Abstract:The armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine has brought the issue of protecting cultural property to the forefront. Numerous documented cases of illegal exports of cultural property from Ukrainian museums located in territories occupied by the aggressor country have emerged. In addition, little is known about the number of stolen objects from private collections, which are considered cultural artifacts. There are no statistics available on this matter. This paper aims to explore the problem of applicable law during the consideration of disputes regarding the protection of cultural property. The author examines the concept of cultural property restitution in private international law and different approaches and concepts for defining "restitution" and "return" of cultural values. It has been argued that the term “return of cultural property” should encompass a wider scope, including both the restitution of illegally exported cultural property and the return of cultural property that was legally in the possession of another state but was later repatriated to the original state as a gesture of goodwill. The author offers his definitions of these terms based on theoretical research, as well as an analysis of the domestic legislation of Ukraine and the UNIDROIT Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Property of June 24, 1995. The paper also delves into the issues of conflict regulation of disputes involving cultural values. Both the issues of determining the right of ownership to and the problems associated with the protection of the right of ownership of cultural property in private international law are considered. The point of view that the conflict of laws rule lex originis (the law of the country from whose territory the cultural property was exported) should be applied in disputes regarding the return of cultural property from someone else's illegal possession is supported. The author concludes, based on a comparative analysis of laws on private international law, about the most appropriate mechanism for protecting the property rights of a bona fide purchaser in disputes over cultural property.

NAGPRA and Commodification of Cultural Property: A Legal Mechanism to Prevent Its Transfer to Europe and Return to the Native Nations

Return and restitution of cultural property in the wake of the 1970 Convention

Decolonizing collections: A legal perspective on the restitution of cultural artifacts

Reviewing the experience with the repatriation of sacred ceremonial objects: A comparative legal analysis of Canada and South Africa

THE RIGHT TO RESTITUTION OF CULTURAL PROPERTY REMOVED AS SPOILS OF WAR DURING THE NINETEENTH-CENTURY INTERNATIONAL WARFARE

Cultural Property Protection in Private International Law

Protecting Cultural Objects: Enforcing the Illicit Export of Foreign Cultural Objects

Restitution of African Cultural Heritage: Revisiting Natural Law Concepts of Statehood and Property in the Context of Colonial Spoliation

Nationalism versus Internationalism in International Law in the Field of Cultural Relics Recovery

Restitution of cultural property: the rise and fall of a cosmopolitan ideal

The Problem of International Private Law in the Pursuit of Cultural Relics Overseas

RETURN OF THE CULTURAL OBJECTS UNDER INTERNATIONAL LAW, EUROPEAN UNION LAW, AND LITHUANIAN LAW

Part V Regional Approaches, Ch.40 North American Cultural Heritage Law

Art, Cultural Heritage and the Market: Legal and Ethical Issues

Toward Repatriation of Human Remains as a Postcolonial Museum Practice

Heritage Trouble: Recent Work on the Protection of Intangible Cultural Property

Ready for Restitution? Meeting Challenges of Colonial Legacies in Africa's Collections

The Reform of Italian Law on Cultural Property Export and Its Implications for the “Definitional Debate”: Closing the Gap with the European Union Approach or Cosmetics? Some Systemic Considerations from a Criminal Law Perspective

Enhancing the mobility of collections and access to cultural heritage: immunity of cultural objects from seizure in Poland

Cultural Property and Culture Theory

Restitution of stolen cultural properties: Lessons and challenges from recent Korean cases