Abstract:In conditionally automated driving, drivers are required to respond to takeover requests (TORs) and resume manual driving of the vehicle in situations where the conditionally automated driving systems are ineffective. Prior to TORs, the driver may be engaged in Non-Driving Related Tasks (NDRTs), and their manual driving performance after the takeover transition (post-automation) may require time to return to normal. This study investigated the influences of NDRTs on manual driving performance during the post-automation period. Seventeen volunteers participated in this driving simulator study. There were three NDRTs: writing business emails (working condition), watching videos (entertaining condition), and taking a break with eyes closed (resting condition). The duration of engagement in each NDRT before resuming manual driving was either 5 min (short interval) or 30 min (long interval). When TORs were made, drivers were given 10 s (TOR lead time) to switch from an NDRT to manual driving and then continue driving on a straight highway for 5 min. The results demonstrated that driving performance was impaired during the post-automation period. A significant detrimental effect on driving performance was observed for all three NDRT conditions and both task engagement durations. This effect was particularly evident for lane control, where drivers on average spent 4–8 s per minute outside of their lane for each of the five minutes following the TOR. These results indicate that driver engagement in other tasks, even for brief periods, can increase accident risk during the minutes following a TOR. Analysis of individual driving performance revealed a subset of 5 drivers who were strongly impaired, spending 10–25 s per minute outside of their lane throughout the post-automation period. These unsafe drivers could be accurately identified from their driving behaviour during the pre-automation (control) period. Surprisingly, participants were unaware that their degraded driving performance following the takeover. These findings extend the understanding of the disruptive effect of cognitive set-switching while driving and have important implications for the design and safety of autonomous vehicles.

Effects of Unreliable Automation, Non-Driving Related Task, and Takeover Time Budget on Drivers’ Takeover Performance and Workload

Transition in Different Critical Situations: How Non-Driving Related Tasks Affect Drivers’ Physiological Response and Takeover Behavior after Partial Automation Silent Failures

Evaluating Effects of Cognitive Load, Takeover Request Lead Time, and Traffic Density on Drivers’ Takeover Performance in Conditionally Automated Driving

Effects of non-driving-related tasks on takeover performance in different takeover situations in conditionally automated driving

Promote or inhibit: An inverted U-shaped effect of workload on driver takeover performance

Effects of non-driving related postures on takeover performance during conditionally automated driving

Effects of Non-Driving Related Task Modalities on Takeover Performance in Highly Automated Driving

Measuring Takeover Performance in Different Driving Scenarios: Considering the Influence of Non-Driving-Related Tasks and Takeover Request Lead Time

Effect of Similar Cognitive Secondary Tasks Under Different Levels on Takeover Performance within Various Time Windows for Transition Control from Automated to Manual Driving

Influence of non-driving related tasks on driving performance after takeover transition in conditionally automated driving

Measuring drivers’ takeover performance in varying levels of automation: Considering the influence of cognitive secondary task

A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Takeover Performance During Conditionally Automated Driving

Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving

Takeover Performance and Workload under Varying Automation Levels, Time Budget and Road Curvature

Physiological Indicators of Driver Workload During Car-Following Scenarios and Takeovers in Highly Automated Driving

Is driving experience all that matters? Drivers' takeover performance in conditionally automated driving

Analyzing the Influencing Factors and Workload Variation of Takeover Behavior in Semi-Autonomous Vehicles

Effects of non-driving related tasks on readiness to take over control in conditionally automated driving

A Study on the Entire Take-Over Process-Based Emergency Obstacle Avoidance Behavior

Evaluation of Imminent Take-Over Requests With Real Automation on a Test Track

The Effects of Lead Time of Take-Over Request and Nondriving Tasks on Taking-Over Control of Automated Vehicles