Abstract:It has been widely assumed that there was a bubble in the U.S. housing market after 1999. This paper analyzes the extent to which that was true. We define a bubble as: (1) a regime shift that is characterized by a change in the properties of deviations from the fundamentals of house price growth, and (2) where a shock to the fundamental equation is more self sustaining and volatile than in other periods. We model the fundamentals of price growth as a lagged adjustment of prices to the expected present value of future rent. We then study the autoregressive behavior of the residuals thus generated. We look at changes in momentum (the extent to which a shock to house price growth leads to further increases in house price growth) of the residuals. Our results from 44 Metropolitan Statistical Areas for the period of 1980-2005 (quarterly data) are mixed. There is evidence of momentum in house price growth throughout the period, and momentum did increase after 1999, indicating a regime shift; but by a modest amount, and while momentum was sometimes strong it was not explosive. The regime shift was less apparent in the likely bubble candidate cities along the coasts, which had shown high growth in the past. The evidence on volatility is strong. In general, volatility did not increase in the nonbubble MSAs, and it decreased in the faster-growing bubble MSAs.

Business and Real Estate Price Cycles Across the U.S.: Evidence from a Vector Markov-Switching Regression Exercise

House Price Growth Synchronization and Business Cycle Alignment

Testing Business Cycle Theories: Evidence from the Great Recession

The Aggregate Implications of Regional Business Cycles

Housing Boom-Bust and Price-Rent Dynamics Over the Business Cycle

Price-rent dynamics , and business cycles

Identification of Business Cycles and the Great Moderation in the Post-War U.S. Economy

A Regime Shift Model of the Recent Housing Bubble in the United States

Housing Market Spillovers: Evidence from an Estimated DSGE Model

Liquidity Shocks and Real GDP Growth: Evidence from a Bayesian Time-Varying Parameter VAR

Residential Land Use Regulation and the Us Housing Price Cycle Between 2000 and 2009

Dependence structure between business cycles and CO2 emissions in the U.S.: Evidence from the time-varying Markov-Switching Copula models

Growth, cycles, and residential investment

House Prices and Job Losses

House Price, Interest Rate And Macroeconomic Fluctuation: Evidence From Shanghai Real Estate Market

On housing booms and credit market conditions : A state space model

Liquidity Premia, Price-Rent Dynamics, and Business Cycles

Systemic Risk and Spatiotemporal Dynamics of the US Housing Market

Leading indicators for US house prices: New Evidence and Implications for EU Financial Risk Managers

Bubbles in US regional house prices: evidence from house price–income ratios at the State level

Monetary policy and housing market cycles