Abstract:Discrepancies in trade statistics can be normal or benign and attributed to a wide variety of unintentional factors, or in some instances within the timber products sector, such discrepancies can be associated with “systemic” factors that distort trade statistics, including (i) measurement and shipment issues, (ii) misreporting of product volumes, (iii) misclassification of timber product types, and (iv) government regulations concerned about trade. This study measured trade discrepancies in logs and lumber trade statistics for China and its trading partner countries from 2002 to 2018 using a time-lagged function, based on the customs data available from Global Trade Information Services (GTIS), with the aim of exploring a more nuanced understanding of trade discrepancies and their “systemic” factors. The results showed that the range of overall discrepancies in logs and lumber trade statistics shrunk over time, from [−0.069, 1.207] in 2002–2007 to [−0.120, 0.408] in 2013–2018. The larger trade flows of logs and lumber from Russia, New Zealand, and the U.S. (each above 10% of total China’s import) showed small trade statistics discrepancy ratios, which were less than ± 0.06. However, trade discrepancies still remained large at the disaggregated level, and significant differences of trade discrepancies between tropical and non-tropical countries. The range of trade discrepancies in hardwood logs increased from 2002 to 2018 and appeared to be attributed to misclassification and misreporting in tropical countries such as Indonesia, the Philippines, Thailand, and Ghana. However, these countries’ trade flows are becoming relatively minor over time. Government policies are suggested to play an important role in influencing both the occurrence and resolution of trade discrepancies.

Softwood lumber trade and trade restrictions: gravity model.

Trade Effects of Transnational Timber Legality Assurance Regimes: Evidence from the Lacey Act Amendment on China’s Forest Product Exports

Impacts of Trade Liberalization on Chinese Economy with Belt and Road Initiative

Wood Trade Responses to Ecological Rehabilitation Program: Evidence from China's New Logging Ban in Natural Forests

'Two roads diverged in [soft]wood' - Targeted Dumping, Differential Pricing Methodology, and Zeroing: US-Canada Anti-dumping in Softwood Lumber

Sustainable Timber Trade: A Study on Discrepancies in Chinese Logs and Lumber Trade Statistics

Determinants of Vietnam’s wood products trade: application of the gravity model

Border Effect Of China-Us Agricultural Trade Based On The Gravity Model

Trade Restrictiveness and Deadweight Loss in China'S Imports

Trade Destruction and Deflection Effects of US‐China Trade Frictions on China’s Tariff‐targeted Products

The US State-Level Wood Product-Based Bilateral Trade Balances with Canada Under the Protectionist US Trade Policy, COVID-19, and Economic Policy Uncertainty

Incidence of Russian Log Export Tax: A Vertical Log-Lumber Model

The Structural Gravity Model and Its Implications on Global Forest Product Trade

The Trade Effect of the U.S. Antidumping against China: an Empirical Analysis Based on Wooden Bedroom Furniture

The Economic Impact of SPS Measures on Agricultural Exports to China: An Empirical Analysis Using the PPML Method

Regional Price Dynamics and Countervailing Duties: Did the Canada-U.S. Hog/Pork Dispute Have a Permanent Impact?

Country Risk and Wooden Furniture Export Trade: Evidence from China

Analyzing Bilateral Trade Barriers under Global Trade Context: A Gravity Model Adjusted Trade Intensity Index Approach

The impact of interstate soft conflicts on bilateral trade flows using structural gravity model

The Impact of TBT and SPS Measures on Japanese and Korean Exports to China

TBT and SPS impacts on Korean exports to China: empirical analysis using the PPML method