Abstract:DO ‘welfare states’ enhance or subvert economic enterprise, civic virtue, private moral character, the integrity of social life? Though these questions have a piquantly contemporary ring in modern British politics, they are nevertheless old quandaries in the history of social policy. Since the seventeenth century, if not earlier, practitioners, theorists and critics of public welfare schemes have argued for and against such schemes in contradictory and adversarial terms; claiming on the one hand that social welfare schemes would supply a humanitarian corrective to the rigours of a market economy; and on the other hand that they would support and streamline market forces by enhancing individual and collective efficiency. Similarly, for several hundred years models of civic morality which emphasize independence and self-sufficiency have jostled with alternative models which emphasize paternalism, altruism and organic solidarity. Few phases of social policy in Britain and elsewhere have not contained elements of more than one approach. Even the New Poor Law, notorious for its subordination to market pressures, nevertheless harboured certain residual anti-market principles and often lapsed into practices that were suspiciously communitarian; whilst Edwardian New Liberalism, famous for its philosophy of organic solidarism, in practice tempered social justice with the quest for ‘national efficiency’. These varying emphases have all been reflected in the fashions and phases of welfare state historiography—fashions and phases that appear to have been at least partly determined by the vagaries of prevailing political climate. Thus, in the aftermath of the Second World War, historians tended to portray the history of social policy as a series of governmental battles against private vested interests—battles in which the mantle of civic virtue was worn by an altruistic administrative elite, while civic vice was embodied in the motley crew of doctors, landlords, employers and insurance companies who viewed social welfare as a commodity in the market.

Britain: moving towards a work and opportunity‐focused welfare state?

New Labour, Old Functionalism: The Underlying Contradictions of Welfare Reform in the US and the UK

Employment Policies in UK and Germany. An Important Aspect of Welfare State: The Labour Market

Enterprise and Welfare States: a Comparative Perspective

Enterprise and the Welfare State: A Comparative Perspective

Twenty-first century social work: the influence of political context on public service provision in social work education and service delivery

Public Services Under New Labour: Back to Bureaucracy?

Business, skills and the welfare state: the political economy of employment-oriented family policy in Britain and Germany

New Labour’s overseas development aid policy – charity or self-interest?

The Managerial State: Power, Politics and Ideology in the Remaking of Social Welfare

Implementation of community care policy in the United Kingdom: will it be achieved?

The Politics of Postindustrial Social Policy

British Social Reform at the Start of the 20th Century with Its Influence

The welfare–work nexus in East Asia – a comparison of contexts, paths and directions

NEW MODES OF CONTROL IN THE PUBLIC SERVICE

The Maastricht Treaty's impact on the welfare state

The New Politics of the Welfare State

Include Us Out—Economic Development and Social Policy in the Creative Industries

Tropism of Pension System Reform:International Experience and Enlightenment

Pension Funds and the Politics of Ownership in Britain, c. 1970-86

From consumerism to partnership? Britain's National Health Service at the turn of the century