A macro context theory of academic self-concept: Ability stratification and the big-fish-little-pond effect

Philip David Parker,Theresa Dicke,Jiesi Guo,Herb Marsh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/bwy59
2019-06-10
Abstract:Governments rarely aim at altering the way children view themselves. Yet, governments, culture, and social norms shape the social settings children find themselves in (i.e., the amount of ability stratification in the education system). Reviewing sociological, economic, and psychological literature we construct a theory that states that any macro influence which leads children to be schooled with peers of similar ability levels (ability stratification) will bias children’s academic self-concepts via larger Big-Fish-Little-Pond effects (the negative effect of school average achievement on academic self-concept). Applying meta-analysis to estimates derived from four cycles of the Trends in International Math and Science Study we test the hypothesis that the relationship between achievement stratification and the effect of school average achievement on academic self-concept will be large and negative. Findings strongly support our hypothesis (r < -.50).
What problem does this paper attempt to address?