A multi-laboratory benchmark study of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) using Ca2+ and Mg2+ binding to EDTA
Adrian Velazquez-Campoy,Bárbara Claro,Olga Abian,Jonas Höring,Louis Bourlon,Rafael Claveria-Gimeno,Eric Ennifar,Patrick England,Jonathan Brad Chaires,Di Wu,Grzegorz Piszczek,Chad Brautigam,Shih-Chia Tso,Huaying Zhao,Peter Schuck,Sandro Keller,Margarida Bastos
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00249-021-01523-7
2021-04-16
European Biophysics Journal
Abstract:A small-scale ITC benchmarking study was performed involving 9 biophysics laboratories/facilities, to evaluate inter-laboratory and intra-laboratory basal levels of uncertainty. Our prime goal was to assess a number of important factors that can influence both the data gathered by this technique and the thermodynamic parameter values derived therefrom. In its first part, the study involved 5 laboratories and 13 different instruments, working with centrally prepared samples and the same experimental protocol. The second part involved 4 additional laboratories and 6 more instruments, where the users prepared their own samples according to provided instructions and did the experiments following the same protocol as in the first part. The study design comprised: (1) selecting a minimal set of laboratories; (2) providing very stable samples; (3) providing samples not requiring preparation or manipulation; and (4) providing a well-defined and detailed experimental protocol. Thus, we were able to assess: (i) the variability due to instrument and data analysis performed by each user on centrally prepared samples; (ii) the comparability of data retrieved when using 4 different software packages to analyze the same data, besides the data analysis carried out by the different users on their own experimental results; and (iii) the variability due to local sample preparation (second part of the study). Individual values, as well as averages and standard deviations for the binding parameters for EDTA-cation interaction, were used as metrics for comparing the equilibrium association constant (log<i>K</i>), enthalpy of interaction (Δ<i>H</i>), and the so-called "stoichiometry" (<i>n</i>), a concentration-correction factor.