Abstract:The apparent eroding in the hegemonic power of the United States and the sustained growth of China has triggered debate as to whether the rise of China will be peaceful or conflictual. Structural realism posits that the world is characterised by the anarchic ordering principle in which there is no central authority sitting above the states. Therefore, the absence of a “leviathan” on the international system automatically makes every state equal on the system which created an atmosphere of competition for the maximisation of power for survival. On a similar line of reasoning, the Power Transition theory as a variant theory within realism postulates that when the international system is structured based on the principle of hierarchy, peace will reign. It means that when international relations are regulated and influenced by a dominant power, the international system becomes stable. But the emergence of a dissatisfied powerful nation to challenge the hegemon usually ends up in war. Based on this assumption, Power Transition theorists argued that the rise of China to rival the dominance of the United States could not be peaceful. The Power Transition theory has influenced many academics to have the belief that the two nations will end up in “Thucydides’ Trap”. This belief has aggravated the matter beyond the reasonable level and has instilled panic in the mind of foreign policymakers which could jeopardise world peace and international cooperation. Hence, this paper aims to critically evaluate the deficiency of the Power Transition theory in the 21st century in explaining the current United States-China relations and the prospect of peace or war between the two nations using process tracing. Accordingly, in this paper, it is argued that in the 21st century, an armed confrontation between the United States and China is highly unlikely. Because in today’s world, nations (including the United States and China) are intertwined by the forces of globalisation which created inexorable economic interdependence. Additionally, there is rapid advancement in military technology and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction which came with the concept of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD). Consequently, there is a need to revisit the Power Transition theory to accommodate contemporary factors. The inclusion of the current variables into the Theory will make it applicable and adequately fit in the discourse of international relations and global politics of the 21st-century international system.

Great Power Competition: Lessons from the Past, Implications for the Future

The United States in a World of Great Power Competition

Technology, power, and uncontrolled great power strategic competition between China and the United States

The Roots of Great Power Competition: an Analysis Based on the Increasing Returns Mechanism

Narratives, Knowledge Objects, and the Making of Great Power Competition

Temporal Theory and US-China Relations

Southeast Asia amid Sino-US Competition: Power Shift and Regional Order Transition

The Crowe Memorandum, the Rebalance to Asia, and Sino-US Relations

Introduction: Can America and China Escape the Thucydides Trap?

Balance of power, balance of alignment, and China's role in the regional order transition

It’s not a cold war: competition and cooperation in US–China relations

Defining China–US Strategic Competition: Partisan Realignment and the Domestic Political Logic of Change in American Strategy Toward China, 2009–2020

Historical Insights of Global Power Transitions: Implications on US-China Relations

THE DECLINING HEGEMONY OF THE UNITED STATES AND THE GROWING INFLUENCE OF CHINA: A CRITICAL PERSPECTIVE ON POWER TRANSITION THEORY IN THE 21ST CENTURY

Chinese perspectives on the US-China rivalry: navigating geo-economic and technological tensions in a new era of global statism

Decoding US–China Strategic Competition: Comparative Leverages and Issue Selection

Uncertainty, Cooperation and US-China Relations:A Survey Experiment on Conflictual Possibilities Between Great Powers

International Organizations and Sino-U.S. Strategic Competition: Evolution,Dynamics, and Implications Chinese Full Text

The “managed competition” concept in the US–China security nexus. Theoretical analysis and practical implementation

Sino-American-Russian Competition and Cooperation in Central Asia: Through the Optics of Game Theory

Sino-US Competition in the South China Sea: Power, Rules and Legitimacy