Abstract:This paper examines the political embeddedness of public-sector primary care in urban India. The low quality of urban healthcare in many low- and middle-income countries is well documented. But there is relatively little analysis showing how the politics of urban healthcare delivery contribute to quality shortfalls. This study integrates urban and political theory and draws on ethnographic fieldwork in municipal government-run primary care clinics in Pune, India. I conceptualize Pune's municipal doctors as street-level bureaucrats: frontline state agents charged with delivering public services, who regularly confront conflicts between their mandate and its realization in practice. I observe how the municipal doctors experience and respond to these conflicts; delineate the historical design of the municipal institutions in which they operate; and interview doctors, nurses, nonclinical staff, administrators, and elected officials, who collectively shape primary care delivery in municipal clinics. My findings show how the doctors' work is characterized by routine departures from public service ideals. The departures stem from local electoral politics (politicians' patronage and clientelistic relations with municipal employees and patients) and weak administrative capacity (misuse and incompetent planning of public resources). The doctors are compelled to follow extra-policy directives, meaning instructions that have little to do with healthcare goals and that emphasize the political utility rather than medical purpose of their work. In response, the doctors circumscribe their clinical practice. They aim, as one doctor put it, only to "ensure the ordinary," or to sustain a deficient status quo. In these conditions, improving quality of care requires not just behavioral interventions targeted at doctors. It requires normative, social, and organizational shifts in public service planning and delivery so that doctors are positioned - materially and affectively - to meet urban healthcare challenges in low-resource contexts.

Paperwork, patronage, and citizenship: the materiality of everyday interactions with bureaucracy in Tamil Nadu, India

Paperwork as statecraft: documents, politics, and bureaucratic agency in street-level organisations

Paperwork performances

Ensuring the ordinary: Politics and public service in municipal primary care in India

Everyday practices of administrative ambiguation and the labour of de-ambiguation: Struggling for water infrastructure in Mumbai

The dichotomous world of sanitation management: ‘Matter out of place’ in Urban India

Management of Performance and Performance of Management: Getting to Work on Time in the Indian Bureaucracy

Producing dispossessed and humanitarian subjects: Land acquisition and compensation policies in Lahore, Pakistan

Phenomenology of the stop: street-level bureaucracy and everyday citizenship of marginalized groups

Studying health care institutions: Using paperwork as ethnographic research tools

Patronage and power in rural India: a study based on interaction networks

Clean bodies in school: spatial-material discourses of children’s school uniforms and hygiene in Tamil Nadu, India

Waiting for welfare: experiences of street traders from Delhi, India

Cross-border activities in everyday life: the Bengal borderland

Paradoxes of Intermediation in Aadhaar: Human Making of a Digital Infrastructure

The Street-Level Bureaucracy at the Intersection of Formal and Informal Water Provision

Voluntary Participation and Self-Governance: A Study of Community Health Volunteering in Kolkata, India

Negotiating urban entities: marginalized citizens, participation, and the Indian smart city

Governing through paperwork

Caste, mistrust and municipal inaction: The interwoven barriers for the integration of waste pickers in India

How frontline staff manage paperwork in group homes for people with intellectual disability: Implications for practice