Abstract:A challenge for online retail firms is managing stockouts of products when substitutes are available. We develop a game‐theoretic model to analyze the competition between multiple‐product online firms and characterize the scenarios when they can use prices as stockout recovery mechanisms. Depending on the consumer costs of searching for unfamiliar substitute products on their sites and the consumer mismatch costs of shopping at backup compared to favorite firms, in our primary analysis, we demonstrate that the equilibrium of a pricing game can be one of three possible types: following stockouts the firms retain their customers, the firms release their customers, or all consumers turn to one of the firms. We also examine a firm's combined use of prices and product recommender systems to manage stockouts. Results in the primary section of the analysis and a first extension combine to demonstrate a firm's strategic marketing complementarity of its prices and quality of its product recommender system. That is, when a firm uses a better product recommender system to retain consumers following stockouts, we show that it also raises prices. In our primary section, we also show that by implementing a better product recommender system, surprisingly a firm's sales may fall. However, implementing higher‐quality recommender systems may not be jointly optimal for the firms. In the first extension's game, depending on the cost of better product recommender systems, the firms, when choosing recommender systems, may engage in a prisoner's dilemma, where the price increase associated cannot fully compensate the implementation cost. In a second extension, we show that positively (negatively) correlated stockouts of a product between the competitors reduces (raises) each firm's profit and prices because the positive (negative) correlation reduces (raises) each consumer's expected utility of shopping experience. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved

How Precious Are Scarce Products? an Experimental Study on a Turn-and-Earn Allocation Mechanism

Pricing and Introductory Scarcity Strategies Based on Consumers' Response.

Restrained by Resources: the Effect of Scarcity Cues and Childhood Socioeconomic Status (SES) on Consumer Preference for Feasibility

Purchasing Luck: the Impact of Scarcity Cues on Superstitious Behavior

How Does Scarcity Promotion Lead to Impulse Purchase in the Online Market? A Field Experiment

Does Scarcity Add Value in Influencing Consumers in the Try-Before-You-Buy Model?

When Less Is More? The Contingent Effect Of Product Supply Limitation In The Release Of New Electronic Products

Inventory Rationing In A Capacitated System With Backorders And Lost Sales

Does Scarce Inventory Information Disclosure Strategy Promote Online Sales?

Positive scarcity effect of virtual product position in hunger marketing situation based on the model of psychological ownership and relative deprivation

Allocation with demand competition: Uniform, proportional, and lexicographic mechanisms

Rationing and Pricing with Strategic Consumer Behavior

Capacity Allocation with Demand Competition in Asymmetric Market

Smallest-order-first Mechanism in Supply Chain Operations

Decision Bias in Capacity Allocation Games with Uncertain Demand

How Do Scarcity Messages Lead to Impulsive Online Purchase? the Perspective of Arousal

Modeling Bounded Rationality in Capacity Allocation Games with the Quantal Response Equilibrium

Retailer’s Multi-Tier Green Procurement Contract in the Presence of Suppliers’ Reference Point Effect

The Study on Random Rationing Strategy Based on Heterogeneous Consumers

Inventory and Pricing Decisions when Dealing with Strategic Consumers: A Comprehensive Analysis.

Let them stay or let them go? Online retailer pricing strategy for managing stockouts