Abstract:Background: Computer‐assisted instruction in medicine appears to facilitate learning, but it has not been compared prospectively to more traditional teaching methods. Purpose: To compare the efficacy of computer‐assisted instruction to a more traditional format in medical students’ acquisition of clinical acid‐base problem‐solving skills. Methods: 2nd‐year medical students at Northeastern Ohio Universities College of Medicine (N = 82) were randomized into 2 groups. Thirty‐seven received computer‐assisted instruction in acid‐base problem‐solving skills, and 45 were enrolled in a teacher‐supervised workshop. Preinstruction and postinstruction questionnaires, as well as a 25‐question test, were administered to all students. Results: Analysis of the preinstruction questionnaire demonstrated that the students’ preferred method of learning was the teacher supervised workshop (50%) followed by reading (39.5%). Fifty‐eight percent of the students did not use computers at all. Of the remaining 42%, average computer use was 5.9 days per month. At the end of the course, both groups felt equally prepared for the test. When asked, “If you had a choice to learn the material again, which would you choose: workshop, reading, or computer‐assisted instruction?”; 93% of the supervised‐workshop group chose the workshop, whereas 53% of the computer‐assisted instruction group chose computer‐assisted instruction (p < .001). No significant difference between the groups was demonstrated in performance on postinstruction recall questions. We did, however, find a significant difference favoring the workshop group in postinstruction problem‐solving skills (p = .04). Conclusions: Computer‐assisted instruction can be as effective as a teacher‐supervised workshop in transmitting clinical acid‐base knowledge skills to medical students. The students, however, do not appear inclined to rely solely on computer programs for learning and seem to benefit from teacher‐student interaction in learning problem‐solving skills.

Comparison of Different Commercial Wireless Keypad Systems

Wireless Keypads - A New Classroom Technology Using Enhanced Multiple-Choice Questions

Beyond Clickers, Next Generation Classroom Response Systems for Organic Chemistry

Making room for interactivity: using the cloud-based audience response system Nearpod to enhance engagement in lectures

A Comparative Study of Classroom Response Systems in China and Abroad

Using classroom communication systems to support interaction and discussion in large class settings

A brilliantly simple classroom response system

Effectiveness of keyboard-based English vocabulary practice application on vocational school students

Paperclickers: Affordable Solution for Classroom Response Systems

Socratic Dialogs and Clicker use in an Upper-Division Mechanics Course

Evaluation of interactive teaching for undergraduate medical students using a classroom interactive response system in India

Transforming student learning with classroom communication systems

The Effects of Clickers With Different Teaching Strategies

A Campus-Wide Investigation of Clicker Implementation: The Status of Peer Discussion in STEM Classes

Comparison of traditional and interactive teaching methods in a UK emergency department

A Kind of Smart Space for Remote Real-Time Interactive Learning Based on Pervasive Computing Mode

Peer Instruction: Comparing Clickers to Flashcards

Evidence for teaching practice: The impact of clickers in a large classroom environment

A Kind Of Pervasive Computing System For Future Remote Real-Time Interactive Learning

A comparison of interactive computerized medical education software with a more traditional teaching format

The PAD Class, a New Paradigm for University Classroom Teaching