Computational model‐based design of molten salt electrorefining process for high‐purity zirconium metal recovery from spent nuclear fuel

Sungjune Sohn,Sungyeol Choi,Jaeyeong Park,Il Soon Hwang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/er.5724

IF: 4.6

2020-08-06

International Journal of Energy Research

Abstract:<p>Effective decontamination methods for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) cladding are required to recycle Zr, which is a valuable resource, by separating high purity Zr from the actinides. In this study, computational modeling is performed on an electrorefiner to achieve high‐purity Zr metal recovery without ZrCl and U from SNF Zircaloy‐4 cladding utilizing a commercial fluid dynamics code. A three‐dimensional (3D) electrorefining model specialized in simulation of multistep electrochemical reduction (eg, two‐step reduction of Zr(IV) to Zr via ZrCl) is developed by coupling the numerical models of the Butler‐Volmer equation and fluid dynamics. This model is validated by benchmarking the chemical formula of cathode deposits obtained from lab‐scale electrorefining experiments utilizing fresh Zircaloy‐4. The computational results are consistent with the compositions of Zr and ZrCl in the cathode deposits, depending on the initial ZrCl₄ concentrations. Based on the developed 3D model, a pilot‐scale electrorefiner for the SNF cladding is simulated with several derived design parameters. The effects of rotating anode and cathode, potential range, molten salt weight, and the number of anode baskets are determined to optimize the electrorefiner design to achieve the suppression of ZrCl and U codeposition. The electrorefiner throughput when employing the optimized design and operating conditions is predicted to be 0.1 to 0.2 ton/y, as only pure Zr metal is recovered.</p>

energy & fuels,nuclear science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problem of recovering high - purity zirconium metal from spent fuel cladding. Specifically, the article aims to separate high - purity zirconium metal from Zircaloy - 4 cladding of Spent Nuclear Fuel (SNF) used in reactors through the molten - salt electro - refining process, while avoiding the co - deposition of zirconium chloride (ZrCl) and actinides (such as uranium U).

### Problem Background

1. **Recovery of Zirconium Resources in Spent Fuel Cladding**: Zircaloy - 4 cladding is used as a fuel cladding material in nuclear power plants and contains valuable zirconium resources. However, during the operation of the reactor, the cladding material will be contaminated by deeply - penetrating actinides, making it a medium - level radioactive waste.
2. **Requirement for an Efficient Decontamination Method**: In order to reduce the level of radioactive waste and recover valuable zirconium resources, an effective decontamination method is required to separate high - purity zirconium from the entire cladding material.

### Research Objectives

- **Develop a Computational Model**: Establish a three - dimensional electro - refining model through Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) software to simulate the multi - step electrochemical reduction process (for example, the gradual reduction of Zr(IV) to Zr through ZrCl) in order to achieve the recovery of high - purity zirconium metal.
- **Optimize the Electro - Refiner Design**: Through numerical simulation, study the effects of factors such as the rotating anode and cathode, potential range, molten - salt weight, and the number of anode baskets on the electro - refining effect, thereby optimizing the design parameters of the electro - refiner and suppressing the co - deposition of ZrCl and U.
- **Predict the Production Capacity of the Electro - Refiner**: Based on the optimized design and operating conditions, predict the annual output of the electro - refiner to ensure that only pure zirconium metal is recovered without the deposition of ZrCl and U.

### Key Technologies and Methods

- **Multi - step Electrochemical Reaction Model**: Combine the Butler - Volmer equation and the hydrodynamic model to establish a multi - step electrochemical reduction model for describing the gradual reduction process from Zr(IV) to Zr.
- **Experimental Verification**: Verify the validity of the numerical model through the results of laboratory - scale electro - refining experiments and determine the key material constants.
- **Parameter Optimization**: Through multiple simulation experiments, determine the optimal operating current range to ensure that only pure zirconium metal is deposited on the cathode.

### Formula Display

The formulas involved in the article are as follows:

1. **Molar Generation Rate and Current Density of ZrCl Formation Reaction**:
\[
m'_{\text{ZrCl}} = -\frac{i_{\text{ZrCl}}}{n_{\text{ZrCl}} F} = -k_{0,\text{ZrCl}} \left[ -C_{\text{Zr(IV)}}(0,t) \exp\left(-\frac{\alpha_{\text{ZrCl}} n_{\text{ZrCl}} F (E - E^0_{\text{ZrCl}})}{RT}\right) + \exp\left(\frac{(1 - \alpha_{\text{ZrCl}}) n_{\text{ZrCl}} F (E - E^0_{\text{ZrCl}})}{RT}\right) \right]
\]

2. **Molar Generation Rate and Current Density of Zr Metal Formation Reaction**:
\[
m'_{\text{Zr}} = \frac{i_{\text{Zr}}}{n_{\text{Zr}} F} = k_{0,\text{Zr}} \left[ -\exp\left(-\frac{\alpha_{\text{Zr}} n_{\text{Zr}} F (E - E^0_{\text{Zr}})}{RT}\right) + \exp\left(\frac{(1 - \alpha_{\text{Zr}}) n_{\text{Zr}} F (E - E^0_{\text{Zr}})}{RT}\right) \right]
\]

3. **Relationship between Diffusion Layer Thickness and Mass Transfer Rate**:
\[
J_{\text{Zr(IV)}}