Abstract:<h1>Biocontrol of Carp: The Australian Plan Does Not Stand Up to a Rational Analysis of Safety and Efficacy</h1><a href="http://www.frontiersin.org/people/u/653220">Maxime Boutier</a>1, <a href="http://www.frontiersin.org/people/u/662129">Owen Donohoe</a>1,2, <a href="http://www.frontiersin.org/people/u/654951">R. Keller Kopf</a>3, <a href="http://www.frontiersin.org/people/u/653330">Paul Humphries</a>3, <a href="http://www.frontiersin.org/people/u/345329">Joy A. Becker</a>4, <a href="http://www.frontiersin.org/people/u/653946">Jonathan Marshall</a>5,6 and <a href="http://www.frontiersin.org/people/u/653162">Alain Vanderplasschen</a>1*<ul><li>1Department of Parasitic and Infectious Diseases, University of Liège, Liège, Belgium</li><li>2Bioscience Research Institute, Athlone Institute of Technology, Athlone, Ireland</li><li>3School of Environmental Sciences, Institute for Land Water & Society, Charles Sturt University, Albury, NSW, Australia</li><li>4Faculty of Science, School of Life and Environmental Sciences, The University of Sydney, Camden, NSW, Australia</li><li>5Queensland Department of Environment and Science, Water Planning Ecology, Brisbane, QLD, Australia</li><li>6Australian Rivers Institute, Griffith University, Nathan, QLD, Australia</li></ul><h2>The Australian Plan for Biocontrol of Invasive Carp Using Cyprinid Herpesvirus 3</h2>Common carp (Cyprinus carpio), hereafter referred as carp, is one of the most widely cultured fish produced for food globally. It was introduced into Australia for aquaculture in the mid-nineteenth century (<a href="#B17">Lintermans, 2004</a>). Following floods in the 1970's, carp became abundant and widespread in many Australian waterways where it has come to comprise a large proportion of the fish fauna of these ecosystems (<a href="#B14">Koehn, 2004</a>). To reduce carp population abundance and aid native species recovery, the Australian Government is evaluating the release of cyprinid herpesvirus 3 [CyHV-3, also known as koi herpesvirus (KHV)] presumed to be absent from Australia (<a href="#B22">NCCP, 2017</a>). CyHV-3 emerged in the mid 1990's and since that time has devastated carp production worldwide (<a href="#B4">Boutier et al., 2015</a>). Due to its economic impact on aquaculture, the Word Organization for Animal Health requires notification when the virus is identified.<h2>Potential Safety Concerns Associated With the Use of CyHV-3 as a Biocontrol Agent</h2>Following carp mortality caused by CyHV-3, decomposing dead fish could itself lead to undesirable environmental damage (<a href="#B16">Lighten and van Oosterhout, 2017</a>). A detailed analysis of this indirect risk vs the potential benefits of the use of CyHV-3 is published elsewhere (<a href="#B15">Kopf et al., 2019</a>). The virus may also cause direct deleterious effects by infection of non-target species.Herpesviruses have mainly evolved by co-speciation with their host, leading to a narrow host range restricted to their natural host species and closely related species (<a href="#B37">Waltzek et al., 2009</a>). Consistently, it has been demonstrated that CyHV-3 causes mortality only in common and koi carp. However, the ability of the virus to establish subclinical infection in non-natural host species, to persist and to be transmitted from the latter to naïve cohabitant carp has been suggested based on PCR analyses (<a href="#B13">Kempter et al., 2012</a>; <a href="#B8">Fabian et al., 2013</a>, <a href="#B7">2016</a>). The biological relevance of these data should be taken with caution as the signals observed were weak and the transmission to sentinel carp was never associated with the expression of CyHV-3 disease. The risk of CyHV-3 infecting non-target species of Australia was investigated in limited experimental conditions in a recent paper (<a href="#B21">McColl et al., 2017</a>). Importantly, the results of that study indicate that CyHV-3 may have induced mortality in at least some native fish species [e.g. silver perch (Bidyanus bidyanus)] in Australia. <a href="#B21">McColl et al. (2017)</a> ignored the potential role of CyHV-3 in the deaths observed (including in the groups where mortality was significantly higher in infected than in mock-infected groups) by presenting data suggesting that viral transcripts could not be detected in dead fish. The possibility of technical issues or the hypothesis that CyHV-3 could induce death in non-natural host species through a non-replicative pathogenesis, as observed for other herpesviruses (e.g., alcelaphine herpesvirus 1) (<a href="#B23">Palmeira et al., 2013</a>), were not addressed. For these reasons, the data published by <a h -Abstract Truncated-

Biocontrol of Carp: The Australian Plan Does Not Stand Up to a Rational Analysis of Safety and Efficacy

Susceptibility of Pimephales promelas and Carassius auratus to a strain of koi herpesvirus isolated from wild Cyprinus carpio in North America

Integrative Transcriptomic Analysis Reveals the Immune Mechanism for a CyHV-3-Resistant Common Carp Strain

Metagenomic sequencing reveals a lack of virus exchange between native and invasive freshwater fish across the Murray–Darling Basin, Australia

Transcriptomic Responses to Koi Herpesvirus in Isolated Blood Leukocytes from Infected Common Carp

Mass mortality events associated with cyprinid herpesvirus 2 (CyHV-2) infection in wild Prussian carp Carassius gibelio in the Netherlands, and molecular biology of virus strains

Disease resistance and infectivity of virus susceptible and resistant common carp strains

Mapping and Sequencing of a Significant Quantitative Trait Locus Affecting Resistance to Koi Herpesvirus in Common Carp

A Seasonal Study of Koi Herpesvirus and Koi Sleepy Disease Outbreaks in the United Kingdom in 2018 Using a Pond-Side Test

Don’t Let It Get Under Your Skin! – Vaccination Protects the Skin Barrier of Common Carp From Disruption Caused by Cyprinid Herpesvirus 3

In Vivo Imaging Sheds Light on the Susceptibility and Permissivity of Carassius auratus to Cyprinid Herpesvirus 2 According to Developmental Stage

Autophagy induced by Cyprinid herpesvirus 3 (CyHV-3) facilitated intracellular viral replication and extracellular viral yields in common carp brain cells

Cloning and Identification of Common Carp (Cyprinus carpio) PI3KC3 and Its Expression in Response to CyHV-3 Infection

Common carp (Cyprinus carpio) CD81 promoting CyHV-3 virus replication via regulating autophagy and RLRs-interferon signaling pathway

Serological responses to koi herpesvirus (KHV) in a non-cyprinid reservoir host

Efficacy of anti-koi herpesvirus DNA vaccine in carp Cyprinus carpio fry by immersion method and hyperosmotic infiltration

The engineered ORF56–57 deletion mutant leads to attenuation of an Asian koi herpesvirus strain

Occurrence of herpesvirus in fish

Koi herpesvirus and carp edema virus threaten common carp aquaculture in Croatia.

Stability of viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus, infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus and cyprinid herpesvirus 3 in various water samples

Alterations of Plasma Biochemical and Immunological Parameters and Spatiotemporal Expression of TLR2 and TLR9 in Gibel Carp (Carassius auratus gibelio) after CyHV-2 Infection