Study the effects of mineral content on water diffusion mechanism and swelling characteristics in shale formations of Pakistan
Shaine Mohammadali Lalji,Syed Imran Ali,Rafiq Ahmed,Saud Hashmi,Zahoor Ul Hussain Awan,Yunus Jawed
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12517-022-10133-2
2022-04-26
Arabian Journal of Geosciences
Abstract:<p class="a-plus-plus">The chemical interaction between the shale formation and water-based drilling fluid has some profound influence on the wellbore stability. Formation swelling, disintegration, bit balling, or even abandonment of the wellbore are some severe consequences after this interaction. Hence, it is extremely important to understand the dynamics of the water molecules as it penetrates into the nano-platelets of the shale formation. At the macroscopic level, the diffusion of water molecules is primarily dependent on the size of the clay pore, while at the microscopic level, it is predominantly the function of the clay surfaces. Hence, during this study, three Pakistan shale formations, namely Ranikhot, Murree, and Talhar, were experimentally investigated in a linear dynamic swell-meter, and then the effects of mineral content on water diffusion mechanism were analyzed. As the weight (%) of clay minerals increases, the swelling tendency of these formations increases in the order of <span class="a-plus-plus inline-equation id-i-eq1"><span class="a-plus-plus equation-source format-t-e-x"><span class="mjpage"><svg xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="29.762ex" height="2.176ex" style="vertical-align: -0.338ex;" viewBox="0 -791.3 12814.1 936.9" role="img" focusable="false" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><g stroke="currentColor" fill="currentColor" stroke-width="0" transform="matrix(1 0 0 -1 0 0)"> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-52" x="0" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-61" x="736" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-6E" x="1237" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-69" x="1793" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-6B" x="2072" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-68" x="2600" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-6F" x="3157" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-74" x="3657" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-3E" x="4324" y="0"></use><g transform="translate(5381,0)"> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-4D" x="0" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-75" x="917" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-72" x="1474" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-72" x="1866" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-65" x="2259" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-65" x="2703" y="0"></use></g> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-3E" x="8806" y="0"></use><g transform="translate(9863,0)"> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-54" x="0" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-61" x="722" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-6C" x="1223" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-68" x="1501" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-61" x="2058" y="0"></use> <use xlink:href="#MJMAIN-72" x="2558" y="0"></use></g></g></svg></span></span></span>. Three diffusion models specifically; the Higuchi model, Peppas model, and Peppas and Sahlin model were then used to investigate the diffusion characteristics of the respective shale samples. It was found that the performance of all the diffusion models suffers substantially in Ranikhot formation, with the highest weight percentage of clay mineral. The models exhibit the transient state throughout the course of experimentation. However, Higuchi model was extremely useful during the transient state of this formation, but an over-estimation of the swelling % was observed during the equilibrium state. Overall in Ranikhot formation, Peppas model was consider the most efficient, with MAE values below 1 and smaller percentages of relative errors. On the other hand, in both Murree and Talhar formations, Peppas and Sahlin's model was the most efficient in terms of modeling the flow behavior and swelling (%), as the MAE value was below 0.5. All these formations exhibit a Fickian type diffusion mechanism with adjustable parameter "<em class="a-plus-plus">n</em>" < 0.5. However, the characteristics of Fickian behavior increase with a decrease in clay content.</p><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" style="display: none;"><defs id="MathJax_SVG_glyphs"><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-52" d="M130 622Q123 629 119 631T103 634T60 637H27V683H202H236H300Q376 683 417 677T500 648Q595 600 609 517Q610 512 610 501Q610 468 594 439T556 392T511 361T472 343L456 338Q459 335 467 332Q497 316 516 298T545 254T559 211T568 155T578 94Q588 46 602 31T640 16H645Q660 16 674 32T692 87Q692 98 696 101T712 105T728 103T732 90Q732 59 716 27T672 -16Q656 -22 630 -22Q481 -16 458 90Q456 101 456 163T449 246Q430 304 373 320L363 322L297 323H231V192L232 61Q238 51 249 49T301 46H334V0H323Q302 3 181 3Q59 3 38 0H27V46H60Q102 47 111 49T130 61V622ZM491 499V509Q491 527 490 539T481 570T462 601T424 623T362 636Q360 636 340 636T304 637H283Q238 637 234 628Q231 624 231 492V360H289Q390 360 434 378T489 456Q491 467 491 499Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-61" d="M137 305T115 305T78 320T63 359Q63 394 97 421T218 448Q291 448 336 416T396 340Q401 326 401 309T402 194V124Q402 76 407 58T428 40Q443 40 448 56T453 109V145H493V106Q492 66 490 59Q481 29 455 12T400 -6T353 12T329 54V58L327 55Q325 52 322 49T314 40T302 29T287 17T269 6T247 -2T221 -8T190 -11Q130 -11 82 20T34 107Q34 128 41 147T68 188T116 225T194 253T304 268H318V290Q318 324 312 340Q290 411 215 411Q197 411 181 410T156 406T148 403Q170 388 170 359Q170 334 154 320ZM126 106Q126 75 150 51T209 26Q247 26 276 49T315 109Q317 116 318 175Q318 233 317 233Q309 233 296 232T251 223T193 203T147 166T126 106Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-6E" d="M41 46H55Q94 46 102 60V68Q102 77 102 91T102 122T103 161T103 203Q103 234 103 269T102 328V351Q99 370 88 376T43 385H25V408Q25 431 27 431L37 432Q47 433 65 434T102 436Q119 437 138 438T167 441T178 442H181V402Q181 364 182 364T187 369T199 384T218 402T247 421T285 437Q305 442 336 442Q450 438 463 329Q464 322 464 190V104Q464 66 466 59T477 49Q498 46 526 46H542V0H534L510 1Q487 2 460 2T422 3Q319 3 310 0H302V46H318Q379 46 379 62Q380 64 380 200Q379 335 378 343Q372 371 358 385T334 402T308 404Q263 404 229 370Q202 343 195 315T187 232V168V108Q187 78 188 68T191 55T200 49Q221 46 249 46H265V0H257L234 1Q210 2 183 2T145 3Q42 3 33 0H25V46H41Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-69" d="M69 609Q69 637 87 653T131 669Q154 667 171 652T188 609Q188 579 171 564T129 549Q104 549 87 564T69 609ZM247 0Q232 3 143 3Q132 3 106 3T56 1L34 0H26V46H42Q70 46 91 49Q100 53 102 60T104 102V205V293Q104 345 102 359T88 378Q74 385 41 385H30V408Q30 431 32 431L42 432Q52 433 70 434T106 436Q123 437 142 438T171 441T182 442H185V62Q190 52 197 50T232 46H255V0H247Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-6B" d="M36 46H50Q89 46 97 60V68Q97 77 97 91T97 124T98 167T98 217T98 272T98 329Q98 366 98 407T98 482T98 542T97 586T97 603Q94 622 83 628T38 637H20V660Q20 683 22 683L32 684Q42 685 61 686T98 688Q115 689 135 690T165 693T176 694H179V463L180 233L240 287Q300 341 304 347Q310 356 310 364Q310 383 289 385H284V431H293Q308 428 412 428Q475 428 484 431H489V385H476Q407 380 360 341Q286 278 286 274Q286 273 349 181T420 79Q434 60 451 53T500 46H511V0H505Q496 3 418 3Q322 3 307 0H299V46H306Q330 48 330 65Q330 72 326 79Q323 84 276 153T228 222L176 176V120V84Q176 65 178 59T189 49Q210 46 238 46H254V0H246Q231 3 137 3T28 0H20V46H36Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-68" d="M41 46H55Q94 46 102 60V68Q102 77 102 91T102 124T102 167T103 217T103 272T103 329Q103 366 103 407T103 482T102 542T102 586T102 603Q99 622 88 628T43 637H25V660Q25 683 27 683L37 684Q47 685 66 686T103 688Q120 689 140 690T170 693T181 694H184V367Q244 442 328 442Q451 442 463 329Q464 322 464 190V104Q464 66 466 59T477 49Q498 46 526 46H542V0H534L510 1Q487 2 460 2T422 3Q319 3 310 0H302V46H318Q379 46 379 62Q380 64 380 200Q379 335 378 343Q372 371 358 385T334 402T308 404Q263 404 229 370Q202 343 195 315T187 232V168V108Q187 78 188 68T191 55T200 49Q221 46 249 46H265V0H257L234 1Q210 2 183 2T145 3Q42 3 33 0H25V46H41Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-6F" d="M28 214Q28 309 93 378T250 448Q340 448 405 380T471 215Q471 120 407 55T250 -10Q153 -10 91 57T28 214ZM250 30Q372 30 372 193V225V250Q372 272 371 288T364 326T348 362T317 390T268 410Q263 411 252 411Q222 411 195 399Q152 377 139 338T126 246V226Q126 130 145 91Q177 30 250 30Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-74" d="M27 422Q80 426 109 478T141 600V615H181V431H316V385H181V241Q182 116 182 100T189 68Q203 29 238 29Q282 29 292 100Q293 108 293 146V181H333V146V134Q333 57 291 17Q264 -10 221 -10Q187 -10 162 2T124 33T105 68T98 100Q97 107 97 248V385H18V422H27Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-3E" d="M84 520Q84 528 88 533T96 539L99 540Q106 540 253 471T544 334L687 265Q694 260 694 250T687 235Q685 233 395 96L107 -40H101Q83 -38 83 -20Q83 -19 83 -17Q82 -10 98 -1Q117 9 248 71Q326 108 378 132L626 250L378 368Q90 504 86 509Q84 513 84 520Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-4D" d="M132 622Q125 629 121 631T105 634T62 637H29V683H135Q221 683 232 682T249 675Q250 674 354 398L458 124L562 398Q666 674 668 675Q671 681 683 682T781 683H887V637H854Q814 636 803 634T785 622V61Q791 51 802 49T854 46H887V0H876Q855 3 736 3Q605 3 596 0H585V46H618Q660 47 669 49T688 61V347Q688 424 688 461T688 546T688 613L687 632Q454 14 450 7Q446 1 430 1T410 7Q409 9 292 316L176 624V606Q175 588 175 543T175 463T175 356L176 86Q187 50 261 46H278V0H269Q254 3 154 3Q52 3 37 0H29V46H46Q78 48 98 56T122 69T132 86V622Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-75" d="M383 58Q327 -10 256 -10H249Q124 -10 105 89Q104 96 103 226Q102 335 102 348T96 369Q86 385 36 385H25V408Q25 431 27 431L38 432Q48 433 67 434T105 436Q122 437 142 438T172 441T184 442H187V261Q188 77 190 64Q193 49 204 40Q224 26 264 26Q290 26 311 35T343 58T363 90T375 120T379 144Q379 145 379 161T380 201T380 248V315Q380 361 370 372T320 385H302V431Q304 431 378 436T457 442H464V264Q464 84 465 81Q468 61 479 55T524 46H542V0Q540 0 467 -5T390 -11H383V58Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-72" d="M36 46H50Q89 46 97 60V68Q97 77 97 91T98 122T98 161T98 203Q98 234 98 269T98 328L97 351Q94 370 83 376T38 385H20V408Q20 431 22 431L32 432Q42 433 60 434T96 436Q112 437 131 438T160 441T171 442H174V373Q213 441 271 441H277Q322 441 343 419T364 373Q364 352 351 337T313 322Q288 322 276 338T263 372Q263 381 265 388T270 400T273 405Q271 407 250 401Q234 393 226 386Q179 341 179 207V154Q179 141 179 127T179 101T180 81T180 66V61Q181 59 183 57T188 54T193 51T200 49T207 48T216 47T225 47T235 46T245 46H276V0H267Q249 3 140 3Q37 3 28 0H20V46H36Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-65" d="M28 218Q28 273 48 318T98 391T163 433T229 448Q282 448 320 430T378 380T406 316T415 245Q415 238 408 231H126V216Q126 68 226 36Q246 30 270 30Q312 30 342 62Q359 79 369 104L379 128Q382 131 395 131H398Q415 131 415 121Q415 117 412 108Q393 53 349 21T250 -11Q155 -11 92 58T28 218ZM333 275Q322 403 238 411H236Q228 411 220 410T195 402T166 381T143 340T127 274V267H333V275Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-54" d="M36 443Q37 448 46 558T55 671V677H666V671Q667 666 676 556T685 443V437H645V443Q645 445 642 478T631 544T610 593Q593 614 555 625Q534 630 478 630H451H443Q417 630 414 618Q413 616 413 339V63Q420 53 439 50T528 46H558V0H545L361 3Q186 1 177 0H164V46H194Q264 46 283 49T309 63V339V550Q309 620 304 625T271 630H244H224Q154 630 119 601Q101 585 93 554T81 486T76 443V437H36V443Z"></path><path stroke-width="1" id="MJMAIN-6C" d="M42 46H56Q95 46 103 60V68Q103 77 103 91T103 124T104 167T104 217T104 272T104 329Q104 366 104 407T104 482T104 542T103 586T103 603Q100 622 89 628T44 637H26V660Q26 683 28 683L38 684Q48 685 67 686T104 688Q121 689 141 690T171 693T182 694H185V379Q185 62 186 60Q190 52 198 49Q219 46 247 46H263V0H255L232 1Q209 2 183 2T145 3T107 3T57 1L34 0H26V46H42Z"></path></defs></svg>
geosciences, multidisciplinary