without additional charge at www.nber.org.
The Inviolable Law of Demand

Toinu Reeves,TOINU REEVES

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3930186

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We extend upon Reeves (2020), who attempts to demonstrate that classical violations of the Law of Demand are in actuality the result of a violation of the ‘ceteris paribus’ assumption. For example, price changes in Giffen goods create a chain reaction from the Giffen good through a substitute and back to the Giffen good. Specifically, a price change in the Giffen good is so large wrt the consumer’s income that it creates an income effect on a substitute good, whose decrease in demand sends a shock to the Giffen good’s demand curve, shifting it out through a change in preferences and, hence, violating ceteris paribus.To understand how preferences change, consider the consumer equilibrium condition, MU(x) = λp. When price increases and income (i.e. λ) is held constant, marginal utility must increase. In order for x to increase with price, marginal utility must increase with consumption, violating the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility. Hence, the change in price must precipitate a change in preferences because for some values of x preferences comport with the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility whereas for other values of x preferences do not.In this paper, we respond to the non-technical aspects of Jensen and Nolan (2007) by suggesting that the price and demand changes that they are measuring are likely changes along the supply curve, not an upward sloping demand curve. One possible reason for the purported oversight is that the research explores Giffen effects in (good1 , good2 )-space, which cannot capture shifts in the demand curve, defined in (good1 , price1 )-space.
Herding Behavior in the Market for Green Cryptocurrencies: Evidence from CSSD and CSAD Approaches

Júlio Lobão

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su141912542

IF: 3.9

2022-10-02

Sustainability

Abstract:Green cryptocurrencies have been recently created to reduce energy consumption and environmental pollution by adopting alternative mining practices. This paper examines for the first time the market of green cryptocurrencies for indication of herding behavior in the period of January 2017–June 2022. By using two measures that capture the proximity of asset returns from the market consensus, we conclude that herding behavior among investors in green cryptocurrencies was absent in the whole sample. However, the results of a subsample analysis and rolling window regression show that herding dynamics varied significantly throughout the sample period. The recent COVID-19 pandemic amplified the observed levels of herding behavior, suggesting that opportunities for diversification for investors operating in this market may have become more limited lately. For this reason, financial regulators should focus on the market of green cryptocurrencies if they want to promote the market's efficiency necessary to attract additional investors.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
Does Scarcity Add Value in Influencing Consumers in the Try-Before-You-Buy Model?

Jonathan E. Jackson,Xun Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10864415.2021.2010004

IF: 7.73

2022-01-02

International Journal of Electronic Commerce

Abstract:The number of shopping options for consumers in the e-commerce retail environment continues to expand. One such option allows consumers to try products at home before committing to purchase, referred to as the Try-Before-You-Buy (TBYB) model. This study examines the role of scarcity in affecting consumers’ product acceptance intention. Our results reveal that product scarcity increases both consumers’ perceived utilitarian value and hedonic value, which enhance their product acceptance intention in the TBYB model. Additionally, we find that price scarcity also stimulates consumers’ product acceptance intention, but channel scarcity does not. Furthermore, we find that a high hassle cost does not necessarily increase consumers’ passive acceptance intention of products in the TBYB model. Our findings provide implications for TBYB retailers to enhance consumers’ intention to accept products through advertising the scarcity of their products and price, improving both the utilitarian values and hedonic values of their product offerings, but not setting obstacles for consumers to return their products. This study helps companies understand consumers’ perception in the TBYB model, which is critical to improving overall performance. This study also contributes to uniqueness theory by revealing that the effect of scarcity on consumers’ perceived uniqueness is not uniform. Scarcity in product acquisition and scarcity in payment have a higher impact on consumers’ perceived uniqueness than the scarcity of process in terms of the channel in which consumers use to acquire the products.

business,computer science, software engineering
Demand Models With Random Partitions

Adam N. Smith,Greg M. Allenby

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.2019.1604360

IF: 4.369

2019-06-04

Journal of the American Statistical Association

Abstract:Many economic models of consumer demand require researchers to partition sets of products or attributes prior to the analysis. These models are common in applied problems when the product space is large or spans multiple categories. While the partition is traditionally fixed a priori, we let the partition be a model parameter and propose a Bayesian method for inference. The challenge is that demand systems are commonly multivariate models that are not conditionally conjugate with respect to partition indices, precluding the use of Gibbs sampling. We solve this problem by constructing a new location-scale partition distribution that can generate random-walk Metropolis–Hastings proposals and also serve as a prior. Our method is illustrated in the context of a store-level category demand model, where we find that allowing for partition uncertainty is important for preserving model flexibility, improving demand forecasts, and learning about the structure of demand. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.2019.1604360">Supplementary materials</a> for this article, including a standardized description of the materials available for reproducing the work, are available as an online supplement.

statistics & probability
Prospecting for dinosaurs on the mining frontier: The value of information in America's Gilded Age

Lukas Rieppel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0306312715570650

Abstract:How much is a dinosaur worth? This essay offers an account of the way vertebrate fossils were priced in late 19th-century America to explore the process by which monetary values are established in science. Examining a long and drawn-out negotiation over the sale of an unusually rich dinosaur quarry in Wyoming, I argue that, on their own, abstract market principles did not suffice to mediate between supply and demand. Rather, people haggling over the price of dinosaur bones looked to social norms from the mineral industry for cues on how to value these rare and unusual objects, adopting a set of negotiation tactics that exploited asymmetries in the distribution of scarce information to secure the better end of the deal. On the mining frontier in America's Gilded Age, dinosaurs were thus valued in much the same way as any other scarce natural resource one could dig out of the ground, including gold, silver, and coal.
The Impact of Scarcity Marketing Models on Consumer Behavior in the Luxury Industry - The Case of Hermes

Shuai Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/hbem.v19i.11937

2023-11-02

Abstract:With the continuous development of China's economic level, major luxury brands have entered the Chinese market one after another. People's rising living standards and more disposable income provide a strong impetus for the development of the luxury goods industry. At the same time, the luxury industry is also facing the challenges of market expansion and balancing product scarcity. The study analyzes the impact of scarcity marketing on consumers and puts forward feasible suggestions through the combination of scarcity marketing theory and Maslow's demand theory. On the base of a comprehensive analysis of the existing literature, the study summarizes and analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of scarcity marketing in the luxury goods industry. This study demonstrates the successful application of scarcity marketing by combining the case of Hermes. Hermès created the scarcity and uniqueness of products through limited sales, high pricing, and distribution system, which stimulated consumers' desire to buy and product sales. However, this also brings some negative effects including queuing, hype, limiting market size, intensifying market competition, and damaging brand reputation. Therefore, this study puts forward a number of feasible suggestions including formulating diversified pricing strategies, providing differentiated products and services, and strengthening brand social responsibility.
Behind The Bubble: Exploring The Motivations Of Nft Buyers

Paul Griffiths,Carlos J. Costa,Nuno Crespo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2024.108307

IF: 9.9

2024-05-23

Computers in Human Behavior

Abstract:Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) represent a multibillion-dollar global market. While considerable speculation exists about the future utility of NFTs, there has been limited research into the consumer behaviors of market participants. This research paper examines the motivations of NFT buyers through the lens of self-determination theory. Using a sample of 482 participants, the authors tested a conceptual framework to better understand both NFT buyers' intrinsic and extrinsic motivations. This study expands the literature on NFTs in three different ways: i) it is the first study, as far as we know, to focus exclusively on NFT buyers and their motivations in purchasing NFTs; ii) it explores a variety of potential motivations theorized in the literature; and iii) it tests the expected future value of NFTs as both a motivation and as a moderator for NFT buyers. The authors determined that intrinsic motivation had the most substantial effect on purchase intention, and the expectations of NFTs' future value positively moderated the effect of amotivation on purchase intention. In contrast, high expectations of future value moderated the effect of external regulation on purchase intention. The results suggest that NFT buyers are not as impacted by potential social or monetary gain as often characterized in the academic literature but behave more like traditional buyers of luxury goods.

psychology, multidisciplinary, experimental
Positive scarcity effect of virtual product position in hunger marketing situation based on the model of psychological ownership and relative deprivation

ZHAO Yang,W.U. Yongchao,S.L. Aarthy,M.P. Gopinath,Yang Zhao,Yongchao Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2021.101630

IF: 4.874

2021-06-01

Aggression and Violent Behavior

Abstract:<p>As a frequently observed business phenomenon, the utilization of product scarcity to enhance its performance has received increasing attention in recent years. Hunger marketing is a marketing policy where goods suppliers intentionally limit product supply to achieve excess demand. In this paper, the Heterogeneous Heuristic Structural Equation Modeling (HHSEM) has been proposed to describe product scarcity's critical factors and how they impact both market and consumer with psychological inception. The data determined from definite deficiency depending on product suitability in the consumption level. For each case, the sensitivity analysis has been conducted to investigate the effects of the product compatibility with net sales and the data disclosure cost. The empirical outcomes suggest that the impact of scarcity on purchase intention and scarcity effects has been analyzed based on perceived value, uniqueness, and value.</p>

psychology, multidisciplinary,criminology & penology

Demand for Rarity: Evidence from a Collectible Good*

Measuring the impact of rarity on price: evidence from NBA Top Shot

The pursuit of optimal distinctiveness and consumer preferences.

A Hedonic Index for Collectables Arising from Modelling Diamond Prices

Rarity Value and Species Extinction: The Anthropogenic Allee Effect

How Precious Are Scarce Products? an Experimental Study on a Turn-and-Earn Allocation Mechanism

How rarity and exclusivity influence types of perceived value for luxury

Purchasing Luck: the Impact of Scarcity Cues on Superstitious Behavior

Unraveling Information Asymmetry in Blockchain-Enabled Nft Marketplaces: the Impact of Rarity Rank on Consumer Behavior

Auctions Versus Posted-Price Selling: the Case of Correlated Private Valuations

The egalitarian value of counterfeit goods: Purchasing counterfeit luxury goods to address income inequality

Price determinants of non-fungible tokens in the digital art market

Scalable Demand and Markups

The Inviolable Law of Demand

Herding Behavior in the Market for Green Cryptocurrencies: Evidence from CSSD and CSAD Approaches

Does Scarcity Add Value in Influencing Consumers in the Try-Before-You-Buy Model?

Demand Models With Random Partitions

Prospecting for dinosaurs on the mining frontier: The value of information in America's Gilded Age

The Impact of Scarcity Marketing Models on Consumer Behavior in the Luxury Industry - The Case of Hermes

Behind The Bubble: Exploring The Motivations Of Nft Buyers

Positive scarcity effect of virtual product position in hunger marketing situation based on the model of psychological ownership and relative deprivation