Abstract:Based on simulation results and theoretical analysis according to an atomistically informed continuum-scale model for the surface morphological response of tungsten plasma-facing component (PFC) in nuclear fusion devices, we demonstrate that the onset of the well-known surface nanostructure (known as “fuzz”) formation in PFC tungsten is the outcome of a stress-induced surface morphological instability. Specifically, we show that formation and growth of nanotendrils emanating from the exposed surface of PFC tungsten, a precursor to fuzz formation, is caused by a long-wavelength surface morphological instability triggered by compressive stress in the PFC near-surface layer due to over-pressurized helium (He) bubbles forming in this near-surface region through implantation of low-energy He ions from the plasma. Using linear stability theory (LST), we predict the onset of surface growth in response to low-amplitude perturbations from a planar PFC surface morphology and calculate the average spacing between nanotendrils growing from the PFC surface, in excellent agreement with self-consistent dynamical simulations of surface morphological response according to the fully nonlinear surface evolution model starting with random fluctuations from the planar surface morphology that result in nanoscale surface roughness. In addition, we examine the morphological response of the PFC surface to low-amplitude perturbations of very long wavelengths from its planar morphology and interpret fully the simulation results on the basis of a weakly nonlinear tip-splitting instability theory, which predicts a post-instability nanotendril pattern formation with nanotendril separation consistent with the LST predictions regardless of the initial surface perturbation. Finally, we compare our simulation predictions for surface nanotendril growth with experimental measurements of fuzz layer growth on the exposed surface of PFC tungsten. Our simulation results are in very good agreement with the surface growth measurements at the early stages of fuzz growth, further establishing the onset of fuzz formation in PFC tungsten as the outcome of a stress-driven PFC surface morphological instability.

Material migration in W and Mo during bubble growth and fuzz formation

Material mixing during fuzz formation in W and Mo

The dependence of tungsten fuzz layer thickness and porosity on tungsten deposition rate and helium ion fluence

Initial growth of tungsten fuzz induced by bubble-driven surface stress layer under helium irradiation

Temperature dependent study of helium retention in tungsten fuzz surfaces

Molecular dynamics simulation of bubble growth under surface of tungsten under helium irradiation

Tungsten ‘fuzz’ growth re-examined: the dependence on ion fluence in non-erosive and erosive helium plasma

A model of ballistic helium transport during helium-induced fuzz growth in tungsten

A review of late-stage tungsten fuzz growth

Effects of elastic softening and helium accumulation kinetics on surface morphological evolution of plasma-facing tungsten

Effect of Ta Addition on the Fuzz Formation of Additively Manufactured W-based Materials

Loop punching and bubble rupture causing surface roughening —A model for W fuzz growth

Onset of fuzz formation in plasma-facing tungsten as a surface morphological instability

An improved model for the prediction of He bubbles driven W fuzz growth at different temperatures

Fuzz Nanostructure and Erosion on Tungsten–vanadium Alloys Exposed to Helium Plasma in the STEP Linear Plasma Device

Changes in Dislocation Punching Behavior Due to Hydrogen-Seeded Helium Bubble Growth in Tungsten

Erosion dynamics of tungsten fuzz during ELM-like heat loading

He-ion induced surface morphology change and nanofuzz growth on hot tungsten surfaces

Tungsten fuzz: Deposition effects and influence to fusion devices

Molecular dynamics simulation analysis of the stress around an up-migrating helium bubble under tungsten surface and its bursting

Nanostructured fuzz growth on tungsten under low-energy and high-flux He irradiation