Abstract:Coastal shorelines are a key interface between terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems and are vital for human livelihood. As a result, shorelines have experienced substantial human modifications worldwide. Shoreline "hardening" – the construction of armor including seawalls, bulkheads, or rip-rap – is a common modification that has substantial negative ecological effects. Currently, restoration involving the removal of armor and replacement with "living" shorelines is becoming an established practice. Still, the ecological response to armor removal is oftentimes unpredictable and site-specific. We hypothesized that the confluence of larger-scale geophysical features might strongly influence ecological restoration outcomes at particular locations. To measure the effectiveness of armor removal in the context of broad-scale geophysical features across the Salish Sea, WA, USA, we studied 26 paired restored and natural reference beaches of the same shoretype (feeder bluff, accretion shoreform, or pocket beach), as well as corresponding fetch, sub-basin, and percent of shoreline sediment drift cell armored. Sites were restored for an average of six years. We gauged restoration effectiveness based on levels of five ecological response variables: beach wrack (percent, depth), logs (count, width), sediments (percent sand), vegetation (percent overhanging, count of fallen trees), and insects (density, taxa richness). We found that armor removal often restored these variables to natural levels, but that restoration response was dependent on geophysical features such as shoretype and fetch. Natural beaches did have higher measurements of overhanging vegetation, fallen trees, and insect taxa richness, as these features likely take time to mature at restored beaches. Feeder bluffs had a higher proportion of surface sand and number of fallen trees than other shoretypes, coinciding with the erosion of bluff material, whereas natural pocket beaches within bordering rocky headlands had higher insect densities. Sites with a large fetch had higher input of deposited wrack and logs, whereas sites with a small fetch had higher input from localized terrestrial sources – fallen trees and eroding sand. By incorporating the effectiveness of restoration with landscape features such as shoretype and fetch, we can more effectively plan for future restoration actions and better predict their outcomes.

A literature review of beach nourishment impacts on marine turtles

Examining the potential impacts of a coastal renourishment project on the presence and abundance of Escherichia coli

Beach nourishment response and recent morphological evolution of Minnesota Point, Lake Superior

An experimental study on the evolution of beach profiles under different beach nourishment methods

Surf zone hazards before and after a beach nourishment in Virginia, USA

Effects of Beach Nourishment Project on Coastal Geomorphology and Mangrove Dynamics in Southern Louisiana, USA

Historical Trends and Future Predictions

Artificial nesting habitats as a conservation strategy for turtle populations experiencing global change

Reef design and site hydrodynamics mediate oyster restoration and marsh stabilization outcomes

Characteristics of coastal dune topography and vegetation in environments recently modified using beach fill and vegetation plantings, Veneto, Italy

Nearshore placement of dredged material for estuarine shoreline restoration in Berkeley Township, New Jersey

Environmental Assessment of Xinhe Beach Development

Managing for Sandy Coastal Habitat in SW Florida: Institutional Complexities Hinder Local Agencies' Use of Best Practices

Beach Nourishment Protection against Storms for Contrasting Backshore Typologies

The effects of dune plant roots on loggerhead turtle (Caretta caretta) nest success

Coastal landforms and fetch influence shoreline restoration effectiveness

Artificial Reef Effect in relation to Offshore Renewable Energy Conversion: State of the Art

Using Artificial-Reef Knowledge to Enhance the Ecological Function of Offshore Wind Turbine Foundations: Implications for Fish Abundance and Diversity

Quantifying Wildlife and Navigation Benefits of a Dredging Beneficial‐Use Project in the Lower Atchafalaya River: A Demonstration of Engineering with Nature®

The Impact of Coastal Erosion and Shoreline Changes on Beach Leisure Activities: Evaluating the Importance of Maritime Police in Maintaining Public Safety

Multi-level assessment of ecological coastal restoration in South Texas