Abstract:We evaluated the potential role of vertebrate seed predators in limiting recruitment of later‐successional tree species in nine forests actively restored ≥15 years prior and in four paired remnant forest fragments embedded in an agricultural landscape in southern Costa Rica. We found that vertebrate seed predators can substantially reduce later‐successional seedling recruitment in restored forests and should be considered alongside dispersal limitation and microsite conditions as factors slowing forest recovery. The effects of vertebrate seed predation on the regeneration of restored forests are not well understood because most past studies have focused on seed predation within the first few years after restoration and have measured seed removal without quantifying subsequent seedling establishment of seeds that avoid predation. Quantifying the establishment of seeds that escape predation in restored forests at later stages of regrowth is crucial for anticipating longer‐term recovery trajectories. Here, we evaluated the potential role of vertebrate seed predators in limiting recruitment of later‐successional tree species in nine forests actively restored ≥15 years prior and in four paired remnant forest fragments embedded in an agricultural landscape in southern Costa Rica. We conducted seed addition experiments with four tree species inside and outside vertebrate exclosures and used camera trapping to detect seed predators. To determine the fate of seeds that avoided predation, we also measured seedling establishment after 1 year, given that other mortality factors may compensate in the absence of vertebrate seed predation. We detected two species of birds and five species of granivorous mammals removing seeds. Seed tagging indicated that most removal resulted in predation. For three of the four tree species tested, vertebrate seed predation reduced seedling establishment. The magnitude of this effect depended on species' susceptibility to other causes of mortality during the seed‐to‐seedling transition. Our study demonstrates that vertebrate seed predators can substantially reduce later‐successional seedling recruitment in restored forests and should be considered alongside dispersal limitation and microsite conditions as factors slowing forest recovery. in Spanish is available with online material. RESUMEN Los efectos de la depredación de semillas por vertebrados en la regeneración de bosques restaurados no se comprenden bien porque la mayoría de los estudios anteriores se han centrado en la depredación de semillas dentro de los primeros años posteriores a la restauración y han medido la remoción de semillas sin cuantificar el establecimiento de semillas que evitan la depredación. Cuantificar el establecimiento de semillas que escapan a la depredación en bosques restaurados en etapas posteriores es crucial para anticipar trayectorias de recuperación a largo plazo. Evaluamos el papel potencial de los vertebrados depredadores de semillas en la limitación del reclutamiento de especies de árboles de sucesión tardía en nueve bosques restaurados activamente ≥15 años antes y en cuatro fragmentos de bosque remanente dentro de un paisaje agrícola en el sur de Costa Rica. Realizamos experimentos de adición de semillas con cuatro especies de árboles dentro y fuera de jaulas de exclusión para vertebrados y utilizamos cámaras trampa para detectar depredadores de semillas. Para determinar el destino de las semillas que evitaron la depredación, también medimos el establecimiento de plántulas después de un año, dado que otros factores de mortalidad pueden compensar por la ausencia de depredación de semillas por vertebrados. Detectamos dos especies de aves y cinco especies de mamíferos granívoros que removieron semillas. Semillas marcadas con hilo indicaron que la mayor parte de la remoción resultó en depredación. En tres de las cuatro especies de árboles analizadas, la depredación de semillas por vertebrados redujo el establecimiento de plántulas. La magnitud de este efecto dependió de la susceptibilidad de las especies a otras causas de mortalidad durante la transición de semilla a plántula. Nuestro estudio demuestra que los vertebrados depredadores de semillas pueden reducir sustancialmente el reclutamiento de plántulas para especies de sucesión tardía en bosques restaurados y deben considerarse junto con la limitación de la dispersión y las condiciones de micrositios como factores que retrasan la recuperación de bosques.

Spatial patterns of tree recruitment in a montane Hawaiian wet forest after cattle removal and pig population control

Vegetation Recovery 16 Years after Feral Pig Removal from a Wet Hawaiian Forest

Proximity and abundance of mother trees affects recruitment patterns in a long‐term tropical forest restoration study

Regeneration dynamics of major tree species during 2002-2007 in a subtropical evergreen broad-leaved forest in Gutianshan National Nature Reserve in East China

Ecosystem and Restoration Consequences of Invasive Woody Species Removal in Hawaiian Lowland Wet Forest

Vegetation Succession Following Clearcutting of Lowland Hawaiian Rainforest on the Island of Hawai‘i

Effects of large mammal exclusion on seedling communities depend on plant species traits and landscape protection in human‐modified Costa Rican forests

Crossing the threshold: Invasive grasses inhibit forest restoration on Hawaiian islands

Regeneration of tree species after 11 years of canopy gap creation and deer exclusion in a warm temperate broad-leaved forest over-browsed by sika deer

Dynamic and growth of the forests of the Isla del Coco National Park, Costa Rica

Testing applied nucleation as a strategy to facilitate tropical forest recovery

Long-term surveys of ungulates' effects on tree and shrub species in mountainous forests –outcomes and potential limits

Post-fire regeneration strategies contribute to plant growth dynamics and habitat selection in subtropical monsoon fire-prone ecosystem

Inconsistent recovery of nitrogen cycling after feral ungulate removal across three tropical island ecosystems

Multi‐scale habitat selection of key frugivores predicts large‐seeded tree recruitment in tropical forest restoration

Multiple Browsers Structure Tree Recruitment in Logged Temperate Forests

From Stand to Forest: Woody Plant Recruitment in an Andean Restoration Project

Seedling Recruitment in Forests: Calibrating Models to Predict Patterns of Tree Seedling Dispersion

Long-Term Changes in Abundance and Composition of Forest-Floor Small Mammal Communities in a Landscape with Cumulative Clearcutting

Vertebrate seed predation can limit recruitment of later‐successional species in tropical forest restoration

Land cover preferences and spatiotemporal associations of ungulates within a Scottish mammal community