Conflict Assessment and Peacebuilding Planning: Toward a Participatory Approach to Human Security
Kai Chen
2014-01-01
Abstract:CONFLICT ASSESSMENT AND PEACEBUILDING PLANNING: TOWARD A PARTICIPATORY APPROACH TO HUMAN SECURITY Lisa Schirch Boulder, CO: Kumarian Press, 2013 229 pages, paper cover, $19.95.In the early 21st century, there is still a gap between intents and impacts of peacebuilding. Why do some well-intentioned peacebuilding projects produce unintended impacts? How can counterproductive effects of peacebuilding planning in the conflict-affected contexts be minimized? How can conflict assessment be made suitable for realities in the conflict areas? How can all the stakeholders be made to participate in peacebuilding? What should the stakeholders' planning peacebuilding do or not do? There is an urgent need to find answers to these questions.Based on twenty years of teaching and practice on conflict assessment and peacekeeping planning, Lisa Schirch's Conflict Assessment and Peacebuilding Planning develops an alternative framework for self-assessment, conflict assessment, theories of change, design, monitoring, and evaluation to achieve better peacebuilding practice in the conflict areas around the world. In addition, this alternative framework aims at reducing the chance for negative second and third-order effects that are counterproductive to goals of peace and security, which are caused by overconfidence, untested assumptions, and organizational interests in peacebuilding operations.This book features 13 chapters, which organize six thematic sections. Section 1 (chapters 1-2) describes the research purpose and methodologies of this book, addressing the challenges facing conflict assessment and peacebuilding. Section 2 (chapter 3) explains six categories of questions (i.e., Where, Who, Why, What, How, and When) in self-assessment. In the following pages (chapters 4-10) Schirch uses this categorization schema to analyze her framework of conflict assessment.Section 4 (chapter 11 ) focuses on theories of change for peacebuilding. A theory of change has two layers of meaning: first, it is a theory about driving and mitigating factors of a conflict; second, it is about how driving or mitigating factors could be changed to prevent conflict or rebuild peace. In Schirch's opinion, a theory of change should have three components: factors (conflict assessment), actions (type of peacebuilding effort), and impacts (peacebuilding effects) (p.167).In the next section (chapter 12), Schirch turns to stressing the essential models and conceptual models for peacebuilding planning, such as reaching more people with geographic and demographic replication, connecting personal with structural change strategies, increasing connectors, and decreasing dividers (pp.180-188). The final section (chapter 13) highlights the scope, dimensions and strategies of monitoring and evaluation of peacebuilding efforts.Distinguished with many works on conflict assessment and peacebuilding, Schirch considers that conflict assessment is to map and describe all the different perceptions of diverse stakeholders, rather than exploring the truth about a conflict (p. …