Transformation: From Sustainably Productive Agriculture to Industry?
Uma Lele,Manmohan Agarwal,Sambuddha Goswami
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198755173.003.0003
2021-10-15
Abstract:The chapter explores issues of farm size, productivity, and structural transformation, as well as the reasons underlying performance. Productivity growth is crucial to structural transformation, and conventional wisdom held that small farms were more productive than large farms, in terms of yields per hectare. Increasingly, however, there is evidence that farms of all sizes can perform well, particularly when total factor productivity is measured in terms of all factors of production—that is, for farmers of large, medium, and small farms—rather than in terms of land productivity. Similarly, transformation theory has held that manufacturing tends to be more productive than agriculture, explaining migration from agriculture to industry and manufacturing being seen as the escalator of growth, but some evidence suggests agricultural productivity growth can be greater than growth of productivity in the manufacturing sector. Some have questioned the role of smallholder farms, suggesting development policy, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, needs to foster medium and large farms, reallocating factors of production in their favor, as the only way to achieve an increase in overall levels of productivity and food for the burgeoning urban population. The chapter also tests the hypothesis of premature deindustrialization in many low-income and low-middle-income developing countries, including relative rates of growth in agriculture, manufacturing, and the service sector.