Abstract:Stable isotopes (δ 18 O) and tritium ( 3 H) are frequently used as tracers in environmental sciences to estimate the age distributions of water. However, it has previously been argued that seasonally variable tracers, such as δ 18 O, generally and systematically fail to detect the tails of water age distributions and therefore substantially underestimate water ages as compared to radioactive tracers, such as 3 H. In this study for the Neckar river basin in central Europe and based on a >20-year record of hydrological, δ 18 O, and 3 H data, we systematically scrutinized the above postulate together with the potential role of spatial aggregation effects to exacerbate the underestimation of water ages. This was done by comparing water age distributions inferred from δ 18 O and 3 H with a total of 12 different model implementations, including lumped parameter sine-wave (SW) and convolution integral models (CO) as well as integrated hydrological models in combination with SAS-functions (IM-SAS). We found that, indeed, water ages inferred from δ 18 O with commonly used SW and CO models are with mean transit times (MTT) ~ 1–2 years substantially lower than those obtained from 3 H with the same models, reaching MTTs ~ 10 years. In contrast, several implementations of IM-SAS models did not only allow simultaneous representations of stream flow as well as δ 18 O and 3 H stream signals, but water ages inferred from δ 18 O with these models were with MTTs ~ 16 years much higher than those from SW and CO models and similar to those inferred from 3 H, which suggested MTTs ~ 15 years. Characterized by similar parameter posterior distributions, in particular for parameters that control water age, IM-SAS model implementations individually constrained with δ 18 O or 3 H observations, exhibited only limited differences in the magnitudes of water ages in different parts of the models as well as in the temporal variability of TTDs in response to changing wetness conditions. This suggests that both tracers lead to comparable descriptions of how water is routed through the system. These findings provide evidence that allowed us to reject the hypothesis that δ 18 O as a tracer generally and systematically "cannot see water older than about 4 years" and that it truncates the corresponding tails in water age distributions, leading to underestimations of water ages. Instead, our results provide evidence for a broad equivalence of δ 18 O and 3 H as age tracers for systems characterized by MTTs of at least 15–20 years. The question to which degree aggregation of spatial heterogeneity can further adversely affect estimates of water ages remains unresolved as the lumped and distributed implementations of the IM-SAS model provided inconclusive results. Overall, this study demonstrates that previously reported underestimations of water ages are most likely not a result of the use of δ 18 O or other seasonally variable tracers per se. Rather, these underestimations can be largely attributed to choices of model approaches and complexity not considering hydrological next to tracer aspects. Given the additional vulnerability of SW and CO model approaches in combination with δ 18 O to substantially underestimate water ages due to spatial aggregation and potentially other, still unknown effects, we, therefore, advocate to avoid the use of this model type in combination with seasonally variable tracers if possible, and to instead adopt SAS-based or comparable model formulations.

Isotopic evaluation of the National Water Model reveals missing agricultural irrigation contributions to streamflow across the western United States

Water isotopic composition traces source and dynamics of water supply in a semi‐arid agricultural landscape

Elevation and spatial structure explain most surface-water isotopic variation across five Pacific Coast basins

Patterns of local and nonlocal water resource use across the western U.S. determined via stable isotope intercomparisons

Using an Isotope Enabled Mass Balance to Evaluate Existing Land Surface Models

A WRF-Hydro-based retrospective simulation of water resources for US integrated water availability assessment

Neglect of Potential Seasonal Streamflow Forecasting Skill in the United States National Water Model

Stable hydrogen and oxygen isotopes of tap water reveal structure of the San Francisco Bay Area's water system and adjustments during a major drought

Improving the representation of stream water sources in surrogate nutrient models with water isotope data

The Value of Water Isotope Data on Improving Process Understanding in a Glacierized Catchment on the Tibetan Plateau

Assessing Retrospective National Water Model Streamflow with Respect to Droughts and Low Flows in the Colorado River Basin

Evaluating input data sources for isotope‐enabled rainfall‐runoff models

Advancing isotope‐enabled hydrological modelling for ungauged calibration of data‐scarce humid tropical catchments

Evaluation of Retrospective National Water Model Soil Moisture and Streamflow for Drought‐Monitoring Applications

Benchmarking high-resolution hydrologic model performance of long-term retrospective streamflow simulations in the contiguous United States

Towards the development of an isotope‐enabled rainfall‐runoff model: Improving the ability to capture hydrological and anthropogenic change

Characterizing Water Flow in Vegetated Lysimeters with Stable Water Isotopes and Modeling

Stable water isotopes and tritium tracers tell the same tale: No evidence for underestimation of catchment transit times inferred by stable isotopes in SAS function models

Process‐Based Intercomparison of Water Isotope‐Enabled Models and Reanalysis Nudging Effects

Towards hydrological model calibration and validation: simulation of stable water isotopes using the isoWATFLOOD model

The impact of evaporation fractionation on the inverse estimation of soil hydraulic and isotope transport parameters