An opt‐out model for kidney transplant referral: The time has come

Anne M. Huml,John R. Sedor,Emilio Poggio,Rachel E. Patzer,Jesse D. Schold

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ajt.16129

IF: 9.369

2020-07-05

American Journal of Transplantation

Abstract:Disparities that impact equity in access to kidney transplantation for patients with kidney failure have been well described. Many robust clinical trials have tested the effectiveness of interventions to reduce disparities and equilibrate access to kidney transplantation. Moreover, policy changes have been enacted to achieve the same aims. Despite these efforts, rates of kidney transplant wait listing within the first year of end‐stage kidney disease have remained unchanged over the past two decades, while incident rates of end‐stage kidney disease have climbed. Since prior interventions have not durably increased transplant access, disruptive change is clearly needed. The Advancing American Kidney Health Executive Order sets bold goals to transform kidney care for patients and caregivers. In this spirit, we discuss an Opt Out for Transplant Referral Model as a compelling solution to improve equity in access to kidney transplantation.

surgery,transplantation

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the significant inequality in the kidney transplantation process, especially for patients with End - Stage Kidney Disease (ESKD). Although there have been many clinical trials and policy reforms aimed at reducing these inequalities, in the past two decades, the proportion of patients who are placed on the kidney transplantation waiting list within the first year after being diagnosed with end - stage kidney disease has remained at about 15%, and this proportion is independent of the organ supply. In addition, although certain policy interventions, such as the change in the kidney allocation system in 2014 and the implementation of the Affordable Care Act, have increased the transplantation opportunities for minority patients, it is still uncertain whether these changes are sustainable. Therefore, this paper proposes an "opt - out" kidney transplantation referral model (Opt - Out Model for Kidney Transplant Referral) as a solution to improve the fairness of access to kidney transplantation.

Specifically, this model suggests that when a patient meets the basic eligibility criteria for kidney transplantation, he/she should be automatically referred to the transplantation center for evaluation, unless the patient clearly states that he/she is unwilling to undergo the transplantation operation. In this way, the number of referrals can be significantly increased, the differences in the judgment of whether patients are suitable for transplantation among providers can be reduced, and it also helps to reduce the existing time differences and actual referral differences related to transplantation. In addition, this model can also help to determine the actual number of patients who may benefit from transplantation and provide objective information on how many patients are evaluated and regarded as candidates. The paper believes that although this model may increase the workload of the transplantation center, these obstacles can be overcome by transparently defining the selection criteria of each transplantation center and using innovative technologies to optimize the referral process. Ultimately, the goal of this model is to reduce financial disadvantages, provide a smoother path for vulnerable groups, and alleviate the inequalities between those who are referred and those who are not.