A control oriented strategy of disruption prediction to avoid the configuration collapse of tokamak reactors
Andrea Murari,Riccardo Rossi,Teddy Craciunescu,Jesús Vega,Michela Gelfusa,J. Mailloux,N. Abid,K. Abraham,P. Abreu,O. Adabonyan,P. Adrich,V. Afanasev,M. Afzal,T. Ahlgren,L. Aho-Mantila,N. Aiba,M. Airila,M. Akhtar,R. Albanese,M. Alderson-Martin,D. Alegre,S. Aleiferis,A. Aleksa,A. G. Alekseev,E. Alessi,P. Aleynikov,J. Algualcil,M. Ali,M. Allinson,B. Alper,E. Alves,G. Ambrosino,R. Ambrosino,V. Amosov,E. Andersson Sundén,P. Andrew,B. M. Angelini,C. Angioni,I. Antoniou,L. C. Appel,C. Appelbee,S. Aria,M. Ariola,G. Artaserse,W. Arter,V. Artigues,N. Asakura,A. Ash,N. Ashikawa,V. Aslanyan,M. Astrain,O. Asztalos,D. Auld,F. Auriemma,Y. Austin,L. Avotina,E. Aymerich,A. Baciero,F. Bairaktaris,J. Balbin,L. Balbinot,I. Balboa,M. Balden,C. Balshaw,N. Balshaw,V. K. Bandaru,J. Banks,Yu. F. Baranov,C. Barcellona,A. Barnard,M. Barnard,R. Barnsley,A. Barth,M. Baruzzo,S. Barwell,M. Bassan,A. Batista,P. Batistoni,L. Baumane,B. Bauvir,L. Baylor,P. S. Beaumont,D. Beckett,A. Begolli,M. Beidler,N. Bekris,M. Beldishevski,E. Belli,F. Belli,É. Belonohy,M. Ben Yaala,J. Benayas,J. Bentley,H. Bergsåker,J. Bernardo,M. Bernert,M. Berry,L. Bertalot,H. Betar,M. Beurskens,S. Bickerton,B. Bieg,J. Bielecki,A. Bierwage,T. Biewer,R. Bilato,P. Bílková,G. Birkenmeier,H. Bishop,J. P. S. Bizarro,J. Blackburn,P. Blanchard,P. Blatchford,V. Bobkov,A. Boboc,P. Bohm,T. Bohm,I. Bolshakova,T. Bolzonella,N. Bonanomi,D. Bonfiglio,X. Bonnin,P. Bonofiglo,S. Boocock,A. Booth,J. Booth,D. Borba,D. Borodin,I. Borodkina,C. Boulbe,C. Bourdelle,M. Bowden,K. Boyd,I. Božičević Mihalić,S. C. Bradnam,V. Braic,L. Brandt,R. Bravanec,B. Breizman,A. Brett,S. Brezinsek,M. Brix,K. Bromley,B. Brown,D. Brunetti,R. Buckingham,M. Buckley,R. Budny,J. Buermans,H. Bufferand,P. Buratti,A. Burgess,A. Buscarino,A. Busse,D. Butcher,E. de la Cal,G. Calabrò,L. Calacci,R. Calado,Y. Camenen,G. Canal,B. Cannas,M. Cappelli,S. Carcangiu,P. Card,A. Cardinali,P. Carman,D. Carnevale,M. Carr,D. Carralero,L. Carraro,I. S. Carvalho,P. Carvalho,I. Casiraghi,F. J. Casson,C. Castaldo,J. P. Catalan,N. Catarino,F. Causa,M. Cavedon,M. Cecconello,C. D. Challis,B. Chamberlain,C. S. Chang,A. Chankin,B. Chapman,M. Chernyshova,A. Chiariello,P. Chmielewski,A. Chomiczewska,L. Chone,G. Ciraolo,D. Ciric,J. Citrin,Ł. Ciupinski,M. Clark,R. Clarkson,C. Clements,M. Cleverly,J. P. Coad,P. Coates,A. Cobalt,V. Coccorese,R. Coelho,J. W. Coenen,I. H. Coffey,A. Colangeli,L. Colas,C. Collins,J. Collins,S. Collins,D. Conka,S. Conroy,B. Conway,N. J. Conway,D. Coombs,P. Cooper,S. Cooper,C. Corradino,G. Corrigan,D. Coster,P. Cox,T. Craciunescu,S. Cramp,C. Crapper,D. Craven,R. Craven,M. Crialesi Esposito,G. Croci,D. Croft,A. Croitoru,K. Crombé,T. Cronin,N. Cruz,C. Crystal,G. Cseh,A. Cufar,A. Cullen,M. Curuia,T. Czarski,H. Dabirikhah,A. Dal Molin,E. Dale,P. Dalgliesh,S. Dalley,J. Dankowski,P. David,A. Davies,S. Davies,G. Davis,K. Dawson,S. Dawson,I. E. Day,M. De Bock,G. De Temmerman,G. De Tommasi,K. Deakin,J. Deane,R. Dejarnac,D. Del Sarto,E. Delabie,D. Del-Castillo-Negrete,A. Dempsey,R. O. Dendy,P. Devynck,A. Di Siena,C. Di Troia,T. Dickson,P. Dinca,T. Dittmar,J. Dobrashian,R. P. Doerner,A. J. H. Donné,S. Dorling,S. Dormido-Canto,D. Douai,S. Dowson,R. Doyle,M. Dreval,P. Drewelow,P. Drews,G. Drummond,Ph. Duckworth,H. Dudding,R. Dumont,P. Dumortier,D. Dunai,T. Dunatov,M. Dunne,I. Ďuran,F. Durodié,R. Dux,A. Dvornova,R. Eastham,J. Edwards,Th. Eich,A. Eichorn,N. Eidietis,A. Eksaeva,H. El Haroun,G. Ellwood,C. Elsmore,O. Embreus,S. Emery,G. Ericsson,B. Eriksson,F. Eriksson,J. Eriksson,L. G. Eriksson,S. Ertmer,S. Esquembri,A. L. Esquisabel,T. Estrada,G. Evans,S. Evans,E. Fable,D. Fagan,M. Faitsch,M. Falessi,A. Fanni,A. Farahani,I. Farquhar,A. Fasoli,B. Faugeras,S. Fazinić,F. Felici,R. Felton,A. Fernandes,H. Fernandes,J. Ferrand,D. R. Ferreira,J. Ferreira,G. Ferrò,J. Fessey,O. Ficker,A. R. Field,A. Figueiredo,J. Figueiredo,A. Fil,N. Fil,P. Finburg,D. Fiorucci,U. Fischer,G. Fishpool,L. Fittill,M. Fitzgerald,D. Flammini,J. Flanagan,K. Flinders,S. Foley,N. Fonnesu,M. Fontana,J. M. Fontdecaba,S. Forbes,A. Formisano,T. Fornal,L. Fortuna,E. Fortuna-Zalesna,M. Fortune,C. Fowler,E. Fransson,L. Frassinetti,M. Freisinger,R. Fresa,R. Fridström,D. Frigione,T. Fülöp,M. Furseman,V. Fusco,S. Futatani,D. Gadariya,K. Gál,D. Galassi,K. Gałązka,S. Galeani,D. Gallart,R. Galvão,Y. Gao,J. Garcia,M. García-Muñoz,M. Gardener,L. Garzotti,J. Gaspar,R. Gatto,P. Gaudio,D. Gear,T. Gebhart,S. Gee,M. Gelfusa,R. George,S. N. Gerasimov,G. Gervasini,M. Gethins,Z. Ghani,M. Gherendi,F. Ghezzi,J. C. Giacalone,L. Giacomelli,G. Giacometti,C. Gibson,K. J. Gibson,L. Gil,A. Gillgren,D. Gin,E. Giovannozzi,C. Giroud,R. Glen,S. Glöggler,J. Goff,P. Gohil,V. Goloborodko,R. Gomes,B. Gonçalves,M. Goniche,A. Goodyear,S. Gore,G. Gorini,T. Görler,N. Gotts,R. Goulding,E. Gow,B. Graham,J. P. Graves,H. Greuner,B. Grierson,J. Griffiths,S. Griph,D. Grist,W. Gromelski,M. Groth,R. Grove,M. Gruca,D. Guard,N. Gupta,C. Gurl,A. Gusarov,L. Hackett,S. Hacquin,R. Hager,L. Hägg,A. Hakola,M. Halitovs,S. Hall,S. A. Hall,S. Hallworth-Cook,C. J. Ham,D. Hamaguchi,M. Hamed,C. Hamlyn-Harris,K. Hammond,E. Harford,J. R. Harrison,D. Harting,Y. Hatano,D. R. Hatch,T. Haupt,J. Hawes,N. C. Hawkes,J. Hawkins,T. Hayashi,S. Hazael,S. Hazel,P. Heesterman,B. Heidbrink,W. Helou,O. Hemming,S. S. Henderson,R. B. Henriques,D. Hepple,J. Herfindal,G. Hermon,J. Hill,J. C. Hillesheim,K. Hizanidis,A. Hjalmarsson,A. Ho,J. Hobirk,O. Hoenen,C. Hogben,A. Hollingsworth,S. Hollis,E. Hollmann,M. Hölzl,B. Homan,M. Hook,D. Hopley,J. Horáček,D. Horsley,N. Horsten,A. Horton,L. D. Horton,L. Horvath,S. Hotchin,R. Howell,Z. Hu,A. Huber,V. Huber,T. Huddleston,G. T. A. Huijsmans,P. Huynh,A. Hynes,M. Iliasova,D. Imrie,M. Imríšek,J. Ingleby,P. Innocente,K. Insulander Björk,N. Isernia,I. Ivanova-Stanik,E. Ivings,S. Jablonski,S. Jachmich,T. Jackson,P. Jacquet,H. Järleblad,F. Jaulmes,J. Jenaro Rodriguez,I. Jepu,E. Joffrin,R. Johnson,T. Johnson,J. Johnston,C. Jones,G. Jones,L. Jones,N. Jones,T. Jones,A. Joyce,R. Juarez,M. Juvonen,P. Kalniņa,T. Kaltiaisenaho,J. Kaniewski,A. Kantor,A. Kappatou,J. Karhunen,D. Karkinsky,Yu Kashchuk,M. Kaufman,G. Kaveney,Ye. O. Kazakov,V. Kazantzidis,D. L. Keeling,R. Kelly,M. Kempenaars,C. Kennedy,D. Kennedy,J. Kent,K. Khan,E. Khilkevich,C. Kiefer,J. Kilpeläinen,C. Kim,Hyun-Tae Kim,S. H. Kim,D. B. King,R. King,D. Kinna,V. G. Kiptily,A. Kirjasuo,K. K. Kirov,A. Kirschner,T. kiviniemi,G. Kizane,M. Klas,C. Klepper,A. Klix,G. Kneale,M. Knight,P. Knight,R. Knights,S. Knipe,M. Knolker,S. Knott,M. Kocan,F. Köchl,I. Kodeli,Y. Kolesnichenko,Y. Kominis,M. Kong,V. Korovin,B. Kos,D. Kos,H. R. Koslowski,M. Kotschenreuther,M. Koubiti,E. Kowalska-Strzęciwilk,K. Koziol,A. Krasilnikov,V. Krasilnikov,M. Kresina,K. Krieger,N. Krishnan,A. Krivska,U. Kruezi,I. Książek,A. B. Kukushkin,H. Kumpulainen,T. Kurki-Suonio,H. Kurotaki,S. Kwak,O. J. Kwon,L. Laguardia,E. Lagzdina,A. Lahtinen,A. Laing,N. Lam,H. T. Lambertz,B. Lane,C. Lane,E. Lascas Neto,E. Łaszyńska,K. D. Lawson,A. Lazaros,E. Lazzaro,G. Learoyd,Chanyoung Lee,S. E. Lee,S. Leerink,T. Leeson,X. Lefebvre,H. J. Leggate,J. Lehmann,M. Lehnen,D. Leichtle,F. Leipold,I. Lengar,M. Lennholm,E. Leon Gutierrez,B. Lepiavko,J. Leppänen,E. Lerche,A. Lescinskis,J. Lewis,W. Leysen,L. Li,Y. Li,J. Likonen,Ch. Linsmeier,B. Lipschultz,X. Litaudon,E. Litherland-Smith,F. Liu,T. Loarer,A. Loarte,R. Lobel,B. Lomanowski,P. J. Lomas,J. M. López,R. Lorenzini,S. Loreti,U. Losada,V. P. Loschiavo,M. Loughlin,Z. Louka,J. Lovell,T. Lowe,C. Lowry,S. Lubbad,T. Luce,R. Lucock,A. Lukin,C. Luna,E. de la Luna,M. Lungaroni,C. P. Lungu,T. Lunt,V. Lutsenko,B. Lyons,A. Lyssoivan,M. Machielsen,E. Macusova,R. Mäenpää,C. F. Maggi,R. Maggiora,M. Magness,S. Mahesan,H. Maier,R. Maingi,K. Malinowski,P. Manas,P. Mantica,M. J. Mantsinen,J. Manyer,A. Manzanares,Ph. Maquet,G. Marceca,N. Marcenko,C. Marchetto,O. Marchuk,A. Mariani,G. Mariano,M. Marin,M. Marinelli,T. Markovič,D. Marocco,L. Marot,S. Marsden,J. Marsh,R. Marshall,L. Martellucci,A. Martin,A. J. Martin,R. Martone,S. Maruyama,M. Maslov,S. Masuzaki,S. Matejcik,M. Mattei,G. F. Matthews,D. Matveev,E. Matveeva,A. Mauriya,F. Maviglia,M. Mayer,M.-L. Mayoral,S. Mazzi,C. Mazzotta,R. McAdams,P. J. McCarthy,K. G. McClements,J. McClenaghan,P. McCullen,D. C. McDonald,D. McGuckin,D. McHugh,G. McIntyre,R. McKean,J. McKehon,B. McMillan,L. McNamee,A. McShee,A. Meakins,S. Medley,C. J. Meekes,K. Meghani,A. G. Meigs,G. Meisl,S. Meitner,S. Menmuir,K. Mergia,S. Merriman,Ph. Mertens,S. Meshchaninov,A. Messiaen,R. Michling,P. Middleton,D. Middleton-Gear,J. Mietelski,D. Milanesio,E. Milani,F. Militello,A. Militello Asp,J. Milnes,A. Milocco,G. Miloshevsky,C. Minghao,S. Minucci,I. Miron,M. Miyamoto,J. Mlynář,V. Moiseenko,P. Monaghan,I. Monakhov,T. Moody,S. Moon,R. Mooney,S. Moradi,J. Morales,R. B. Morales,S. Mordijck,L. Moreira,L. Morgan,F. Moro,J. Morris,K.-M. Morrison,L. Msero,D. Moulton,T. Mrowetz,T. Mundy,M. Muraglia,A. Murari,A. Muraro,N. Muthusonai,B. N’Konga,Yong-Su Na,F. Nabais,M. Naden,J. Naish,R. Naish,F. Napoli,E. Nardon,V. Naulin,M. F. F. Nave,I. Nedzelskiy,G. Nemtsev,V. Nesenevich,I. Nestoras,R. Neu,V. S. Neverov,S. Ng,M. Nicassio,A. H. Nielsen,D. Nina,D. Nishijima,C. Noble,C. R. Nobs,M. Nocente,D. Nodwell,K. Nordlund,H. Nordman,R. Normanton,J. M. Noterdaeme,S. Nowak,E. Nunn,H. Nyström,M. Oberparleiter,B. Obryk,J. O’Callaghan,T. Odupitan,H. J. C. Oliver,R. Olney,M. O’Mullane,J. Ongena,E. Organ,F. Orsitto,J. Orszagh,T. Osborne,R. Otin,T. Otsuka,A. Owen,Y. Oya,M. Oyaizu,R. Paccagnella,N. Pace,L. W. Packer,S. Paige,E. Pajuste,D. Palade,S. J. P. Pamela,N. Panadero,E. Panontin,A. Papadopoulos,G. Papp,P. Papp,V. V. Parail,C. Pardanaud,J. Parisi,F. Parra Diaz,A. Parsloe,M. Parsons,N. Parsons,M. Passeri,A. Patel,A. Pau,G. Pautasso,R. Pavlichenko,A. Pavone,E. Pawelec,C. Paz Soldan,A. Peacock,M. Pearce,E. Peluso,C. Penot,K. Pepperell,R. Pereira,T. Pereira,E. Perelli Cippo,P. Pereslavtsev,C. Perez von Thun,V. Pericoli,D. Perry,M. Peterka,P. Petersson,G. Petravich,N. Petrella,M. Peyman,M. Pillon,S. Pinches,G. Pintsuk,W. Pires de Sá,A. Pires dos Reis,C. Piron,L. Pionr,A. Pironti,R. Pitts,K. L. van de Plassche,N. Platt,V. Plyusnin,M. Podesta,G. Pokol,F. M. Poli,O. G. Pompilian,S. Popovichev,M. Poradziński,M. T. Porfiri,M. Porkolab,C. Porosnicu,M. Porton,G. Poulipoulis,I. Predebon,G. Prestopino,C. Price,D. Price,M. Price,D. Primetzhofer,P. Prior,G. Provatas,G. Pucella,P. Puglia,K. Purahoo,I. Pusztai,O. Putignano,T. Pütterich,A. Quercia,E. Rachlew,G. Radulescu,V. Radulovic,M. Rainford,P. Raj,G. Ralph,G. Ramogida,D. Rasmussen,J. J. Rasmussen,G. Rattá,S. Ratynskaia,M. Rebai,D. Réfy,R. Reichle,M. Reinke,D. Reiser,C. Reux,S. Reynolds,M. L. Richiusa,S. Richyal,D. Rigamonti,F. G. Rimini,J. Risner,M. Riva,J. Rivero-Rodriguez,C. M. Roach,R. Robins,S. Robinson,D. Robson,R. Rodionov,P. Rodrigues,M. Rodriguez Ramos,P. Rodriguez-Fernandez,F. Romanelli,M. Romanelli,S. Romanelli,J. Romazanov,R. Rossi,S. Rowe,D. Rowlands,M. Rubel,G. Rubinacci,G. Rubino,L. Ruchko,M. Ruiz,J. Ruiz Ruiz,C. Ruset,J. Rzadkiewicz,S. Saarelma,E. Safi,A. Sahlberg,M. Salewski,A. Salmi,R. Salmon,F. Salzedas,I. Sanders,D. Sandiford,B. Santos,A. Santucci,K. Särkimäki,R. Sarwar,I. Sarychev,O. Sauter,P. Sauwan,N. Scapin,F. Schluck,K. Schmid,S. Schmuck,M. Schneider,P. A. Schneider,D. Schwörer,G. Scott,M. Scott,D. Scraggs,S. Scully,M. Segato,Jaemin Seo,G. Sergienko,M. Sertoli,S. E. Sharapov,A. Shaw,H. Sheikh,U. Sheikh,A. Shepherd,A. Shevelev,P. Shigin,K. Shinohara,S. Shiraiwa,D. Shiraki,M. Short,G. Sias,S. A. Silburn,A. Silva,C. Silva,J. Silva,D. Silvagni,D. Simfukwe,J. Simpson,D. Sinclair,S. K. Sipilä,A. C. C. Sips,P. Sirén,A. Sirinelli,H. Sjöstrand,N. Skinner,J. Slater,N. Smith,P. Smith,J. Snell,G. Snoep,L. Snoj,P. Snyder,S. Soare,E. R. Solano,V. Solokha,A. Somers,C. Sommariva,K. Soni,E. Sorokovoy,M. Sos,J. Sousa,C. Sozzi,S. Spagnolo,T. Spelzini,F. Spineanu,D. Spong,D. Sprada,S. Sridhar,C. Srinivasan,G. Stables,G. Staebler,I. Stamatelatos,Z. Stancar,P. Staniec,G. Stankūnas,M. Stead,E. Stefanikova,A. Stephen,J. Stephens,P. Stevenson,M. Stojanov,P. Strand,H. R. Strauss,S. Strikwerda,P. Ström,C. I. Stuart,W. Studholme,M. Subramani,E. Suchkov,S. Sumida,H. J. Sun,T. E. Susts,J. Svensson,J. Svoboda,R. Sweeney,D. Sytnykov,T. Szabolics,G. Szepesi,B. Tabia,T. Tadić,B. Tál,T. Tala,A. Tallargio,P. Tamain,H. Tan,K. Tanaka,W. Tang,M. Tardocchi,D. Taylor,A. S. Teimane,G. Telesca,N. Teplova,A. Teplukhina,D. Terentyev,A. Terra,D. Terranova,N. Terranova,D. Testa,E. Tholerus,J. Thomas,E. Thoren,A. Thorman,W. Tierens,R. A. Tinguely,A. Tipton,H. Todd,M. Tokitani,P. Tolias,M. Tomeš,A. Tookey,Y. Torikai,U. von Toussaint,P. Tsavalas,D. Tskhakaya,I. Turner,M. Turner,M. M. Turner,M. Turnyanskiy,G. Tvalashvili,S. Tyrrell,M. Tyshchenko,A. Uccello,V. Udintsev,G. Urbanczyk,A. Vadgama,D. Valcarcel,M. Valisa,P. Vallejos Olivares,O. Vallhagen,M. Valovič,D. Van Eester,J. Varje,S. Vartanian,T. Vasilopoulou,G. Vayakis,M. Vecsei,J. Vega,S. Ventre,G. Verdoolaege,C. Verona,G. Verona Rinati,E. Veshchev,N. Vianello,E. Viezzer,L. Vignitchouk,R. Vila,R. Villari,F. Villone,P. Vincenzi,I. Vinyar,B. Viola,A. J. Virtanen,A. Vitins,Z. Vizvary,G. Vlad,M. Vlad,P. Vondráček,P. de Vries,B. Wakeling,N. R. Walkden,M. Walker,R. Walker,M. Walsh,E. Wang,N. Wang,S. Warder,R. Warren,J. Waterhouse,C. Watts,T. Wauters,A. Weckmann,H. Wedderburn Maxwell,M. Weiland,H. Weisen,M. Weiszflog,P. Welch,N. Wendler,A. West,M. Wheatley,S. Wheeler,A. Whitehead,D. Whittaker,A. Widdowson,S. Wiesen,J. Wilkinson,J. C. Williams,D. Willoughby,I. Wilson,J. Wilson,T. Wilson,M. Wischmeier,P. Wise,G. Withenshaw,A. Withycombe,D. Witts,A. Wojcik-Gargula,E. Wolfrum,R. Wood,C. Woodley,R. Woodley,B. Woods,J. Wright,J. C. Wright,T. Xu,D. Yadikin,M. Yajima,Y. Yakovenko,Y. Yang,W. Yanling,V. Yanovskiy,I. Young,R. Young,R. J. Zabolockis,J. Zacks,R. Zagorski,F. S. Zaitsev,L. Zakharov,A. Zarins,D. Zarzoso Fernandez,K. -D. Zastrow,Y. Zayachuk,M. Zerbini,W. Zhang,Y. Zhou,M. Zlobinski,A. Zocco,A. Zohar,V. Zoita,S. Zoletnik,V. K. Zotta,I. Zoulias,W. Zwingmann,I. Zychor,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-46242-7
IF: 16.6
2024-03-18
Nature Communications
Abstract:Abstract The objective of thermonuclear fusion consists of producing electricity from the coalescence of light nuclei in high temperature plasmas. The most promising route to fusion envisages the confinement of such plasmas with magnetic fields, whose most studied configuration is the tokamak. Disruptions are catastrophic collapses affecting all tokamak devices and one of the main potential showstoppers on the route to a commercial reactor. In this work we report how, deploying innovative analysis methods on thousands of JET experiments covering the isotopic compositions from hydrogen to full tritium and including the major D-T campaign, the nature of the various forms of collapse is investigated in all phases of the discharges. An original approach to proximity detection has been developed, which allows determining both the probability of and the time interval remaining before an incoming disruption, with adaptive, from scratch, real time compatible techniques. The results indicate that physics based prediction and control tools can be developed, to deploy realistic strategies of disruption avoidance and prevention, meeting the requirements of the next generation of devices.
multidisciplinary sciences