Abstract:Unbalanced bidding describes an activity otherwise known as item price loading. It is a practice used to some extent by building contractors to determine the prices that they will allocate to the individual component items within a project. This practice takes advantage of the contractor’s opportunity to manipulate these prices without this affecting their overall bid price for a project. Three types of loading are described, namely those of “front-end loading,” “back-end loading,” and “quantity error exploitation” (otherwise known as “individual rate loading”). Several scientists have expressed an interest in this field, starting with Marvin Gates in 1959. All of these scientific endeavors have entailed the attempt by which to mathematically determine the optimum method of item pricing. These efforts are seen as potentially significant given that it has become recognized that this practice can contribute substantially to a contractor’s profit as well as their risk. It is therefore interesting to note that although some research has found that some forms of unbalanced bidding are being practiced, there is no published research known to the writers that describes any practical application of any of the mathematical models that have been advocated by the aforementioned scientific community. A critical assessment is made of all of the scientific contributions known to the writers that have been in this field. This critical assessment finds flaws with all of the existing scientific proposals. In particular it finds fault with the technique that is incorporated into many of them by which prices are bounded by arbitrary upper and lower limits that have no scientific basis. It also concludes that further research is required to test the practical efficacy of some of these academic models.

Comparative analysis of quantitative bidding methods using agent-based modelling

Competitive Bidding Strategy Model and Software System for Bid Preparation

Integration between different construction bidding models to improve profitability and reduce prices

A Multi-Agent System of Project Bidding Management Simulation

Auctions Versus Posted-Price Selling

A New Method for Construction Engineering Bidding Evaluation

Game Analysis of Reverse Multiple Attribute Electronic Bidding in Construction Markets for End Users

The Bidding Strategy of Bill of Quantities Based on Statistical Methods

Research on Game Model of Engineering Project Bidding Quotation under the Mode of Tender Control Price

Investigation of Bid Price Competition Measured through Prebid Project Estimates, Actual Bid Prices, and Number of Bidders

Review of Unbalanced Bidding Models in Construction

A survey of the bidding practices of Canadian civil engineering construction contractors

Unit-price-based model for evaluating competitive bids

State of the Art—Auctions and Bidding Models: A Survey

Constructing Demand-Side Bidding Curves Based on a Decoupled Full-Cycle Process

Selection of Bid Evaluation Method for Construction Project

Applying Friedman’s Bidding Model Towards Lowest-Bid Procurement Utilizing the Monte Carlo Simulation

Bidding Evaluation of Construction Engineering Using Extend Data Envelopment Analysis Method

Construction Engineering Bidding Risk Analysis

Game Analysis of Principal-Agent Relation in Evaluating Bids of Construction Project

A multi-space model for Chinese bids evaluation with analyzing