Foreign–local microdialect discrimination in a songbird, the black redstart
Tifany Volle,Sébastien Derégnaucourt,Rémi Chambon,Tudor-Ion Draganoiu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2024.01.020
IF: 3.041
2024-04-01
Animal Behaviour
Abstract:Dialects have been described as geographical variations of vocal signals in several taxa such as humans, cetaceans, bats and birds. Many playback studies have focused on dialect perception by territorial birds, mainly reporting a stronger aggressiveness towards local dialects in comparison to foreign ones. However, exploration of the influence of several methodological factors is lacking, and very few studies have focused on species displaying microdialects (covering distances under 2km). We investigated these issues in a migratory population of a territorial songbird, the black redstart, Phoenicurus ochruros. In this species only males sing to defend their territories, and their distribution leads to several small groups of neighbours with a relatively high level of song sharing within each group. Using a playback experiment, we tested whether males were able to discriminate between the local and a foreign microdialect, while testing for the effects of their age class, the initial distance to the speaker, the relative acoustic similarity between the playback songs and songs of the tested birds and the order of the stimuli. We broadcast two acoustic stimuli (foreign and local microdialect) from unfamiliar individuals to 26 territorial males, during two breeding seasons. In line with our predictions, males showed a stronger response towards the local microdialect, spending more time in proximity to the speaker, in agreement with the escalation chain of aggression. Our results conformed to the previously reported trend in wide-spanning dialect species. We also showed that both the vocal response and the approach behaviours were influenced by the distance of tested males from the speaker at the beginning of the experiment. Males that were further from the sound source tended to sing rather than approach. More studies are needed to get a better understanding of discrimination abilities and their functions in microdialect species.
zoology,behavioral sciences