Abstract:Acoustic communication plays a prominent role in various ecological and evolutionary processes involving social interactions. The properties of acoustic signals are thought to be influenced not only by the interaction between signaller and receiver but also by the acoustic characteristics of the environment through which the signal is transmitted. This conjecture forms the core of the so-called "acoustic adaptation hypothesis" (AAH), which posits that vegetation structure affects frequency and temporal parameters of acoustic signals emitted by a signaller as a function of their acoustic degradation properties. Specifically, animals in densely vegetated 'closed habitats' are expected to produce longer acoustic signals with lower repetition rates and lower frequencies (minimum, mean, maximum, and peak) compared to the ones inhabiting less vegetated 'open habitats'. To date, this hypothesis has received mixed results, with the level of support depending on the taxonomic group and the methodology used. We conducted a systematic literature search of empirical studies testing for an effect of vegetation structure on acoustic signalling and assessed the generality of the AAH using a meta-analytic approach based on 371 effect sizes from 75 studies and 57 taxa encompassing birds, mammals and amphibians. Overall, our results do not provide consistent support for the AAH, neither in within-species comparisons (suggesting no overall phenotypically plastic response of acoustic signalling to vegetation structure) nor in among-species comparisons (suggesting no overall evolutionary response). However, when considering birds only, we found a weak support for the AAH in within-species comparisons, which was mainly driven by studies that measured frequency bandwidth, suggesting that this variable may exhibit a phenotypically plastic response to vegetation structure. For among-species comparisons in birds, we also found support for the AAH, but this effect was not significant after excluding comparative studies that did not account for phylogenetic non-independence. Collectively, our synthesis does not support a universal role of vegetation structure in the evolution of acoustic communication. We highlight the need for more empirical work on currently under-studied taxa such as amphibians, mammals, and insects. Furthermore, we propose a framework for future research on the AAH. We specifically advocate for a more detailed and quantitative characterization of habitats to identify frequencies with the highest detection probability and to determine if frequencies with greater detection distances are preferentially used. Finally, we stress that empirical tests of the AAH should focus on signals which are selected for increased transmission distance.

Signalling adjustments to direct and indirect environmental effects on signal perception in meerkats

Signalling Behaviour is Influenced by Transient Social Context in a Spontaneously Ovulating Mammal

Flexible signalling strategies by victims mediate post-conflict interactions in bonobos

Spatial position relative to group members affects weight gain in meerkats (Suricata suricatta)

Territoriality, Social Bonds, and the Evolution of Communal Signaling in Birds

Vocal grooming in meerkats: weakly bonded subordinates call more in response to dominants

Inter-call intervals, but not call durations, adhere to Menzerath's Law in the submissive vocal bouts of meerkats

Multimodal communication and audience directedness in the greeting behaviour of semi-captive African savannah elephants

Behavioural responses of Diana monkeys to male long-distance calls: changes in ranging, association patterns and activity

Using social network analysis of mixed-species groups in African savannah herbivores to assess how community structure responds to environmental change

Context-dependent multimodal behaviour in a coral reef fish

Meta-analysis of the acoustic adaptation hypothesis reveals no support for the effect of vegetation structure on acoustic signalling across terrestrial vertebrates

Levels of Airborne Sound And Substrate-borne Vibration Calling Are Negatively Related Across Neotropical False-leaf Katydids

Rat ultrasonic vocalizations and novelty-induced social and non-social investigation behavior in a seminatural environment

Implications of target signal choice in passive acoustic monitoring: an example of age‐ and sex‐dependent vocal repertoire use in African forest elephants (Loxodonta cyclotis)

Dynamical coupling during collective animal motion

Dialogues in colour and behaviour - Integration of complex signalling traits and physiology

Urban sensory conditions alter rival interactions and mate choice in urban and forest túngara frogs

Investigating the impact of anthropogenic noise on the decision-making of dwarf mongoose offspring

The ecological benefits of interceptive eavesdropping

A sensory ecological perspective on mate sampling strategies: simulation models and an empirical test