Richard B. Felson,Jukka Savolainen,Sarah Fry,Corey Whichard,Noora Ellonen
Abstract:To understand the etiology and consequences of child sexual abuse it is important to study the victims' subjective reactions to such incidents. Because researchers have not been able to survey children about sexual abuse, not much is known about how subjective reactions are related to gender, age, age difference, and the social relationship between the offender and victim. The present study fills this gap using data gathered from a large, nationally representative sample of Finnish children ages 11 to 17 (<em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">N</em> = 32,145). Analyses of abuse are based on a sample of 1520 children (78% girls), while analyses of peer sexual experiences are based on a sample of 3551 children (55% girls). Multivariate analyses adjusted for the use of coercion, the intimacy of the sexual experience, and other incident characteristics. It was hypothesized that, as a result of sex differences in sexuality and attitudes toward deviant behavior, girls are more sensitive than boys to age and age difference. Three findings supported the hypothesis: (1) girls were more likely than boys to have a negative reaction to sexual encounters regardless of the age difference; (2) for girls, age was negatively associated with the likelihood of a negative reaction, but age had no effect for boys; and (3) girls reacted negatively to age difference while boys did not. However, girls did not react more negatively unless the offender was at least eight years older. The results highlight the susceptibility of adolescent boys to encounters with older women. They further suggest that ignoring the role of the victim limits understanding of the vulnerability of young people to sexual abuse.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the subjective reactions of child sexual abuse victims and their associations with gender, age, age differences, and the social relationships between victims and perpetrators. Specifically, the research aims to fill the gaps in the existing literature, that is, there are few studies on the subjective reactions of child sexual abuse victims, especially how these reactions are affected by factors such as gender and age. In addition, the research also explores whether there are differences in subjective reactions between sexual experiences among peers and sexual abuse, in order to fully understand the reaction patterns of adolescents in different situations.
### Research Background and Problems
1. **Limitations of Existing Research**:
- Most studies on child sexual abuse rely on small samples, such as the recollections of college students or adults, and these samples may not accurately reflect the immediate reactions of children and adolescents.
- Research on gender differences mainly focuses on heterosexual encounters and cannot distinguish the influence of the victim's gender and the perpetrator's gender on the reaction.
- Research on the relationship between victims and perpetrators is also relatively limited, especially the influence of whether the perpetrator is a stranger or a family member on the victim's reaction.
2. **Research Objectives**:
- To explore how the subjective reactions of child sexual abuse victims are affected by gender, age, age differences, and social relationships.
- To compare the subjective reactions of child sexual abuse and sexual experiences among peers to understand whether these reactions are specific to sexual abuse events or reflect the reaction patterns of adolescents in general sexual experiences.
### Research Hypotheses
1. **Gender Differences**:
- Girls are more sensitive to age and age differences than boys and are more likely to have negative reactions to sexual abuse.
- Girls have more negative reactions to older perpetrators, while boys are not sensitive to this.
- The negative reactions of girls decrease with age, while the reactions of boys are not affected by age.
2. **Age Differences**:
- The greater the age gap, the more intense the negative reactions of girls, while boys are not sensitive to this.
3. **Social Relationships**:
- Girls have more negative reactions to stranger perpetrators than to familiar people, while boys' reactions are the opposite.
### Methods
- **Sample**: The research used data from adolescent victimization surveys in Finland in 1988, 2008, and 2013, with a total of 32,145 respondents.
- **Variables**:
- **Negative Reactions**: Measured by two indicators, one is an adjective indicator (such as disgust, fear, shock), and the other is an evaluation indicator (retrospectively evaluating the experience as positive or negative).
- **Age and Age Differences**: Divided into three age groups (11 years old and below, 12 - 14 years old, 15 - 17 years old), and age differences are divided into three categories (5 - 7 years old, 8 - 11 years old, 12 years old and above).
- **Social Relationships**: Divided into strangers, family members, and other known non - family members.
- **Forced Use**: Whether physical force, coercion, or blackmail was used.
- **Number of Repetitions**: The number of sexual experiences.
- **Intimacy Level**: The most intimate type of sexual behavior (such as suggesting a certain sexual behavior, sexual touching, sexual intercourse).
- **Control Variables**: Parental education level, family structure, survey year.
### Results
- **Descriptive Statistics**: The results show that the proportion of girls reporting negative reactions is significantly higher than that of boys.
- **Multivariate Analysis**: After adjusting for other factors such as forced use and the intimacy level of sexual behavior, the research found that:
- Regardless of age differences, girls are more likely to have negative reactions to sexual experiences than boys.
- For girls, age is negatively correlated with negative reactions, while boys' age has no significant impact on their reactions.
- Girls have more negative reactions to perpetrators with a large age gap, while boys are not sensitive to this.
- Girls have more negative reactions to stranger perpetrators than to familiar people, while boys' reactions are the opposite.
### Conclusions
The research results emphasize the importance of gender in the subjective reactions of child sexual abuse victims and point out that ignoring the victim's role will limit the understanding of young people's vulnerability to sexual abuse. In addition, the research also reveals the reaction patterns of adolescents to sexual experiences among peers, providing an important reference for further exploration of adolescent sexual behavior.