Abstract:Background: Neurobiological measures have been associated with delinquent behaviour, but little is known about the predictive power of these measures for criminal recidivism and whether they have incremental value over and above demographic and behavioural measures. This study examined whether selected measures of autonomic functioning, functional neuroimaging and electroencephalography predict overall and serious recidivism in a sample of 127 delinquent young adults. Methods: We assessed demographics; education and intelligence; previous delinquency and drug use; behavioural traits, including aggression and psychopathy; and neurobiological measures, including heart rate, heart rate variability, functional brain activity during an inhibition task and 2 electroencephalographic measures of error-processing. We tested longitudinal associations with recidivism using Cox proportional hazard models and predictive power using C-indexes. Results: Past offences, long-term cannabis use and reactive aggression were strongly associated with recidivism, as were resting heart rate and error-processing. In the predictive model, demographics, past delinquency, drug use and behavioural traits had moderate predictive power for overall and for serious recidivism (C-index over 30 months [fraction of pairs in the data, where the higher observed survival time was correctly predicted]: C30 = 0.68 and 0.75, respectively). Neurobiological measures significantly improved predictive power (C30 = 0.72 for overall recidivism and C30 = 0.80 for serious recidivism). Limitations: Findings cannot be generalized to females, and follow-up was limited to 4 years. Conclusion: Demographic and behavioural characteristics longitudinally predicted recidivism in delinquent male young adults, and neurobiological measures improved the models. This led to good predictive function, particularly for serious recidivism. Importantly, the most feasible measures (autonomic functioning and electroencephalography) proved to be useful neurobiological predictors.

Predicting criminal recidivism: A comparison of neural network models with statistical methods

Predicting Criminal Recidivism with Support Vector Machine

Reducing race-based bias and increasing recidivism prediction accuracy by using past criminal history details

Accuracy, Fairness, and Interpretability of Machine Learning Criminal Recidivism Models

DeepOffense: a Recurrent Network Based Approach for Crime Prediction

Predicting Recidivism With Machine Learning: An Analysis of Risk Factors and Proposal of Preventions

Recidivism early warning model based on rough sets and the improved K-prototype clustering algorithm and a back propagation neural network

The limits of human predictions of recidivism

In Pursuit of Interpretable, Fair and Accurate Machine Learning for Criminal Recidivism Prediction

The Application of Machine Learning to a General Risk–Need Assessment Instrument in the Prediction of Criminal Recidivism

Achieving Fairness through Adversarial Learning: an Application to Recidivism Prediction

Can nonexperts really emulate statistical learning methods? A comment on “The accuracy, fairness, and limits of predicting recidivism”

Clarifying the relationship between mental illness and recidivism using machine learning: A retrospective study

Predicting Criminal Recidivism in Adult Male Offenders

Interpretable Classification Models for Recidivism Prediction

The limited value of machine learning approach to improving predictive performance: The Ministry of Justice Case Assessment Tool.

Fair-by-design explainable models for prediction of recidivism

The predictive value of neurobiological measures for recidivism in delinquent male young adults

Decision Tree Ensemble Approach for Recidivism Risk Classification Among Heinous Crime Convicts

A Comparative User Study of Human Predictions in Algorithm-Supported Recidivism Risk Assessment

Rethinking recidivism through a causal lens