Abstract:The objective of this review is to survey the development of the optimization of lyophilization. The optimization study of the lyophilizer has been roughly developing by the order of (i) trial-and-error approach, (ii) process modeling using mathematical models, (iii) scalability, and (iv) quality-by-design. From the conventional lyophilization studies based on the trial-and-error, the key parameters to optimize the operation of lyophilization were found out, i.e., critical material attributes (CMAs), critical process parameters (CPPs), and critical quality attributes (CQAs). The mathematical models using the key parameters mentioned above have been constructed from the viewpoints of the heat and mass transfer natures. In many cases, it is revealed that the control of the primary drying stage determines the outcome of the lyophilization of products, as compared with the freezing stage and the secondary drying stage. Thus, the understanding of the lyophilization process has proceeded. For the further improvement of the time and economical cost, the design space is a promising method to give the possible operation range for optimizing the lyophilization operation. This method is to search the optimized condition by reducing the number of key parameters of CMAs, CPPs, and CQAs. Alternatively, the transfer of lyophilization recipe among the lab-, pilot-, and production-scale lyophilizers (scale-up) has been examined. Notably, the scale-up of lyophilization requires the preservation of lyophilization dynamics between the two scales, i.e., the operation of lab- or pilot-scale lyophilizer under HEPA-filtrated airflow condition. The design space determined by focusing on the primary drying stage is large and involves the undesired variations in the quality of final products due to the heterogeneous size distribution of ice crystals. Accordingly, the control of the formation of the ice crystal with large size gave impact on the product quality and the productivity although the large water content in the final product should be improved. Therefore, the lyophilization should take into account the quality by design (QbD). The monitoring method of the quality of the product in lyophilization process is termed the “process analytical technology (PAT).” Recent PAT tools can reveal the lyophilization dynamics to some extent. A combination of PAT tools with a model/scale-up theory is expected to result in the QbD, i.e., a quality/risk management and an in situ optimization of lyophilization operation.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the optimization of the lyophilization process. Specifically, the author reviews the development history of lyophilization process optimization, from the initial trial - and - error approach, to process modeling using mathematical models, then to scalability, and quality - by - design (QbD). The article mainly discusses how to optimize the lyophilization process, reduce time and economic costs, and improve product quality and production efficiency by identifying critical material attributes (CMAs), critical process parameters (CPPs) and critical quality attributes (CQAs), combined with mathematical models and process analytical technology (PAT). It is mentioned in the paper that the lyophilization process is usually divided into three stages: the freezing stage, the primary drying stage and the secondary drying stage. Among them, the primary drying stage has the greatest impact on the final quality of the lyophilized product, so the optimization of this stage is particularly important. To achieve this goal, the author discusses the concept of design space, that is, finding the optimal lyophilization conditions by determining the possible range of operating variables. In addition, the article also explores the scale - up problem between lyophilizers of different scales (laboratory - scale, pilot - scale and production - scale), emphasizing the importance of maintaining the consistency of lyophilization kinetics between different scales. In summary, this paper aims to propose a systematic method to improve the efficiency and product quality of the lyophilization process by reviewing the research progress of lyophilization process optimization, especially for applications in the pharmaceutical and food engineering fields.

Recent Development of Optimization of Lyophilization Process

Process development and quality attributes for the freeze-drying process in pharmaceuticals, biopharmaceuticals and nanomedicine delivery: a state-of-the-art review

Lyophilization of Small-Molecule Injectables: an Industry Perspective on Formulation Development, Process Optimization, Scale-Up Challenges, and Drug Product Quality Attributes

Advanced Process Analytical Technology in Combination with Process Modeling for Endpoint and Model Parameter Determination in Lyophilization Process Design and Optimization

Recent advances in freeze-drying: variables, cycle optimization, and innovative techniques

[Optimization of Lime Milk Precipitation Process of Lonicera Japonica Aqueous Extract Based on Quality by Design Concept].

Model-Based Optimisation and Control Strategy for the Primary Drying Phase of a Lyophilisation Process

Leveraging Lyophilization Modeling for Reliable Development, Scale-up and Technology Transfer

Tuning, measurement and prediction of the impact of freezing on product morphology: A step toward improved design of freeze-drying cycles

Recommended Best Practices for Lyophilization Validation—2021 Part I: Process Design and Modeling

LyoPRONTO: an Open-Source Lyophilization Process Optimization Tool

Quality by design (QbD) in the formulation and optimization of liquid crystalline nanoparticles (LCNPs): A risk based industrial approach

Finite Element Method (FEM) Modeling of Freeze-drying: Monitoring Pharmaceutical Product Robustness During Lyophilization

Mechanistic Modeling of Continuous Lyophilization for Pharmaceutical Manufacturing

Development of liposomes using formulation by design: Basics to recent advances

Application of the Quality by Design Concept (QbD) in the Development of Hydrogel-Based Drug Delivery Systems

Spray drying of pharmaceuticals and biopharmaceuticals: Critical parameters and experimental process optimization approaches

Design Space Calculation and Continuous Improvement Considering a Noise Parameter: A Case Study of Ethanol Precipitation Process Optimization for Carthami Flos Extract

Optimization of Critical Quality Attributes in Tablet Film Coating and Design Space Determination Using Pilot-Scale Experimental Data

Toward Polymer Product Design. I. Dynamic Optimization of Average Molecular Weights and Polydispersity Index in Batch Free Radical Polymerization

Optimization of a Coupling Process for Insulin Degludec According to a Quality by Design (qbd) Paradigm