New soil weathering index based on compositional data analyses of silt to sand sized parent mineral assemblages of terra rossa soils
Ivan Razum,Snježana Mikulčić Pavlaković,Vedran Rubinić,Goran Durn
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gexplo.2024.107513
IF: 4.166
2024-05-26
Journal of Geochemical Exploration
Abstract:Weathering indices are widely used in soil science and some other environmental disciplines for a variety of purposes (e. g. for soil classification, in soil formation studies, or in wider palaeoclimatic research). Two main categories of weathering indices have been developed: geochemical and mineralogical. In both cases, an approach is developed that takes into account the compositional nature of the geochemical data. To date, however, the most commonly used weathering indices are geochemical indices that do not consider the geochemical data as compositional. Although the compositional approach minimises possible statistical errors, the weathering indices developed in both approaches, i.e. the compositional and the classical, axiomatically assume two things that are inaccurate in some cases. First, that soil composition is invariant with respect to preferential translocation of clay sized particles, i.e. lessivage, and second, that the role of selective sorting of minerals during transport is neglected, which in extreme cases could mimic weathering. As a result, in some cases bulk analyses of mineralogical and geochemical content are an unreliable tool for determining soil weathering rates. To overcome these difficulties, this study proposes a new weathering index (W p-min ) based on the orthonormal log ratio (olr) transformation of quantitative mineral data derived from silt to sand sized allochthonous mineral assemblages. The size fraction used ensures that only the parent mineral assemblages, which are not prone to translocation, are analysed. In this paper, olr transformation is done using the concept of balances. This enabled the construction of variables, which essentially are various mineral log ratios, with the desired properties, i.e. transport invariance and sensitivity to selective dissolution. In this way, undesirable effects, i.e. selective sorting and lessivage, which ultimately affect bulk analyses, are avoided, allowing a more accurate estimation of weathering in the soil profiles studied. The new index was validated by comparison with the geochemical W index, which was modified by consulting the standardized variation matrix prior to element selection. Ultimately, compared to the geochemical index, the new index was better able to characterise weathering in soils where intense lessivage was detected. The study was conducted on terra rossa soils, which have common source, mostly of an aeolian origin.
geochemistry & geophysics