Abstract:Diffusion MR images are prone to severe geometric distortions induced by head movement, eddy-current and inhomogeneity of magnetic susceptibility. Various correction methods have been proposed that depend on the choice of the acquisition settings and potentially provide highly different data quality. However, the impact of this choice has not been evaluated in terms of the ratio between scan time and preprocessed data quality. This study aims at investigating the impact of six well-known preprocessing methods, each associated to specific acquisition settings, on the outcome of diffusion analyses. For this purpose, we developed a comprehensive toolbox called <i>Diffuse</i> which automatically guides the user to the best preprocessing pipeline according to the input data. Using MR images of 20 subjects from the HCP dataset, we compared the six pre-processing pipelines regarding the following criteria: the ability to recover brain's true geometry, the tensor model estimation and derived indices in the white matter, and finally the spatial dispersion of six well known connectivity pathways. As expected the pipeline associated to the longer acquisition fully repeated with reversed phase-encoding (RPE) yielded the higher data quality and was used as a reference to evaluate the other pipelines. In this way, we highlighted several significant aspects of other pre-processing pipelines. Our results first established that eddy-current correction improves the tensor-fitting performance with a localized impact especially in the corpus callosum. Concerning susceptibility distortions, we showed that the use of a field map is not sufficient and involves additional smoothing, yielding to an artificial decrease of tensor-fitting error. Of most importance, our findings demonstrate that, for an equivalent scan time, the acquisition of a b0 volume with RPE ensures a better brain's geometry reconstruction and local improvement of tensor quality, without any smoothing of the image. This was found to be the best scan time/data quality compromise. To conclude, this study highlights and attempts to quantify the strong dependence of diffusion metrics on acquisition settings and preprocessing methods.

Diffusion MRI: Assessment of the Impact of Acquisition and Preprocessing Methods Using the BrainVISA-Diffuse Toolbox

Multishot diffusion-prepared magnitude-stabilized balanced steady-state free precession sequence for distortion-free diffusion imaging.

Analysis of the effects of noise, DWI sampling, and value of assumed parameters in diffusion MRI models

Quality Control of Diffusion Weighted Images.

Same Brain, Different Look?—The Impact of Scanner, Sequence and Preprocessing on Diffusion Imaging Outcome Parameters

Influence of preprocessing, distortion correction and cardiac triggering on the quality of diffusion MR images of spinal cord

Multi-Site Harmonization of Diffusion MRI Data Via Method of Moments

On the construction of a ground truth framework for evaluating voxel-based diffusion tensor MRI analysis methods

Reproducibility of the Standard Model of diffusion in white matter on clinical MRI systems

Assessment of Precision and Accuracy of Brain White Matter Microstructure using Combined Diffusion MRI and Relaxometry

The Effect of Spatial Resolution on the Reproducibility of Diffusion Imaging when Controlled Signal to Noise Ratio

High-fidelity, high-spatial-resolution diffusion magnetic resonance imaging of ex vivo whole human brain at ultra-high gradient strength with structured low-rank echo-planar imaging ghost correction

Considerations and recommendations from the ISMRM Diffusion Study Group for preclinical diffusion MRI: Part 3 -- Ex vivo imaging: data processing, comparisons with microscopy, and tractography

Optimization of image preprocessing for diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging

Optimization and Validation of the DESIGNER dMRI preprocessing pipeline in white matter aging

Effects of Non-Local Diffusion on Structural MRI Preprocessing and Default Network Mapping: Statistical Comparisons with Isotropic/anisotropic Diffusion.

Optimisation of quantitative brain diffusion-relaxation MRI acquisition protocols with physics-informed machine learning

Robust diffusion imaging framework for clinical studies

Submillimeter diffusion MRI using an in-plane segmented 3D multi-slab acquisition and denoiser-regularized reconstruction

Recommendations and Guidelines from the ISMRM Diffusion Study Group for Preclinical Diffusion MRI: Part 2 -- Ex Vivo Imaging

In vivo disentanglement of diffusion frequency‐dependence, tensor shape, and relaxation using multidimensional MRI