Comparative analysis of medial pivot vs. posterior stabilized total knee arthroplasty in patients with valgus deformed osteoarthritic knees: a retrospective cohort study
Kentaro Iwakiri,Yoichi Ohta,Yukihide Minoda,Shuhei Ueno,Akio Kobayashi,Hiroaki Nakamura
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00264-024-06337-8
Abstract:Purpose: Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is highly effective for end-stage knee osteoarthritis, providing long-term benefits and anticipated increased prevalence. The study compares Medial Pivot TKA's (MP-TKA) historical success for varus deformities with recent findings suggesting comparable outcomes for valgus deformities. Despite prevalent use of Posterior Stabilized TKA (PS-TKA) for valgus deformities, this research explores the unexplored comparative efficacy of MP-TKA vs. PS-TKA in knee osteoarthritis patients with valgus deformity. Methods: This single-centre cohort study focused on 57 knees in 53 patients undergoing TKA for knee osteoarthritis with valgus deformity. Conducted between January 2013 and April 2021, the study compared MP-TKA and PS-TKA. Surgeries adhered to a medial parapatellar approach and modified gap technique, with perioperative interventions for pain, bleeding, and swelling. Outcome measurements included knee joint range of motion, radiographic evaluation, patients-reported outcomes, operative time, blood laboratory tests, estimated blood loss, and postoperative adverse events, and analyzed between the two groups. Results: Postoperative hip-knee-ankle angles showed no significant difference between MP-TKA and PS-TKA. The pie crust technique was similarly used in both groups, and deformity correction showed no significant difference. Range of motion and clinical outcomes, measured by WOMAC and JOA scores, were comparable postoperatively. MP-TKA had a shorter surgical duration (p = 0.01), and PS-TKA exhibited higher estimated blood loss (p = 0.01) without significant complications in either group. Conclusions: This pioneering study compares the outcomes of MP TKA and PS TKA in patients with valgus-deformed osteoarthritic knees. Compared to PS TKA, MP TKA shows a prolonged operative duration and increased blood loss, likely due to the requirement for patellar replacement. However, postoperative range of motion and clinical outcomes are similar. Both groups exhibit favorable midterm clinical results, supporting the viability of MP TKA for valgus deformed knees. The study, consistent in surgical approach, highlights MP TKA's effectiveness for valgus deformities.