Abstract:The capacity to collect and analyse data is growing exponentially. Referred to as ‘Big Data’, this scientific, social and technological trend has helped create destabilising amounts of information, which can challenge accepted social and ethical norms. Big Data remains a fuzzy idea, emerging across social, scientific, and business contexts sometimes seemingly related only by the gigantic size of the datasets being considered. As is often the case with the cutting edge of scientific and technological progress, understanding of the ethical implications of Big Data lags behind. In order to bridge such a gap, this article systematically and comprehensively analyses academic literature concerning the ethical implications of Big Data, providing a watershed for future ethical investigations and regulations. Particular attention is paid to biomedical Big Data due to the inherent sensitivity of medical information. By means of a meta-analysis of the literature, a thematic narrative is provided to guide ethicists, data scientists, regulators and other stakeholders through what is already known or hypothesised about the ethical risks of this emerging and innovative phenomenon. Five key areas of concern are identified: (1) informed consent, (2) privacy (including anonymisation and data protection), (3) ownership, (4) epistemology and objectivity, and (5) ‘Big Data Divides’ created between those who have or lack the necessary resources to analyse increasingly large datasets. Critical gaps in the treatment of these themes are identified with suggestions for future research. Six additional areas of concern are then suggested which, although related have not yet attracted extensive debate in the existing literature. It is argued that they will require much closer scrutiny in the immediate future: (6) the dangers of ignoring group-level ethical harms; (7) the importance of epistemology in assessing the ethics of Big Data; (8) the changing nature of fiduciary relationships that become increasingly data saturated; (9) the need to distinguish between ‘academic’ and ‘commercial’ Big Data practices in terms of potential harm to data subjects; (10) future problems with ownership of intellectual property generated from analysis of aggregated datasets; and (11) the difficulty of providing meaningful access rights to individual data subjects that lack necessary resources. Considered together, these eleven themes provide a thorough critical framework to guide ethical assessment and governance of emerging Big Data practices.

Bringing up the bio-datafied child: scientific and ethical controversies over computational biology in education

The Geneticization of Education and Its Bioethical Implications

Implications of the genomic revolution for education research and policy

Ethical issues raised by new genomic technologies: the case study of newborn genome screening

Trends in ethical and legal frameworks for the use of human biobanks

Getting a head start: the importance of personal genetics education in high schools

Ethics and Privacy Considerations for Systems Biology Applications in Predictive and Personalized Medicine

The Ethics of Big Data: Current and Foreseeable Issues in Biomedical Contexts

The genetics revolution. Ethical, legal, and insurance concerns

Impact of Bio Commercial Technology on Modern Educational Technology Environment

Behind the scenes with genomics researchers

Making authentic science accessible—the benefits and challenges of integrating bioinformatics into a high-school science curriculum

Communicating Personal Genomic Information to Non-experts: A New Frontier for Human-Computer Interaction

The informed consent aftermath of the genetic revolution. An Italian example of implementation

Biological data sciences in genome research

How the role of computing is driving new genetics' public policy

The Ethics of Biomedical Big Data

Thinking about the idea of consent in data science genomics: How 'informed' is it?

Students' attitudes towards somatic genome editing versus genome editing of the germline using an example of familial leukemia

Privacy in the Genomic Era

Ethical Issues in Newborn Sequencing Research: The Case Study of BabySeq