Abstract:The many issues managed care poses for providers and health networks are crystallized in the moral problems occasioned by its shifting of the financial risks of care from insurer to provider. The issues occasioned by market-based reform include: the problems presented by clashes between public expectations and payer restrictions; the corporatization of health service delivery and the cultural shift from humanitarian endeavor to business enterprise the depersonalization of treatment as time and money constraints stretch resources, and the culture rewards efficient "business-like" behavior the underfunding of care for the poor and uninsured, even as these populations grow the restructuring of care and reengineering of healthcare roles as the emphasis shifts from quality of care to conservation of resources rapid mergers of both health plans and institutional providers with all the inherent turmoil as rules change, services are eliminated, and support services are minimized to save money the unhealthy competition inherent in market-based reform that posits profit taking and market share as the measures of successful performance the undermining of the professional ethic of advocacy the use of incentives that pander to greed and self-interest. The costs of sophisticated technologies and the ongoing care of increasingly fragile patients have pulled many other elements into what previously were considered "privileged" professional interactions. The fact that very few citizens indeed could pay out-of-pocket for the treatment and ongoing care they might need led to social involvement (few people remember that both widespread health insurance and public programs are relatively recent phenomena--only about 30 years old). However, whether in tax dollars or insurance premiums, other people's money is being spent on the patient's care. Clearly, those "other people" never intended to give either the patient or the professional open-ended access to their collective pocketbooks. Just what form their involvement ought to take is being tested as "managed care" attempts to control the costs. What limits are acceptable to providers?: lower profit margins? quality controls? acceptable risk levels? To patients?: restricted choice? restricted mobility? restricted access to high tech? And to the general public?: decreased access to high tech? higher taxes? underserved populations? Abandonment of the sick or poor? Which "techniques" are acceptable, and which are not?: risk-sharing with providers? financial incentives for decision makers? rationing access? imposing behavioral parameters? The issues posed by market-based managed care cannot be adequately addressed merely in terms of social resources, nor will answers be found in subordinating human rights to practical materialism. Negotiating ethical guidelines for the "safe" handling of such problems to the good of individuals and of society requires a revitalization of the "old" values: the old commitment to master craftsmanship and altruism, the old emphasis on patient advocacy and human rights. However, these old values must be applied with the "new" knowledge of lifestyle choices (and thus personal responsibility), likely outcomes (and thus reasonable options), and the limits of success (and thus fair redeployment of health resources).

From consumerism to partnership? Britain's National Health Service at the turn of the century

Morality, consumerism and the internal market in health care

Towards a history of choice in UK health policy

Constructing health consumers: Private health insurance discourses in Australia and the United Kingdom

Managed competition, governmentality and institutional response in the United Kingdom

Post-Fordism and Welfare: An Analysis of Change in the British Health Sector

Housing the Citizen-Consumer in Post-war Britain: The Parker Morris Report, Affluence and the Even Briefer Life of Social Democracy

The Gospel of Wealth and the National Health: The Rockefeller Foundation and Social Medicine in Britain's NHS, 1945-60

Universal coverage and cost control: the United Kingdom National Health Service

Revolution or evolution: the challenges of conceptualizing patient and public involvement in a consumerist world

What is a 'National' 'Health' 'Service'? A keyword analysis of policy documents leading to the formation of the UK NHS

Reframing the public/private debate on healthcare services: Tracking boundaries in the National Health Service

RESTRUCTURING THE NHS AGAIN: SUPPLY SIDE REFORM IN RECENT ENGLISH HEALTH CARE POLICY

Embedded Liberalism and Health Populism in the UK in a Post-Truth Era

Employer-driven consumerism: integrating health into the business model

Assessing the new public management: the case of the National Health Service.

The British NHS at 75: Past, Contemporary, and Future Challenges

Users as Citizens: Collective Action and the Local Governance of Welfare

The impact of market-based 'reform' on cultural values in health care

Knit Your Own Without a Pattern: Health Promotion Specialists in an Internal Market

An economic analysis of the limits of market based reforms in the English NHS