The convergence history of India-Eurasia records multiple subduction dynamics processes

Adina E Pusok,Dave R Stegman,Adina E. Pusok,Dave R. Stegman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaz8681

IF: 13.6

2020-05-08

Science Advances

Abstract:Reunion plume push set in motion a sequence of events speeding up India, starting with initiation of double subduction.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

India–Eurasia convergence speed-up by passive-margin sediment subduction

Hao Zhou,Jiashun Hu,Luca Dal Zilio,Ming Tang,Keqing Li,Xiumian Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-08069-6

IF: 64.8

2024-11-07

Nature

Abstract:The fast increase of convergence rate between India and Eurasia around 65 million years ago (Ma)—from approximately 8 cm yr −1 to a peak rate of approximately 18 cm yr −1 —remains a complex geological event to explain 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 , given the inherent uncertainty surrounding the tectonic history and the intricate interplay of forces influencing plate speed 9,10,11 . Here we use a combination of geochemical analysis and geodynamic modelling to propose that this rapid convergence can be explained by sediment subduction derived from the northern Indian passive margin. Through isotope and trace element analysis, we find an enhanced contribution of terrigenous sediment melt to the mantle source of the Gangdese magmatic rocks around 65 Ma, concurrent with the acceleration of India–Eurasia convergence. Numerical experiments suggest that subduction of sediments more than 1 km thick covering an approximately 1,000-km-wide ocean basin abutting the northern Indian passive margin starting from 65 Ma could have spurred the increased convergence rate and further led to significant crustal extension, consistent with empirical observations. Our study implies that the acceleration of India–Eurasia convergence marks the arrival of passive-margin-derived sediments, constraining the initial India–Eurasia collision to be around 60 Ma. It further suggests that temporary accelerations in subduction rates might be a common feature at the final stage of continental assembly.

multidisciplinary sciences
From Rodinia to Pangea: an Extroversion Process Driven First by Plume Push Followed by Downwelling Pull, Absorption and Merging

Zheng-Xiang Li,William Collins,Lei Wu,Sergei Pisarevsky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu2020-12348

2020-01-01

Abstract:Numerous works also suggested that mantle plumes or mantle upwellings associated with LLSVPs in a degree-2 mantle state play a major role in driving the break-up of a supercontinent. However, subduction and mantle downwelling may play an increasing role in the leadup to the assembly of the next supercontinent. Anderson (1994) noticed that continents tend to gather at mantle downwelling zones, which was later developed into the hypothesis of orthoversion assembly of supercontinents by Mitchell (2012). Zhong et al. (2007) conceptualised the assembly of supercontinents through the merger or absorption of mantle downwellings, leading to the assembly of supercontinents over a superdownwelling in a degree-1 mantle. Here we present a revised global paleogeographic reconstruction featuring an extroversion assembly of Pangea (i.e. through the closure of the Mirovoi superocean) over a pre-existing yet dynamic mantle downwelling zone (Li et al., 2019). In particular, we show that the Paleozoic world was dominated by two major subduction (dowelling) cells, one associated with the newly assembled Gondwana, and the other associated with the assembly of Laurasia. The two cells gradually merged together by the Carboniferous time, forming the supercontinent Pangea over a mantle superdownwelling (Zhang et al., 2010). It was during the merger of the two dowelling cells that continental and arc terranes was successively transported from Gondwana margin to future Laurasia.References:Anderson, D.L., 1994. Superplume or supercontinents? Geology 22, 39-42.Huang, C., Zhang, N., Li, Z.-X., Ding, M., Dang, Z., Pourteau, A., Zhong, S., 2019. Modeling the Inception of Supercontinent Breakup: Stress State and the Importance of Orogens. Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems 20, 4830-4848.Li, Z.X., Mitchell, R.N., Spencer, C.J., Ernst, R., Pisarevsky, S., Kirscher, U., Murphy, J.B., 2019. Decoding Earth’s rhythms: Modulation of supercontinent cycles by longer superocean episodes. Precambrian Research 323, 1-5.Mitchell, R.N., Kilian, T.M., Evans, D.A.D., 2012. Supercontinent cycles and the calculation of absolute palaeolongitude in deep time. Nature 482, 208-211.Zhang, N., Zhong, S., Leng, W., Li, Z.-X., 2010. A model for the evolution of the Earth's mantle structure since the Early Paleozoic. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 115, B06401.Zhong, S., Zhang, N., Li, Z.-X., Roberts, J.H., 2007. Supercontinent cycles, true polar wander, and very long-wavelength mantle convection. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 261, 551-564.
Triple-stage India-Asia collision involving arc-continent collision and subsequent two-stage continent-continent collision

Jie Yuan,Chenglong Deng,Zhenyu Yang,Wout Krijgsman,Thubtantsering,Huafeng Qin,Zhongshan Shen,Yifei Hou,Shuai Zhang,Zhiqiang Yu,Pan Zhao,Liang Zhao,Bo Wan,Huaiyu He,Zhengtang Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloplacha.2022.103821

IF: 4.956

2022-05-01

Global and Planetary Change

Abstract:The enigmatic geodynamic processes involved in the India-Asia collision shape our understanding of uplift and deformation of the Tibetan Plateau and the subsequent changes in the land-sea distribution pattern, monsoon-arid environments and biotic evolution in Central Asia. However, the current geodynamic models dealing with the India-Asia collision history exhibit significant discrepancies in how, when and where exactly the collision of India with Asia occurred. Recently, we proposed a new hypothesis that favored the opening and closure of a North India Sea during the late Cretaceous to Paleogene. Here we present new additional paleomagnetic data from the red siliceous shales and cherts of the Sangdanlin Formation, which were deposited on the most distal continental margin of the Tethyan Himalaya terrane, i.e. the southern margin of the Neo-Tethys Ocean, during the middle Paleocene. The combination of our new and previously reported paleomagnetic data shows that the Tethyan Himalaya was at a paleolatitude of 14.1° ± 1.9°N during the interval 62.5–59.2 Ma and refines the maximum size of the North India Sea to about 2200 ± 500 km. Combining our geodynamic model with recently published paleomagnetic data from the Kohistan-Ladakh arc, we conclude that the India-Asia collision was a triple-stage process, which involved an arc-continent collision followed by a two-stage continent-continent collision. The arc-continent collision occurred at ca. 64 Ma between the Tibetan Himalaya (Tethyan Himalaya plus Greater Himalaya) and the Trans-Tethyan subduction zone at a paleolatitude of ~8°N. The initial continent-continent collision took place at ca. 61 Ma between the Tibetan Himalaya (plus the accreted Trans-Tethyan subduction zone) and Lhasa terranes at a paleolatitude of ~14°N. The final continent-continent collision occurred during 53–47 Ma between India and the Tibetan Himalaya, diachronously suturing the North India Sea from west to east. The triple-stage collision scenario is in agreement with the history of India-Asia convergence rates, and is reflected by the presence of three slab remnants below Tibet and India as documented by seismic tomographic imaging. Our updated collision scenario reconciles multidisciplinary evidence for the India-Asia collision and provides better constraints on the resulting paleoclimatic and paleoenvironmental changes in Central-Eastern Asia.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,geography, physical
Rapid Drift Of The Tethyan Himalaya Terrane Before Two-Stage India-Asia Collision

Jie Yuan,Zhenyu Yang,Chenglong Deng,Wout Krijgsman,Xiumian Hu,Shihu Li,Zhongshan Shen,Huafeng Qin,Wei An,Huaiyu He,Lin Ding,Zhengtang Guo,Rixiang Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/nsr/nwaa173

IF: 20.6

2021-01-01

National Science Review

Abstract:The India-Asia collision is an outstanding smoking gun in the study of continental collision dynamics. How and when the continental collision occurred remains a long-standing controversy. Here we present two new paleomagnetic data sets from rocks deposited on the distal part of the Indian passive margin, which indicate that the Tethyan Himalaya terrane was situated at a paleolatitude of similar to 19.4 degrees S at similar to 75Ma and moved rapidly northward to reach a paleolatitude of similar to 13.7 degrees N at similar to 61Ma. This implies that the Tethyan Himalaya terrane rifted from India after similar to 75Ma, generating the North India Sea. We document a new two-stage continental collision, first at similar to 61Ma between the Lhasa and Tethyan Himalaya terranes, and subsequently at similar to 53-48Ma between the Tethyan Himalaya terrane and India, diachronously closing the North India Sea from west to east. Our scenario matches the history of India-Asia convergence rates and reconciles multiple lines of geologic evidence for the collision.
Microcontinent subduction and S-type volcanism prior to India–Asia collision

Zongyao Yang,Juxing Tang,M. Santosh,Xiaoyan Zhao,Xinghai Lang,Ying Wang,Shuai Ding,Fengqin Ran

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-94492-y

IF: 4.6

2021-07-21

Scientific Reports

Abstract:Abstract Continental crust has long been considered too buoyant to be subducted beneath another continent, although geophysical evidence in collision zones predict continental crust subduction. This is particularly significant where upper continental crust is detached allowing the lower continental crust to subduct, albeit the mechanism of such subduction and recycling of the upper continental crust remain poorly understood. Here, we investigate Paleocene S-type magmatic and volcanic rocks from the Linzizong volcanic succession in the southern Lhasa block of Tibet. These rocks exhibit highly enriched 87 Sr/ 86 Sr, 207 Pb/ 206 Pb and 208 Pb/ 206 Pb together with depleted 143 Nd/ 144 Nd isotope ratios. The geochemical and isotopic features of these rocks are consistent with those of modern upper continental crust. We conclude that these Paleocene S-type volcanic and magmatic rocks originated from the melting of the upper continental crust from microcontinent subduction during the late stage of India–Asia convergence.

multidisciplinary sciences
Two-stage eastward diachronous model of India-Eurasia collision: Constraints from the intraplate tectonic records in Northeast Indian Ocean

Yanhui Suo,Sanzhong Li,Xianzhi Cao,Hao Dong,Xiyao Li,Xinyu Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gr.2020.01.006

IF: 6.1

2022-02-01

Gondwana Research

Abstract:<p>The onset of timing and the model of the India-Eurasia collision are strongly debated based on continental works, without systematic marine tectonic constraints. Two aseismic ridges, the Laccadives-Maldives-Chagos Ridge (LMCR) formed after the Deccan volcanism in western India and the Ninetyeast Ridge (NER) formed after the emplacement of the Rajmahal Traps in eastern India are prominent features in the Northeast Indian Ocean. The onset of a major and steady increase in magma production rates along the aseismic ridge associated with the significant slowdown of the northward moving Indian Plate is a likely indicator of the onset of the India-Eurasia collision. Using gravity-derived crustal thickness, we calculated the magma production rates along the LMCR and the NER, respectively. The steady increasing magma production rate along the LMCR and a southwestward jump of the Central Indian Ridge constrained the "soft" (India-island arc) and "hard" (India-Eurasia) collisions between western India and Eurasia to 50–52 Ma and ~41 Ma, respectively. The steady increasing magma production rate along the NER and the formation of the Mammerickx Microplate constrained the soft collision between eastern India and Eurasia to 47–49 Ma, and the extinction of the Wharton Ridge constrained the hard collision between eastern India and Eurasia to 38 Ma. Both the soft and hard collisions between western India and Eurasia are ~3 Myr earlier than the soft and hard collisions between eastern India and Eurasia, respectively. With systematic marine tectonic constraints, a two-stage eastward diachronous model of the India-Eurasia collision was proposed.</p>

geosciences, multidisciplinary
Dynamic evolution of competing same-dip double subduction: New perspectives of the Neo-Tethyan plate tectonics

Arnab Roy,Nibir Mandal,Jeroen Van Hunen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsl.2024.119032

IF: 5.3

2024-10-07

Earth and Planetary Science Letters

Abstract:Same-dip double-subduction (SDDS) systems are widely reported from present as well as past complex convergent plate tectonic configurations. However, the dynamics of their evolution is poorly understood, which is crucial to conceptualize anomalous subducting slab kinematics and associated observed geological phenomena, such as irregular trench migration rates, high convergence velocities, and slab break-off. To bridge this gap, we develop dynamic thermo-mechanical subduction models and investigate the initiation and evolution of SDDS systems, considering three different initial plate configurations: oceanic, oceanic-continental and multiple continental settings, based on Neo-Tethyan paleo-reconstructions. Each model offers new insights into the complex tectonic history of the major Neo-Tethyan subduction zones, particularly the Indo–Eurasian and Andaman convergent systems. We evaluate the slab-slab interactions, trench and subduction kinematics, inter-plate reorganization, and temporally varying mantle flow patterns involved in the dynamic evolution of these SDDS systems. The oceanic SDDS model simulations reveal that a sizable oceanic plate can initiate two subduction zones synchronously, and they evolve unequally in a competing mode, leading to exceptionally high convergence rates (∼16–17 cm/year) for a prolonged duration (∼7–8 Myr). This finding explains the coeval activity of coupled subduction zones in the Indo-Eurasia convergence during the Cretaceous evolution of the Neo-Tethys. We further implement a corresponding single subduction model to assess the additional effects of competing slab kinematics in an oceanic SDDS setting. The ocean-continent SDDS model, on the other hand, localizes subduction preferentially at passive margins between the oceanic plate and the continental block, forming double subduction zones that grow almost equally to form a spreading centre between the two trenches. These model results allow to reconstruct the Cenozoic evolution of the eastern Neo-Tethyan region, which ultimately led to the development of the Andaman subduction zone. We also show the post-Cretaceous evolution of the Indo–Eurasian collision zone as a consequence of the SDDS dynamics in presence of multiple continental blocks. These dynamics facilitated slab break-off, transforming the SDDS into a single subduction system in a relatively short time frame (∼3 Myr). We finish with a synthesis of the paleo-reconstructions of the Neo-Tethys in the perspective of these SDDS models.

geochemistry & geophysics
Metamorphic densification can account for the missing felsic crust of the Greater Indian continent

Yang Wang,Lifei Zhang,Zhong-Hai Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-022-00493-8

2022-01-01

Communications Earth & Environment

Abstract:The long-duration, fast convergence, and imbalance of crustal mass in the India-Asia collisional system challenge the classical rules of continental dynamics. Here, we calculate the mass deficit of felsic crust in Greater India indicating ~20–47% of the felsic crust is missing during collision. Phase equilibria modeling and density calculations demonstrate the pressure-temperature-dependent density of felsic crust is denser than the surrounding mantle at P > 7–8 GPa. Integrated petrological-thermo-mechanical models and analytical studies of the slab-pull forces confirm the Greater Indian continent with its felsic crust can subduct spontaneously under its own negative buoyancy when it is dragged to >170 km by the preceding oceanic slab. The great slab-pull force, induced by the negative buoyancy of subducted crust below 170 km, not only contributes to the long-lasting fast convergence between India and Asia but also explains the crustal mass imbalance during the Himalayan orogeny.
The Mystery Deepens: Anomalously Fast Speed of the Indian Lithospheric Plate - A Review

U. Raval

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17491/jgsi/2024/173937

2024-07-01

Journal of the Geological Society of India

Abstract:ABSTRACT During certain time windows of the late Cretaceous and early Tertiary the Indian plate travelled northward from deep south with exceptionally fast speed reaching around 15–18 to ~22 cm/yr. This is indeed intriguing and enigmatic because velocities of all other major tectonic plates, in comparison, do not exceed ~7–8 cm/yr and hence the high mobility of the Indian plate remains somewhat mysterious. This study discusses the various efforts carried out during the past four decades, which are aimed at understanding the processes/forces behind this rapid drift of India. On the basis of marine magnetic survey, deep drilling and numerical models, a number of potential causes have been put forward. Some of the important observations that emerged from these studies are, (i) delineation of multi-phase subduction systems within the India-Asia collision corridor, (ii) occurrence of upwelling of more than one mantle plumes and their push force, (iii) anti-correlated velocities of the Indian and African plates and their coupling with the Reunion mantle plume, and (iv) role of mantle plume in the initiation of subduction or convergent margin that implies initiation of the plate tectonics itself. These studies suggest a number of potential causes that could impart the observed high acceleration to the Indian plate. These include lithospheric thinning and geophysical/geochemical characteristics of the Indian plate, weakening of the litho-asthenospheric coupling and the coupling of mantle plume and double subduction. During the past decade, continued addition of concepts and ideas that negate/compliment/supplement preceding studies, comprehend the forces responsible for India’s rapid drift. It is significant to note that most of these suggestions have come up, in quick succession, thus making the unfoldment of this research highly engrossing and interesting.

geosciences, multidisciplinary
India Indenting Eurasia: A Brief Review and New Data from the Yongping Basin on the SE Tibetan Plateau

Tiannan Yang,Zhen Yan,Chuandong Xue,Di Xin,Mengmeng Dong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences11120518

2021-12-17

Geosciences

Abstract:Successive indentations of Eurasia by India have led to the Tibet-Himalaya E–W orthogonal collision belt and the SE Tibetan Plateau N–S oblique collision belt along the frontal and eastern edges of the indenter, respectively. The belts exhibit distinctive lithospheric structures and tectonic evolutions. A comprehensive compilation of available geological and geophysical data reveals two sudden tectonic transitions in the early Eocene and the earliest Miocene, respectively, of the tectonic evolution of the orthogonal belt. Synthesizing geological and geochronological data helps us to suggest a NEE–SWW trending, ~450 km-long, ~250 km-wide magmatic zone in SE Tibet, which separates the oblique collision belt (eastern and SE Tibet) into three segments of distinctive seismic structures including the mantle and crust anisotropies. The newly identified Yongping basin is located in the central part of the magmatic zone. Geochronological and thermochronological data demonstrate that (1) this basin and the magmatic zone started to form at ~48 Ma likely due to NNW–SSE lithosphere stretching according to the spatial coincidence of the concentrated mantle-sourced igneous rocks on the surface with the seismic anomalies at depth; and (2) its fills was shortened in the E–W direction since ~23 Ma. These two dates correspond to the onset of the first and second tectonic transitions of the orthogonal collision belt. As such, both the orthogonal and oblique belts share a single time framework of their tectonic evolution. By synthesizing geological and geophysical data of both collision belts, the indenting process can be divided into three stages separated by two tectonic transitions. Continent–continent collision as a piston took place exclusively during the second stage. During the other two stages, the India lithosphere underthrust beneath Eurasia.
Where is the missing felsic crust of Greater Indian continent?

Lifei Zhang,Yang Wang,Zhong-Hai Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-227521/v1

2021-01-01

Abstract:Abstract According to the plate tectonics theory, continental crust (CC), especially the felsic upper and middle continental crust (UCC and MCC), cannot subduct due to its buoyancy. Therefore, most, if not all, of the felsic crustal mass will be preserved in continental collision zones or eroded by the surface process. Consequently, the continent-continent convergence is generally slower and more short-lived than oceanic plate subduction. However, the long-duration, fast convergence, and imbalance of crustal mass in the India-Asia collisional system challenge the classical rules of plate tectonics. Systematic compilation and calculations indicate ~20-47% of the felsic crust in Greater India is missing during collision. Based on the phase equilibria modeling and density calculations, we explore the pressure-temperature-dependent density evolutions of UCC and MCC and demonstrate they are denser than the surrounding mantle at P >7-8 GPa when the phase transition from coesite to stishovite occurs. The phase equilibria induced density evolution is further integrated into the thermo-mechanical model, which confirm the deep subduction of Greater Indian continent with its felsic UCC and MCC. Analytical studies of the slab-pull forces in the subduction zone indicate the Greater Indian continent can subduct spontaneously under its own negative buoyancy when it is dragged to a depth of ~170 km by the preceding oceanic slab. The great slab-pull force, induced by the negative buoyancy of UCC and MCC below 170 km, not only contributes to the long-lasting fast convergence between India and Asia, but also explains the crustal mass imbalance during the Himalayan orogeny.
Intermittent Post‐Paleocene Continental Collision in South Asia

Liang Liu,Lijun Liu,Yi‐Gang Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2021gl094531

IF: 5.2

2021-07-22

Geophysical Research Letters

Abstract:Three different conceptual models have been proposed for the Cenozoic subduction style in South Asia, including Greater India, Intra‐oceanic Arc, and Continental Terrane (or Greater Indian basin). Since these models imply distinctive origins for the Tethyan–Greater Himalayan (TGH) sequences, for example, as a relic of the subducted Greater India or Gondwana–affiliated continental terrane, quantitively reproducing the relic TGH crustal mass with numerical models could help further constrain the debated Cenozoic subduction history between India and Eurasia. Based on the modeling results, we show that the subducted plate since the Paleocene should consist of a significant oceanic portion that is, ∼1,000 km long for the Intra‐oceanic Arc model and up to 2,000 km long for the Terrane model. Our results do not support the existence of a continuous >3,000 km long continental Greater India before the early Eocene collision in South Asia. Approximately 55 million years ago, the Indian Subcontinent was in the Southern Hemisphere, >3,000 km away from Tibet. However, it remains unknown what tectonic units were between them. Previous studies suggest that this region was composed of either pure land or with parts being oceans. By now, this region has mostly foundered into the deep Earth, with its surface relics forming the Himalayan Mountains. Because land and ocean contribute differently to the relic materials, the mass of the Himalayan Mountain can provide essential information about this lost tectonic region. This study uses numerical models to replicate the relic Himalayan mass while evaluating the earlier proposed models. We found that to match the Himalayan mass, the region between Tibet and India ∼55 million years ago could not be purely continental and should include >1,000 km long oceanic plate. Different models of Cenozoic subduction history in South Asia imply distinctive origins for the Tethyan–Greater Himalayan sequences Quantitively reproducing the Tethyan–Greater Himalayan mass helps constrain the Cenozoic subduction history in South Asia Both the Intra‐oceanic Arc and Terrane models, but not the Greater India model, could have been operating during the Cenozoic subduction Different models of Cenozoic subduction history in South Asia imply distinctive origins for the Tethyan–Greater Himalayan sequences Quantitively reproducing the Tethyan–Greater Himalayan mass helps constrain the Cenozoic subduction history in South Asia Both the Intra‐oceanic Arc and Terrane models, but not the Greater India model, could have been operating during the Cenozoic subduction

geosciences, multidisciplinary
Latest Cretaceous Himalayan Tectonics: Obduction, Collision or Deccan-Related Uplift?

Eduardo Garzanti,Xiumian Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gr.2014.03.010

IF: 6.1

2015-01-01

Gondwana Research

Abstract:Diverging interpretations and incompatible scenarios have been proposed for the early stages of Himalayan history. Numerous researchers have postulated that northern India was involved in ophiolite obduction, arc–continent, or continent–continent collision during the Late Cretaceous or Early Paleocene, but firm geological evidence was never produced. In this article we argue against orogenic events predating the Late Paleocene, when the Neotethys Ocean was still open. The Tethys Himalayan sedimentary record testifies to anorogenic evolution, primarily controlled by dynamic uplift of the passive margin prior to the massive outburst of Deccan lavas and eventually followed by thermal subsidence. Major stratigraphic gaps in pelagic sediments suggest that such tectono-magmatic episode started to affect the base of the Indian Plate in the Campanian or possibly even in the Santonian, 10 to 20Ma before the climax of Deccan flood-basalt eruptions. The abrupt increase in siliciclastic supply and accumulation rates recorded in sedimentary basins all around the Indian subcontinent during the Maastrichtian was followed by progradation of coastal quartzarenites along the northern Indian margin in the Early Paleocene. Sandstones derived from the rejuvenated craton and uplifted inner continental margin in the south are dominantly but not exclusively quartzose. Felsitic volcanic rock fragments and Cr-spinels, many of which with the same geochemical fingerprint as Deccan spinels and newly found throughout the Maastrichtian to Danian succession, resisted the combined effect of subequatorial weathering and subsequent diagenesis, and testify that detritus from Deccan basalts reached the Indian passive margin as far as South Tibet. At the close of the Early Paleocene India drifted away from the Seychelles block, and thermal subsidence led to widespread carbonate deposition along the Tethys Himalaya. This article illustrates how mega-events of magmatic upwelling followed by lithospheric cooling may control passive-margin sedimentation and stratigraphic patterns, as occurred in northern India first in the Early Cretaceous and next in the latest Cretaceous/Paleocene.
Intraoceanic Subduction System Within the Neo‐Tethys: Evidence from Late Cretaceous Arc Magmatic Rocks of the Eastern Himalaya

Zeming Zhang,Wentao An,Richard M. Palin,Huixia Ding,Xin Dong,Zuolin Tian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2023gc011214

2023-01-01

Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems

Abstract:Abstract The tectonic evolution of the Neo‐Tethys Ocean remains highly controversial, with several models existing in the community that conflict with each other. Here, we present new geochronologic and geochemical data for orthogneisses and amphibolites from the Greater Himalayan Sequence, eastern Himalayan orogen, which indicate that these rocks have Cenozoic metamorphic ages (∼52–3 Ma), but were derived from Late Cretaceous (∼89 Ma) magmas with arc‐like and depleted mantle geochemical signatures. Considering that northern India was a passive continental margin during the Mesozoic, and the previously reported Late Cretaceous magmatic rocks in the eastern Himalaya formed in a continental rifting setting, we suggest that the studied Late Cretaceous arc‐type magmatic rocks formed in an intraoceanic arc setting within the Neo‐Tethys, and accreted onto the passive margin of the Indian continent prior to the terminal continental collision. When combined with the existence of Late Mesozoic and intraoceanic arc‐type magmatic rocks in the western Himalaya, we suggest that a huge Late Cretaceous subduction system operated within the eastern Neo‐Tethys Ocean. This study supports two subduction zones having been responsible for the consumption and closure of the Neo‐Tethys basin, and a two‐stage collision history between India, Asia, and the intermediate island arc system. Our data therefore provide important constraints on the evolution of the Neo‐Tethys Ocean and India‐Asia collisional orogeny in southern Tibet.
Impact of Kerguelen, Marion, and Reunion plumes on the ophiolitic obduction at the northern margin of Indian plate

Amarjeet R. Bhagat,S.J. Sangode,Ashish Dongre

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gr.2023.10.018

IF: 6.1

2024-04-01

Gondwana Research

Abstract:Geochronological data compiled for 29 major ophiolitic occurrences from the northern margin of the Indian plate precisely coincide with the three major mantle plume interactions over Indian plate (viz., Kerguelen at 130–110 Ma, Marion at 90–84 Ma, and Reunion at 65–70 Ma). We analysed i) the geological juxtapositions of these ophiolitic belts, ii) seismic tomographic imaging of the slab breakoffs, iii) equivalent deflections in the marine magnetic anomalies (MMA), iv) stratigraphic records of the Cretaceous formations and v) the paleomagnetic inclination anomalies; and propose significant influence of plume-driven forces over the subduction and obduction processes in Himalayas. The impingement of Kerguelen plume strongly influenced the ∼ 2500 km long subduction of Neo-Tethys, leading to Indus-Tsangpo-Suture-Zone (ITSZ) ophiolites with their metamorphic soles. The impact of Marion plume further led to repeated tilting of the Indian plate reinvigorating Tethyan subduction at 90 ± 5 Ma. The Reunion event at ∼ 65 Ma, led to the mega-obduction along the Tethyan margin of the Indian subcontinent. The Kerguelen plume thus played a key role in initiating the intraoceanic subductions in equatorial Neo-Tethys, and the combined slab pull and plume induced rifting separated Greater India microcontinent from the northern margin of Indian subcontinent at ∼ 120 Ma. The impact of the Reunion plume resulted in the obduction of ITSZ ophiolites at the northern margin and the Pakistan ophiolites at the northwestern margin. The mantle plume impingements caused plate tilting and triggered the subduction/obduction that is well preserved by sharp inflexions in MMA and the spreading rates. We therefore infer that the three mantle plumes have a greater role in the subduction, obduction and tilting of the Indian plate throughout the Late Mesozoic.

geosciences, multidisciplinary
Double subduction controls on long-lived continental tectonics and subcontinental mantle temperatures

Lin-Sen Li,Fabio A. Capitanio,Peter A. Cawood,Ben-Jun Wu,Ming-Guo Zhai,Xiao-Lei Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1130/g52232.1

IF: 5.8

2024-08-19

Geology

Abstract:The complexities of convergent margins commonly include the interactions of subduction zones, with many geological records of “double” subduction. Here, we build two-dimensional numerical models to explore the evolution of complex subduction systems by systematically testing single and inward-dipping double subduction beneath a continental upper plate and the impact of continental collision on these systems. When compared to single subduction models, the inward-dipping double subduction shows hindered trench migrations and larger volumes of upwelling mantle enhanced by excess sinking slab mass. Double subduction draws larger volumes of hotter mantle beneath the continent in an area much broader than the marginal basins of single subductions, contributing to subcontinental heating by ∼200 °C. As collision jams one margin of a double subduction system, the other margin follows the evolution of migrating single subduction zones, although characterized by persisting higher mantle temperatures and strong upwellings, inherited from the double subduction stage, and large-scale upper plate extension. The modeling outcomes are compared to scaling arguments to test the viability of the mechanism proposed for tectonics of the Cenozoic South China Sea and Neoproterozoic Yangtze Block (southeastern China), where the inward-dipping double subduction provides a context for protracted large-scale continental extension, hotter subcontinental temperatures, and channeled mantle flow not easily reconciled with the dynamics of single subduction zones.

geology
India-Asia collision near the western syntaxis-constraints from paleomagnetism, seismic tomography and numerical modeling

Zhi-yu YI,Zhong-hai LI,Zhi-qin XU,Bao-chun HUANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.6038/pg20170413

2017-01-01

Abstract:The initial collision between India and Asia is a hot spot of geoscience.The western segment of the collision zone,involved in complicated continent-arc-continent collision,is hence a key for understanding the process and mechanism of continent-continent collision.In this study,a comprehensive analysis was applied to the available paleomagnetic data (including 6 primary and 35 secondary components) obtained from the area near the western syntaxis (including the western Lhasa-Karakorum,Kohistan-Ladakh and Himalaya terranes).The primary remanences of this compilation indicate that the Kohistan arc and the southern margin of Asia near the western syntaxis were originally located near the paleo-equator and about 14°N,respectively,and most probably represented the initial positions for the continent-arc and continent-continent collisions.Statistical analysis of paleolatitudes calculated from the secondary components defines 3 notable peaks at about 3 °S ～ 2 °N,12°N and 22°N,respectively.The former two peaks overlap the paleolatitudes defined by the primary components,implying that the overprints were possibly associated with the orogenic processes accompanied by the initial collisions.Former studies based on global seismic tomography distinguished two remanent oceanic slabs of the Neo-Tethys from the mantle beneath the India-Asia collision zone,the positions of which are proposed,by a primary numerical modeling designed in this study,to have roughly represented the paleopositions of the paleo-sutures of the continent-arc-continent collision.The inferred paleopositions of the paleo-sutures are also compatible with the ones inferred from paleomagnetic data.The above analysis consistently supports that the initial contacts between India-Kohistan-Asia should have occurred near the paleo-Equator and low latitude of the northern Hemisphere (about 14° N).Together with the trajectory of continent India since about 100 Ma and the assumption of different sizes of Greater India,the timing of initial contacts between India and Kohistan-Ladakh arc and Asia are estimated to be no later than about 62 Ma and about 48 Ma respectively.
Cenozoic India-Asia collision driven by mantle dragging the cratonic root

Yanchong Li,Lijun Liu,Sanzhong Li,Diandian Peng,Zebin Cao,Xinyu Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-51107-0

2024-08-06

Abstract:The driving force behind the Cenozoic India-Asia collision remains elusive. Using global-scale geodynamic modeling, we find that the continuous motion of the Indian plate is driven by a prominent upper-mantle flow pushing the thick Indian lithospheric root, originated from the northward rollover of the detached Neo-Tethyan slab and sinking slabs below East Asia. The maximum mantle drag occurs within the strong Indian lithosphere and is comparable in magnitude to that of slab pull (1013 N m-1). The thick cratonic root enhances both lithosphere-asthenosphere coupling and upper-plate compressional stress, thereby sustaining the topography of Tibetan Plateau. We show that the calculated resistant force from the India-Asia plate boundary is also close to that due to the gravitational potential energy of Tibetan Plateau. Here, we demonstrate that this mantle flow is key for the formation of the Tibetan Plateau and represents part of a hemispheric convergent flow pattern centered on central Asia.
How Do Pre-Existing Weak Zones and Rheological Layering of the Continental Lithosphere Influence the Development and Evolution of Intra-Continental Subduction?

Mengxue Liu,Dinghui Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jseaes.2022.105385

IF: 3

2022-01-01

Journal of Asian Earth Sciences

Abstract:Intra-continental subduction is of special importance for studying the formation of intra-continental orogens, crust-mantle structural evolution, and the far-field effects of continental collision, whose mechanism is still a matter of discussion. In this work, we investigated the role of pre-existing weak zones and the continental lithospheric rheological layering in the formation and evolution of the intra-continental subduction based on a 2D finite element numerical technique. The model results indicate that the deeper the intra-continental weak zone is and the faster the convergence velocity is, the more likely it is to develop into a new intra-continental subduction. Altering the rheological strength of the overriding plate may not have a substantial impact on the intra-continental subduction mode when the depth of the pre-existing weak zone is larger than half of the lithospheric thickness. In contrast, the lithospheric rheological strength is closely related to the continental collision system's deformation style: Models with a weaker overriding plate are inclined to delaminate continuously under collision, whereas a strong overriding plate results in the subducting plate's roll-back. The reactivation of the suture that runs deep into the lithosphere as a result of the Indian-Asian continental collision could be one of the crucial factors controlling the formation of the south-dipping subduction under the North Pamir.
The Timing of India-Asia Collision Onset – Facts, Theories, Controversies

Xiumian Hu,Eduardo Garzanti,Jiangang Wang,Wentao Huang,Wei An,Alex Webb

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2016.07.014

IF: 12.038

2016-01-01

Earth-Science Reviews

Abstract:The timing of initial collision between India and Asia has remained controversial for half a century. This paper attempts to review this crucial and hotly debated argument, describing first the different methods used to constrain the age of collision and discussing next the rationale, results, inferences and problems associated with each. We conclude that stratigraphy represents the best direct way to unravel collision chronology. Other methods focusing on the magmatic, metamorphic or paleomagnetic record provide additional fundamental constraints, but cannot provide a robust direct estimate of collision onset. Initial collision in the central-eastern Himalaya is dated directly at the middle Paleocene (59 ± 1 Ma) by the abrupt change in sediment provenance recorded in trench settings. The quasi-synchronous unconformities documented along both Tethyan passive margin of India and active margin of Asia from Tibet to Zanskar-Ladakh confirm that orogeny was underway at the close of the Paleocene (56 Ma), well before the disappearance of marine seaways in the Himalaya during the early-middle Eocene (50–45 Ma). Sedimentary evolution and provenance changes in marine to fluvio-deltaic successions are recorded synchronously within error from the western to the central-eastern Himalaya, failing to provide conclusive evidence for diachronous collision. These coherent observations are hard to reconcile with three widely cited hypotheses invoking either Paleogene arc-continent collision or Late Cretaceous ophiolite obduction, or the protracted existence of a Greater India Basin, which are all not favored after discussing the geological evidence critically point by point. A scenario no more complex than the one involving solely the passive continental margin of India and the active continental margin of Asia is needed to explain the geological evolution of the nascent Himalaya. The collision between the Tethys Himalaya and the Transhimalayan arc-trench system does represent the collision between India and Asia. Because the Yarlung Zangbo Ophiolite is the forearc basement of the Asian active margin, its obduction onto India could not have preceded the initial closure of Neo-Tethys. Ophiolite obduction began when collision began, in the middle Paleocene.

The convergence history of India-Eurasia records multiple subduction dynamics processes

India–Eurasia convergence speed-up by passive-margin sediment subduction

From Rodinia to Pangea: an Extroversion Process Driven First by Plume Push Followed by Downwelling Pull, Absorption and Merging

Triple-stage India-Asia collision involving arc-continent collision and subsequent two-stage continent-continent collision

Rapid Drift Of The Tethyan Himalaya Terrane Before Two-Stage India-Asia Collision

Microcontinent subduction and S-type volcanism prior to India–Asia collision

Two-stage eastward diachronous model of India-Eurasia collision: Constraints from the intraplate tectonic records in Northeast Indian Ocean

Dynamic evolution of competing same-dip double subduction: New perspectives of the Neo-Tethyan plate tectonics

Metamorphic densification can account for the missing felsic crust of the Greater Indian continent

The Mystery Deepens: Anomalously Fast Speed of the Indian Lithospheric Plate - A Review

India Indenting Eurasia: A Brief Review and New Data from the Yongping Basin on the SE Tibetan Plateau

Where is the missing felsic crust of Greater Indian continent?

Intermittent Post‐Paleocene Continental Collision in South Asia

Latest Cretaceous Himalayan Tectonics: Obduction, Collision or Deccan-Related Uplift?

Intraoceanic Subduction System Within the Neo‐Tethys: Evidence from Late Cretaceous Arc Magmatic Rocks of the Eastern Himalaya

Impact of Kerguelen, Marion, and Reunion plumes on the ophiolitic obduction at the northern margin of Indian plate

Double subduction controls on long-lived continental tectonics and subcontinental mantle temperatures

India-Asia collision near the western syntaxis-constraints from paleomagnetism, seismic tomography and numerical modeling

Cenozoic India-Asia collision driven by mantle dragging the cratonic root

How Do Pre-Existing Weak Zones and Rheological Layering of the Continental Lithosphere Influence the Development and Evolution of Intra-Continental Subduction?

The Timing of India-Asia Collision Onset – Facts, Theories, Controversies