Abstract:Objective: To compare the differences in estimated food, energy, and nutrient intakes between the consecutive 3 days 24-hour dietary recall(24HR)(referred to as the 3-day method) and consecutive 2 days 24HR(referred to as the 2-day method) to provide a basis for the use of consecutive 2 days 24HR in China nutrition surveillance. Methods: Using objective sampling to select participants in northern and southern provinces, dietary data were obtained through consecutive 3 days 24HR, and the average intakes of food, energy and nutrients were calculated for three days from Thursday to Saturday and two days on Friday and Saturday, respectively. The 3-day method was considered as the reference standard method to evaluate the performance of the 2-day method for estimating food, energy and nutrient intakes. Results: Among 778 participants aged 18-60 years in urban and rural areas of two provinces, the errors of the mean and median of 2-day method for estimating the intake of four major food categories less than 6% compared with the 3-day method, and there were significant equivalencies(P<0.025) and no significant differences in four major food categories group(P>0.05). Of the 24 food groups estimated by the 2-day method, 17 had mean errors within 5%, the largest error was in animal offal(13.45%) and the smallest in fruit(0.15%), and there were significant equivalencies(P<0.025) and no significant differences in seven food groups(P>0.05). For energy and nutrients, the mean and median errors of energy were less than 0.5% and there were significant equivalencies(P<0.025) and no significant differences for energy(P>0.05). Among the 25 nutrients, except sodium, iodine and vitamin E, the mean and median errors of the other 22 nutrients were less than 5%, and there were significant equivalencies(P<0.025) and no significant differences in 16 nutrients(P>0.05). Conclusion: There was little difference between the two survey method in assessing the intake of high consumption frequency foods, energy and most nutrients at group level, the 2-day method can be used as an alternative to the 3-day method to collect dietary intake data with high consumption rates in the population.

Comparison of Energy Values on Composition-based Method and Conventional Method

Investigation of Amino Acid and Fatty Acid Profiles of Japanese Diets Using the Food Exchange Lists for Diabetes Diet

Identification and estimation of the intake of fermented foods and their contribution to energy and nutrients among Japanese adults

Validity of the intake of sugars, amino acids, and fatty acids estimated using a self-administered food frequency questionnaire in middle-aged and elderly Japanese: the Japan Public Health Center-based Prospective Study for the Next Generation (JPHC-NEXT) Protocol Area

A NEW METHOD TO EVALUATE THE NUTRITIONAL VALUE OF FOODS WITH NUTRITION EQUIVALENT UNIT

Reliability Of Repeated Measures Of Nutrient Intake By Diet Records In Residents In The Western Region Of Japan

A Study on the Compatibility of a Food-Recording Application with Questionnaire-Based Methods in Healthy Japanese Individuals

Validity of a Web-Based 24-Hour Dietary Recall of Energy and Nutrient Intakes in Japanese Adults

[Comparison study of food, energy and nutrient intake by 24-hour dietary recall method on two consecutive days versus three consecutive days]

[Comparison of Assessment of Food Intakes by Using 3 Dietary Survey Methods].

Validity of a Dietary Questionnaire Assessed by Comparison with Multiple Weighed Dietary Records or 24-Hour Recalls.

Seasonal variation in the intake of food groups and nutrients in Japan: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Comparison of Difference Method and Enzyme-hydrolyzed Casein Method for Determining True Amino Acids Digestibility and Endogenous Amino Acids Losses of Drakes

Nutrient Profiling of Japanese Dishes: The Development of a Novel Ajinomoto Group Nutrient Profiling System

Comparison among Methods of Effective Energy Evaluation of Corn Silage for Beef Cattle

Validity of dietary assessment methods compared with doubly labeled water in children: A systematic review and meta‐analysis

The current status and issues of Japanese dietary habits: From the results of National Health and Nutrition Survey Japan

Content Analysis of Main Nutrients of Recipe Used in Study of Protein Physiological Requirement

Development of a Nutrient Profiling Model for Processed Foods in Japan

Comparisons of Amino Acid Availability by Different Methods and Metabolizable Energy Determination of a Chinese Variety of High Oil Corn1

Comparison between the sodium chloride content and labeled salt value of industrially prepared Japanese single dishes