Abstract:The big-fish-little-pond effect (BFLPE), the negative effect of school-/class-average achievement on academic self-concept, is one of educational psychology's most universal findings. However, critiques of this research have proposed moderators based on achievement motivation theories. Nevertheless, because these motivational theories are not sufficiently well-developed to provide unambiguous predictions concerning moderation of the BFLPE and underlying social comparison processes, we developed a Theory-Integrating Approach; bringing together a panel of experts, independently making theoretical predictions, revising the predictions over several rounds based on independent feedback from the other experts, and a summary of results. We pit a priori hypotheses derived from achievement motivation theories against the more parsimonious a priori prediction that there is no moderation based on previous BFLPE empirical research and Darwinian-economic theory (N = 1,925 Hong Kong students, 47 classes, M age = 12 years). Consistent with both BFLPE research and Darwinian perspectives, but in contrast to achievement motivation theory predictions, the highly significant BFLPE was not moderated by any of the following: prior achievement, expectancy-value theory variables, achievement goals, implicit theories of ability, self-regulated learning strategies, and social interdependence theory measures. Although we cannot "prove" that there are no student-level moderators of the BFLPE, our synthesis of social comparison posited in the BFLPE theory and an evolutionary perspective support BFLPE's generalizability. We propose further integration of our Theory-Integrating Approach with traditional Delphi methods, combining quantitative and qualitative approaches to develop a priori theoretical predictions and identify limitations in existing theory as an alternative form of systematic review.

The big-fish-little-pond effect on academic self-concept and interest in first- and third-grade students

The Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect on Academic Self-Concept: A Meta-Analysis

Academic self-concept formation and peer-group contagion: Development of the big-fish-little-pond effect in primary-school classrooms and peer groups.

The big-fish-little-pond effect on academic self-concept among Chinese middle school students

The Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect for Academic Self-Concept, Test Anxiety, and School Grades in Gifted Children.

The big-fish-little-pond effect: Generalizability of social comparison processes over two age cohorts from Western, Asian, and Middle Eastern Islamic countries.

Classroom effect on primary school students’ self-concept in literacy and mathematics

Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect on Academic Self-Concept 1Dieser Beitrag und die darauf bezogenen Stellungnahmen wurden von D.H. Rost akzeptiert.

Earning Its Place as a Pan-Human Theory: Universality of the Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect across 41 Culturally and Economically Diverse Countries.

Being a big fish in a little pond: student group composition, perceived academic standing, and young people's academic self-concept

Math self-concept in the transition to secondary school: Developmental trends, predictors, and educational implications among high-ability and average-ability students

Moderation of the Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect: Juxtaposition of Evolutionary (Darwinian-Economic) and Achievement Motivation Theory Predictions Based on a Delphi Approach

Ability Stratification Predicts the Size of the Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect

Ability self-concept formation in elementary school: No dimensional comparison effects across time.

Math interest and self-concept among latino/a students: Reciprocal influences across the transition to middle school

Linking academic buoyancy and math achievement in secondary school students: Does academic self-efficacy play a role?

Empathic forecasting of the big-fish-little-pond effect

Profile formation of academic self-concept in elementary school students in grades 1 to 4

Does integration play a role? Academic self-concepts, self-esteem, and self-perceptions of social integration of elementary school children in inclusive and mainstream classes

Development of Self-Concept in Multi-Grade 3rd and 4th Classes

Effects of classroom and school climate on language minority students’ PISA mathematics self-concept and achievement scores