Abstract:This study evaluates the applicability of three thermal comfort indices-Physiologically Equivalent Temperature (PET), Standard Effective Temperature (SET), and Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI)-in various outdoor environments on the campus of Xi'an University, China. Meteorological data were collected on sunny days using a portable weather station at a height of 1.5 m, and subjective questionnaires were administered to 25 healthy university students over three months to gather Thermal Sensation Votes (TSV) and Thermal Comfort Votes (TCV). The study was conducted at four distinct outdoor locations: a lakeside area (Location 1), a shaded path (Location 2), a sports field (Location 3), and a plaza (Location 4). PET, SET, and UTCI values were calculated from the collected data using Rayman software. The analysis revealed significant differences in thermal comfort across the four locations, with the highest proportion of subjects feeling hot at the sports field (54.4%) and the highest proportion feeling cold at the lakeside (39%). The shaded path had the highest proportion of subjects feeling comfortable (79.4%), while the lakeside had the lowest (60.1%). The results indicated that SET underestimated thermal sensation at Locations 1, 3, and 4, necessitating calibration. PET was suitable for Locations 2, 3, and 4 but failed to reflect the thermal sensation at Location 1 due to prolonged sun exposure. In contrast, UTCI demonstrated applicability across all locations. To enhance accuracy, revised indices SET' and PET' were formulated using the mean-median method, providing more precise thermal comfort assessments. These findings underscore the limitations of SET and PET under specific conditions and highlight the robustness of UTCI, offering valuable insights for urban planning and design aimed at improving outdoor thermal comfort and well-being.

Re-visitation of the thermal environment evaluation index standard effective temperature (SET*) based on the two-node model

Interpretation of Standard Effective Temperature (SET) and Explorations on Its Modification and Development

Development of the Universal Standard Effective Temperature for Evaluating Thermal Comfort Across Different Metabolic Rates

A Modified Method of the Standard Effective Temperature (SET) Based on the Extended Mean Skin Temperature Index (EMSTI)

Assessing and enhancing the applicability of standard effective temperature in outdoor thermal sensation prediction for continental climates

Applicability of whole-body heat balance models for evaluating thermal sensation under non-uniform air movement in warm environments

Assessing The Natural Ventilation In Architecture

A new approach for measuring predicted mean vote (PMV) and standard effective temperature (SET∗)

Experimental Study on Skin Temperature and Thermal Comfort of the Human Body in A Recumbent Posture under Uniform Thermal Environments

Numerical study on the effects of different reflective rate and evaporative rate of underlaying surfaces on thermal environment inside residential area

Experimental and Numerical Study of Physiological Responses in Hot Environments.

Two Methods for the Evaluation of Human Thermal Comfort under Non-homogeneous Thermal Environment and Their Key Technology

Development of Outdoor Thermal Comfort Model

Evaluation of the convective heat transfer coefficient of human body and its effect on the human thermoregulation predictions

Applicability of elevated air movement for maintaining thermal comfort in warm environments

Developing Predictive Framework for Human Thermal State Based on Multilevel Fuzzy Integrated Assessment Method: Local Thermal Radiation Environments

Method of determining acceptable air temperature thresholds in Chinese HVAC buildings based on a data-driven model

Evaluating thermal comfort indices for outdoor spaces on a university campus

Exploring on the prediction model of human skin temperature and rectal temperature under heat stress

A three-dimensional thermoregulatory model for predicting human thermophysiological responses in various thermal environments

A Multi-Segmented Human Bioheat Model for Asymmetric High Temperature Environments