Abstract:Many scholars have recently maintained that it is difficult if not impossible to postulate the definite parting of the ways between Judaism and Christianity in antiquity. It is argued in this paper that recent criticisms against the ‘parting of the ways’‐model resemble criticisms levelled against the classical identity theory formulated by Erik H. Erikson. His identity theory emphasises the sense of personal sameness and historical continuity. In recent decades, however, it has become common to question whether the notion of unified and consistent self does justice to diverse social realities in which individuals construct their sense of who they are. Furthermore, the developmental stage model claims to be universal and culturally neutral while, as a matter of fact, it is implicitly moralistic and value‐laden. In case of the ‘parting of the ways’‐model it has become clear that the model does not match the evidence showing an intense interaction between various Jewish and Christian communities during the first centuries CE. In addition, it has been claimed that the model is not an unbiased historical account but serves Christian theological interests. Comparing the ‘parting of the ways’‐theory with the Eriksonian identity theory highlights the problems inherent in both theories. It is suggested that psychological and social‐psychological theories arguing for the flexible and dynamic nature of identity construction are best suited to describe the emergence of early Christian identity in relation to Jews and Judaism.

Sounding Out the Gospel: Robert Jenson’s Theological Project

Robert Jenson and the spirit of it all: or, you (sometimes) wonder where everything else went

The Church and the Spirit in Robert Jenson’s Theology of Scripture

Jenson, Hegel and the Spirit of Recognition

The relation between creation and salvation in the Trinitarian theology of Robert Jenson

Invitation to the Triune Conversation: Explorations of Prayer through the Theology of Robert Jenson

The Identification of the Triune God: Robert W. Jenson's Approach to the Doctrine of the Trinity

Trinity, incarnation and time: a restatement of the doctrine of God in conversation with Robert Jenson

The Spirit and the Community: Pneumatology and Ecclesiology in Jenson, Hütter and Bonhoeffer

An Assessment of Robert Jenson's Hermeneutics on Divine Im/Passibility and the Emotions of God

Divine Roominess: Spatial and Music Analogies in Hans Urs von Balthasar and Robert Jenson

Erik H. Erikson’s Young Man Luther: A Classic Revisited, Again

Erik H. Erikson and the deep context of ministry

Erik H. Erikson’s identity theory and the formation of early Christianity

On earth as it is in heaven: a study of the healing praxis of Bill Johnson

John Gerson and the Foundations of Mystical Theology

C. C. Martindale (1879–1963), the History of Religions, and the Theological Imagination of David Jones (1895–1974)

Embodiment, Identity Formation and Missional Leadership: Roots of Theory and Practice in Theological Education

Strange Deliberations: John Betjeman and Protestant Nonconformity

READING JOHN’S GOSPEL FROM A GLOCAL-MISSION PERSPECTIVE

Teologie as werklikheidsverstaan – anders dink, anders doen: Aantekeninge oor die teologie van Johan Buitendag