Abstract:Remote sensing products have been widely used in water resources assessment and management. However, the accuracy varies in different products. Water budget closure provides an important breakthrough for better assessing the uncertainties and quantifying error sources of satellite-based data products using water budget imbalance, especially in ungauged basins where conventional verification methods are not applicable. However, the commonly used assessment methods mainly refer to closure residual of water budget Delta Res or its proportion to corresponding mean precipitation (P) Delta Res/P, which have apparent limitations due to the dimensional effects in the former method and the high dependence on precipitation in the latter one. More critically, these two methods do not consider measured values (referring to in-situ values in gauged basins or average values of multiple satellite products in ungauged basins as in this study) as benchmarks of water budget components in the assessment of satellite-based hydrological data products, resulting in a wrong choice because the closure result is subject to the mutual cancellation in the errors of water budget components from different satellite-based products. This study proposes a novel error-based method to assess the accuracy of satellite-based hydrological data products for both gauged and ungauged basins based on water budget equation, measured values, and the omission error (OE) which is generally overlooked in existing studies. The method is applied to a typical closed basin, the Tarim River Basin (TRB) of China, to verify the applicability and reliability of the proposed method. Sixty combinations of water budget components from various satellite sources can be designed based on five precipitation (P) products, four evapotranspiration (ET) products and three terrestrial water storage change (TWSC) products. First order reliability method (FORM) is employed to assess the reliability of water budget closure results caused by the errors of satellite sources. The results indicated that different combinations produced different annual Delta Res and Delta Res/P, indicating great water budget closure errors for different combinations due to errors in different satellite sources. The OE error from satellite-based hydrological data products of water budget components clearly showed a greater impact on water budget imbalance than water budget components, indicating that OE error is important for understanding quality of satellite products. By comparing the results of Delta Res and Delta Res/P, it can be seen that our proposed method had great advantages in assessment of satellite products with a low dependence on P, and a better comparability between different combinations. The value of our assessment criterion ranges from 0 to 1 which is easier to understand in practice. The combinations of water budget components from TRMM_3B43 (P), GPM_3IMERGHH (P), GLDAS_NOAH025 (ET), and GRACE (TWSC) products show satisfactory water budget closure results in TRB using our proposed method. The proposed method provides a new aspect for assessing the accuracy of satellite-based hydrological data products especially in ungauged basins, which provides insights into water resources management in basins.

How realistic are water‐balance closure assumptions? A demonstration from the southern sierra critical zone observatory and kings river experimental watersheds

Estimation of Watershed Hydrologic Processes in Arid Conditions with a Modified Watershed Model

A New Method for Assessing Satellite-Based Hydrological Data Products Using Water Budget Closure

Assessing the Water Budget Closure Accuracy of Satellite/Reanalysis-Based Hydrological Data Products over Mainland China

A novel two‐step method for enforcing water budget closure and an intercomparison of budget closure correction methods based on satellite hydrological products

Assessing the steady‐state assumption in water balance calculation across global catchments

Toward a Closure of Catchment Mass Balance: Insight on the Missing Link From a Vegetated Lysimeter

Establishing a quantitative assessment methodology framework of water conservation based on the water balance method under spatiotemporal and different discontinuous ecosystem scales

Simulating River/Lake–Groundwater Exchanges in Arid River Basins: An Improvement Constrained by Lake Surface Area Dynamics and Evapotranspiration

Impacts of Topography‐Driven Water Redistribution on Terrestrial Water Storage Change in California Through Ecosystem Responses

The Water Balance Representation in Urban‐PLUMBER Land Surface Models

Neglecting hydrological errors can severely impact predictions of water resource system performance

Closing Loopholes in Water Rights Systems to Save Water: The Colorado River Basin

Assessing streamflow sensitivity to precipitation variability in karst‐influenced catchments with unclosed water balances

Bedrock Controls on Water and Energy Partitioning

Quantification of soil water balance components based on continuous soil moisture measurement and the Richards equation in an irrigated agricultural field of a desert oasis

Consequences of Incomplete Surface Energy Balance Closure for CO2 Fluxes from Open-Path CO2/H2O Infrared Gas Analysers

Isotopic evaluation of the National Water Model reveals missing agricultural irrigation contributions to streamflow across the western United States

A Proportionality-Based Multi-Scale Catchment Water Balance Model and Its Global Verification

Estimating Reservoir Inflow and Outflow from Water Level Observations Using Expert Knowledge: Dealing with An Ill‐Posed Water Balance Equation in Reservoir Management

The Influence of Groundwater Representation on Hydrological Simulation and Its Assessment Using Satellite‐based Water Storage Variation