Biomechanical study of metacarpal elastic intramedullary needle based on adult metacarpal morphological data for the treatment of metacarpal fractures
邓玖征,袁野,朱剑津,何大炜,赵喆,赵锋,孔德敬,潘勇卫
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1673-9450.2022.04.008
2022-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To explore the biomechanical properties of metacarpal elastic intramedullary needle designed based on adult metacarpal morphological data, and provide the basis for clinical application.Methods:The 2nd to 5th metacarpal bones were selected from 12 fresh frozen palm specimens of adults and the forty-eight metacarpal bones were divided into 3 groups: the plate fixation group, the K-wire fixation group, and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group according to the random number table method. Each group contained 16 metacarpal bones from the 2nd to 5th metacarpals, 8 of them were used for cantilever banding tests and 8 of them were used for torque tests. A simple transverse fracture model was made by making a transverse osteotomy with an osteotome at a distance of 20 mm from the distal end of the metacarpal bone. In the plate fixation group, the fracture was fixed with a four-holes locking plate, the fracture line as the center, and four 2.0 mm bicortical locking screws were used at the distal and proximal ends of the fracture line; in the K-wire fixation group, the fracture was fixed with 1.0 mm stainless steel Kirschner wire with the fracture line as the center for cross fixation; in the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group, the fracture was fixed with antegrade 2.0 mm metacarpal elastic intramedullary needle which was designed by author’s team, cooperated with the handle and pulp opener, and penetrated the medullary cavity antegradely from the base of the metacarpal bone, and then reached the subarticular surface of the metacarpal head through the fracture line for fixation. The biomechanical testing machine was used to test the cantilever bending and torsion of the three groups, and the maximum bending force, bending stiffness, maximum torque and torsion stiffness of the three groups were calculated. Data were compared with one-way ANOVA and SNK method.Results:(1) In the cantilever bending test, the maximum bending loads of the plate fixation group, the K-wire fixation group, and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group were (126.3±53.9), (48.7±18.2), (88.4±13.9) N, and the difference among the three groups was statistically significant (F=10.530, P=0.001); the difference between each two groups was statistically significant (P<0.05). The bending stiffnesses of the plate fixation group, the K-wire fixation group, and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group were (12.33±4.90), (5.86±5.02), (10.49±2.05) N/mm, and the difference among the three groups was statistically significant (F=4.988, P=0.017); the K-wire fixation group was different from the other two groups, the differences were statistically significant (P<0.05), and the difference between the plate fixation group and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group was not statistically significant (P>0.05). (2) In the torsion test, the maximum torques of the plate fixation group, the K-wire fixation group, and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group were (1.98±0.42), (0.61±0.39), (0.50±0.34) N·m, and the difference among the three groups was statistically significant (F=36.635, P<0.05); the differences between the plate fixation group and the other two groups were statistically significant (P<0.05), and there was no statistically significant difference between the K-wire fixation group and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group (P>0.05). The torsional stiffnesses of the plate fixation group, the K-wire fixation group, and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group were (0.093±0.040), (0.022±0.021), (0.032±0.029) N·m/°, and the difference among the three groups was statistically significant (F=12.554, P<0.05); the differences between the plate fixation group and the other two groups were statistically significant (P<0.05), and there was no statistically significant difference between the K-wire fixation group and the elastic intramedullary needle fixation group(P>0.05).Conclusions:The maximum bending load and bending stiffness of the elastic intramedullary needle that designed by author′s team based on the morphological data of adult metacarpal bones are less than plate, and significantly better than K-wire; while the maximum torsional moment and torsional stiffness of the elastic intramedullary needle are comparable to K-wire. The novel elastic intramedullary needle could meet the needs of early functional rehabilitation after internal fixation of metacarpal fractures.