Common Business Group Affiliation and Media Bias

Yi Ru,Fei Xie,Jian Xue

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3655874

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Using a novel dataset that allows the identification of newspapers and publicly traded firms affiliated with the same business group via equity ownership, we examine whether common business group affiliation affects the quality of media reporting on firms. We find that newspapers connected to firms display a more positive reporting tone than unconnected newspapers. This result is robust to both a DiD approach and controlling for newspaper-firm pair fixed effects. We also find that there is a weaker association between connected newspapers’ reporting tone and firm stock returns. Further analyses reveal that the optimism bias is stronger when the affiliated business group has more investment at stake in the publicly traded firm and more power to influence the newspaper and when the firm can benefit more from positive media coverage. Finally, we show that connected newspapers play a weaker information intermediary role, as their reporting tone has less predictive power for future firm performance and adverse corporate events, and firms with connected newspapers exhibit higher stock return synchronicity. Overall, our evidence suggests that media-firm connections via common business group affiliation undermine the media’s independence and objectivity.