Double-edged effects of work-related technology use after hours on employee well-being and recovery: The role of appraisal and its determinants

Kathrin Reinke,Sandra Ohly
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2397002221995797
2021-02-24
Abstract:Research suggests that work-related use of information and communication technologies (ICTs) after hours involves both harms and benefits for employee well-being. Yet, these findings are mainly based on examining the extent of ICT use as the focal construct of interest. Based on cognitive appraisal theories of stress, we argue that research needs to include individuals’ evaluation of their work-related ICT use after hours as well as the conditions shaping this appraisal to explain double-edged effects of ICT use on well-being. Thus, we investigate (1) how situational and personal factors influence whether work-related ICT use after hours is evaluated as positive or negative, and (2) how these factors and ICT use appraisal relate to employee well-being and recovery, beyond the extent of ICT use. We collected data in a daily diary study over five consecutive days. Multilevel path analyses with data from 51 employees and 151 daily observations indicated that goal progress and autonomous motivation for ICT use were positively related to positive ICT use appraisal. Besides, goal progress predicted less and overload predicted more negative ICT use appraisal. In turn, ICT use appraisal was associated with employees’ affective states and psychological detachment in the evening, beyond the extent of ICT use. Additionally, we found several indirect effects of goal progress and overload on employee well-being and recovery via ICT use appraisal. Our findings emphasize the need to investigate ICT usage experiences to explain the double-edged consequences of work-related ICT use after hours on employee well-being.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: the dual impact of using work - related information and communication technology (ICT) outside of working hours on employees' well - being and recovery. Specifically, the research aims to explore the following two issues: 1. **How do situational and personal factors influence employees' evaluation of using ICT after work**: that is, how these factors determine whether employees view ICT use after work as a positive or negative experience. 2. **How do these factors and employees' evaluation of ICT use influence their daily well - being**: that is, how these factors and evaluations are related to employees' emotional states and psychological detachment. ### Research Background Recent years' research has shown that using work - related ICT after work may bring both negative impacts (such as reducing psychological detachment and increasing work - life conflict) and positive impacts (such as enhancing autonomy and flexibility). However, most research mainly focuses on the frequency or duration of ICT use, ignoring the specific evaluation of this use experience by individuals and its influencing conditions. ### Theoretical Framework This research is based on the Cognitive Appraisal Theory, which believes that an individual's response to a certain stimulus (such as using ICT after work) depends on their subjective evaluation of this stimulus. According to this theory, an individual first assesses the relevance of the stimulus to their well - being (primary evaluation), and then assesses whether they have the ability to deal with this stimulus (secondary evaluation). Therefore, an individual's evaluation of ICT use after work may be dynamically changing and is influenced by situational and personal factors. ### Research Objectives In order to more comprehensively understand the dual impact of using ICT after work on employees' well - being, this research proposes the following hypotheses: - **Hypothesis 1**: Daily work - related ICT use goal progress is positively correlated with positive evaluation and negatively correlated with negative evaluation. - **Hypothesis 2**: Daily work - related ICT use overload is negatively correlated with positive evaluation and positively correlated with negative evaluation. - **Hypothesis 3**: Autonomous motivation is positively correlated with positive evaluation and negatively correlated with negative evaluation. - **Hypothesis 4**: Controlled motivation is negatively correlated with positive evaluation and positively correlated with negative evaluation. - **Hypothesis 5**: Daily positive evaluation is positively correlated with positive affect and psychological detachment, and negatively correlated with negative affect. - **Hypothesis 6**: Daily negative evaluation is negatively correlated with positive affect, positively correlated with negative affect, and negatively correlated with psychological detachment. ### Method The research adopted a five - day diary study method and collected data from 51 knowledge workers, with a total of 151 daily observation points. Through multi - level path analysis, the above hypotheses were verified. ### Conclusion The research shows that an individual's evaluation of ICT use after work is indeed influenced by situational and personal factors, and this evaluation further influences employees' emotional states and psychological detachment. Therefore, the research emphasizes the importance of considering individual use experiences when exploring the impact of ICT use after work on employees' well - being.