Building a theory by induction: The example of goal setting theory

Edwin A. Locke,Gary P. Latham

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2041386620921931

2020-05-05

Organizational Psychology Review

Abstract:This article discusses the development of goal setting theory through induction. The processes such as formulating concepts and definitions, measurement issues, data gathering, data integration and presentation, identifying moderators and mediators, resolving contradictions, noting issues in application, expansions and extensions, and the role of induction in deduction are explained. A multi-decade effort that involves these processes led to a useful theory that has withstood the test of time.

psychology, applied,management

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to construct an effective theory through induction, especially the Goal Setting Theory (GST). The authors discuss various steps and challenges involved in the development of GST, including the formation of concepts and definitions, measurement problems, data collection, data analysis and presentation, identification of moderating and mediating variables, resolving contradictions, problems in application, and the role of induction in deduction.

### Main problems

1. **Basis of theory construction**:
- Previous studies mostly relied on single or a small number of experimental results and lacked systematicity and extensive verification. This has led to some theories (such as the hierarchy of needs theory, X - Y theory, etc.) failing to last due to lack of strong empirical support.
- The authors emphasize the importance of extracting scientific principles from a large amount of empirical data through induction to ensure the practicality and predictive ability of the theory.

2. **Application of induction**:
- Induction is a method of generalizing from specific instances to general laws. The authors point out that induction plays an important role in theory construction because it can summarize generally applicable principles from a large number of observations and experiments.
- Specifically, GST is based on 25 years of accumulated data, which are integrated into scientific principles, thus forming a theory that can stand the test of time.

3. **Specific steps of theory construction**:
- **Concepts and definitions**: Defining core concepts and definitions clearly is the starting point of theory construction. For example, in GST, the definition of "goal" is the object or purpose of an action and is used as a standard for measuring performance.
- **Measurement problems**: Ensure that the measurement tools are logically consistent with the concept definitions and avoid confounding irrelevant variables.
- **Data collection and replication**: Emphasize the importance of variability and verify the universality of the theory through repeated experiments under different conditions.
- **Moderating and mediating variables**: Identify the conditions and mechanisms that affect the effectiveness of the theory. For example, feedback, commitment, task knowledge, and situational resources are all important moderating variables in GST.
- **Resolving contradictions**: Analyze studies that do not support the theory, find out possible reasons, and further improve the theory.

4. **Problems in application**:
- The theory must provide specific application guidelines. For example, GST recommends setting challenging but achievable goals and considering employees' abilities and resources.
- In response to criticism (such as encouraging cheating and causing tunnel vision), the authors propose solutions, emphasizing ethical culture and multi - faceted management measures.

### Summary

This paper aims to explore how to construct an effective and practical theory through induction, especially GST. By discussing in detail the various steps and challenges of theory construction, the authors show how GST extracts scientific principles from a large amount of empirical data and is successfully applied in practical situations.