Abstract:We ask whether most species in disturbed habitats fall into similar categories with respect to being strong competitors versus colonizers using a conceptual framework based on how species assemble into plots over time. Our study uses a replicated disturbance experiment, coupled with close tracking of plant cover and native seedlings, as well as a native outplanting experiment, across six dominant vegetation types, including native and invader‐dominated, in old pasture habitats in Hawaiʻi. Our results highlight that the altered states across formerly grazed landscapes in Hawaiʻi are stable to disturbance, and point to the importance of resident communities and their effects on species interactions and seed availability in shaping plant community response to disturbance. Non‐native‐dominated landscapes may arise from invasion by competitive plant species, disturbance and invasion of early‐colonizing species, or some combination of these. Without knowing site history, however, it is difficult to predict how native or non‐native communities will reassemble after disturbance events. Given increasing disturbance levels across anthropogenically impacted landscapes, predictive understanding of these patterns is important. We asked how disturbance affected community assembly in six invaded habitat types common in dryland, grazed landscapes on Island of Hawai'i. We mechanically disturbed 100 m2 plots in six vegetation types dominated by one of four invasive perennial grasses (Cenchrus ciliaris, Cenchrus clandestinus, Cenchrus setaceus, or Melinis repens), a native shrub (Dodonaea viscosa), or a native perennial bunchgrass (Eragrostis atropioides). We censused vegetation before disturbance and monitored woody plant colonization and herbaceous cover for 21 months following the disturbance, categorizing species as competitors, colonizers, or a combination, based on recovery patterns. In addition, we planted individuals of the native shrub and bunchgrass and monitored survival to overcome dispersal limitation of native species when exploring these patterns. We found that the dominant vegetation types showed variation in post‐disturbance syndrome, and that the variation in colonizer versus competitor syndrome occurred both between species, but also within species among different vegetation types. Although there were flushes of native shrub seedlings, these did not survive to 21 months within invaded habitats, probably due to regrowth by competitive invasive grasses. Similarly, survival of planted native individuals was related to the rate of regrowth by dominant species. Regardless of colonization/competitor syndrome, however, all dominant vegetation types were relatively resilient to change. Our results highlight that the altered post‐agricultural, invaded grassland landscapes in Hawaiʻi are stable states. More generally, they point to the importance of resident communities and their effects on species interactions and seed availability in shaping plant community response to disturbance.

Vegetation Succession Following Clearcutting of Lowland Hawaiian Rainforest on the Island of Hawai‘i

Ecosystem and Restoration Consequences of Invasive Woody Species Removal in Hawaiian Lowland Wet Forest

Changes in Community Composition and Functional Traits After Cyclones and Fire in a Pacific Rainforest

Invasive‐dominated grasslands in Hawaiʻi are resilient to disturbance

Vegetation Recovery 16 Years after Feral Pig Removal from a Wet Hawaiian Forest

Differential change in indigenous versus endemic plant cover over time in an invaded Hawaiian landscape

Crossing the threshold: Invasive grasses inhibit forest restoration on Hawaiian islands

Biodiversity recovery of Neotropical secondary forests

Spatial patterns of tree recruitment in a montane Hawaiian wet forest after cattle removal and pig population control

Inconsistent recovery of nitrogen cycling after feral ungulate removal across three tropical island ecosystems

Non-timber Forest Products Survey of Forest Landscape Restoration: A Case Study of Hybrid Ecosystem Restoration in Invaded Hawaiian Forest

The competitive mechanism between post-abandonment Chinese fir plantations and rehabilitated natural secondary forest species under an in situ conservation policy

Functional recovery of secondary tropical forests

Larger fragments have more late‐successional species of woody plants than smaller fragments after 50 years of secondary succession

Height growth and biomass partitioning during secondary succession differ among forest light strata and successional guilds in a tropical rainforest

Community Assembly During Recovery of Tropical Lowland Rain Forest from Abandoned Shifting Cultivation Lands on Hainan Island, China

Forest Structure, Nutrients, and Pentaclethra macroloba Growth after Deforestation of Costa Rican Lowland Forests

Monoculture plantations impede forest recovery: Evidence from the regeneration of lowland subtropical forest in Hong Kong

Shrub Dieback and El Niño Drought in Hawai‘i: Life Stage Demography and Population Rejuvenation

Long‐term stability of tropical forest metacommunities in Puerto Rico: Native and non‐native species

A 60-Year Record of Plant Colonization on Alpine Lava Flows, Maunaloa, Hawai‘i: Climate Change, Substrate Control, and Human Disturbance