Simulation can replace part of speech-language pathology placement time: A randomised controlled trial

Anne E. Hill,Elizabeth Ward,Robert Heard,Sue McAllister,Patricia McCabe,Adriana Penman,Emma Caird,Danielle Aldridge,Stacey Baldac,Elizabeth Cardell,Rachel Davenport,Bronwyn Davidson,Sally Hewat,Simone Howells,Alison Purcell,Joanne Walters
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17549507.2020.1722238
2020-02-25
Abstract:<span><i>Purpose:</i> Simulation is increasingly used within speech-language pathology education. Research has primarily explored students' perceptions of learning in simulation. The aim of this study was to determine if speech-language pathology students achieved a statistically-equivalent level of competency when a mean of 20% of placement time was replaced with simulation compared to placements without a simulation component.<i>Method:</i> This non-inferiority randomised controlled trial involved students from six Australian universities. Students were randomised to either a simulation + traditional placement group attending 5 days of simulation prior to their traditional placement, or a traditional only placement group. Their end-placement clinical competency was assessed using Competency Assessment in Speech Pathology (COMPASS<sup>®</sup>).<i>Result:</i> Final data were available for 325 students: 150 students in traditional placements, 138 students in protocol-compliant simulation + traditional placements, and 37 students in non-protocol simulation + traditional placements. There were no statistically significant differences between groups (traditional vs protocol-compliant simulation + traditional Mann–Whitney–Wilcoxon <i>z</i> = 1.23, <i>df</i> = 286, <i>p</i> = 0.22; traditional vs intention-to-treat simulation + traditional Mann–Whitney–Wilcoxon <i>z</i> = 0.23, <i>df</i> = 323, <i>p</i> = 0.81).<i>Conclusion:</i> This research contributes to the evidence base which suggests that simulation can partially replace traditional placement time for speech-language pathology students without loss of competency, substantiating its value as an alternative placement model in speech-language pathology programmes.</span>
rehabilitation,audiology & speech-language pathology,linguistics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?