Abstract:Countless meta-analytic studies document the relation between parental involvement and achievement, but they mostly include studies conducted in the United States where parental involvement is framed as a policy issue. This is the first meta-analytic study focusing on East Asian countries characterized by high achievement levels, a comparatively standardized education system, and no policy encouraging family–school relations. A meta-analysis of 15 studies retrieved from an exhaustive search of the literature reveals a positive association between parental involvement and achievement. The strength of the relation was highest for academic socialization, followed by home involvement and school involvement, similar to previous meta-analyses.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationship between parental involvement and student achievement in East Asian countries, and to analyze whether this relationship is similar to or different from the research results in other regions (such as the United States). Specifically, the research mainly focuses on the following issues:
1. **Overall relationship**: Is there a significant positive correlation between parental involvement and student achievement in the East Asian sample?
2. **Strength of different types of relationships**: Which types of parental involvement (such as school involvement, family involvement, academic socialization) have the strongest association with student achievement?
3. **Other influencing factors**: How does the effect size of this relationship change with different grade levels, methodological moderator variables, reporting sources, achievement types, and subjects?
### Research background
A large number of past meta - analysis studies have mainly focused on the relationship between parental involvement in American families and student achievement, and rarely involved East Asian countries. East Asian countries are characterized by high academic achievement, relatively standardized education systems, and a lack of policies to encourage family - school relationships. Therefore, this meta - analysis study fills this gap and is the first to specifically analyze East Asian countries.
### Research purposes
1. **Synthesize existing studies**: Synthesize studies on the relationship between parental involvement and student achievement in East Asian countries published between 1990 and 2017.
2. **Analyze different types of impacts**: Evaluate the impacts of different types of parental involvement (school involvement, family involvement, academic socialization) on student achievement.
3. **Explore influencing factors**: Examine the impacts of factors such as grade level, methodological moderator variables, reporting sources, achievement types, and subjects on the relationship between parental involvement and student achievement.
### Methods
- **Inclusion/exclusion criteria**: The study must report specific measures of parental involvement, including parents' beliefs, attitudes, and practices regarding their children's education. At the same time, the study must include measurement indicators of academic achievement, such as grades, GPA, teacher evaluations, and standardized test scores.
- **Search strategy**: Identify relevant studies through extensive database searches (such as EBSCO, ERIC, SocINDEX, and PsycINFO) and keyword combinations.
- **Sample description**: Finally, 15 observational studies were included, involving students in China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, and Singapore, with a total sample size of 30,715 families.
### Results
- **Overall effect size**: There is a significant positive correlation between parental involvement and student achievement, with an average effect size of 0.12 (95% confidence interval [0.09, 0.16]), but the effect size is relatively small.
- **Different types of impacts**: The effect of academic socialization is the strongest, followed by family involvement and school involvement.
- **Other influencing factors**: The effect size varies with different grade levels, reporting sources, achievement types, and subjects.
### Conclusions
This study confirms that there is a positive correlation between parental involvement and student achievement in East Asian countries, but the effect size is relatively small. The impacts of different types of parental involvement also vary, among which the effect of academic socialization is the strongest. These results are helpful for better understanding the parental involvement patterns unique to East Asian countries and their impacts on student achievement.